Global Blind Spot in Understanding Trigonometric Derivatives: A Multinational Analysis
Yossi Ben-Zion, Jianqiang Liu, Chun-Ming Wang, Atanu Rajak, Noah D. Finkelstein · 2025
Read Global Blind Spot in Understanding Trigonometric Derivatives: A Multinational Analysis by Yossi Ben-Zion, Jianqiang Liu, Chun-Ming Wang, Atanu Rajak, Noah D. Finkelstein (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01525.txt.
Introduction
Yossi Ben-Zion and four co-authors report in 2025 a shared weak spot in college maths and physics. Students often miss that the standard rules for rates of change of sine and cosine hold only when angles are measured in radians, not degrees. The team tested that point across four countries.
Their survey drew 769 students, mostly in science and engineering, from Israel, the United States, China, and India. Only about twenty-six percent gave the right answer for pure maths, while most wrongly said both units work. Students did better when the same idea sat inside a physics setting they knew. The authors call for teaching that links maths rules more tightly to their physical use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yossi Ben-Zion, Jianqiang Liu, Chun-Ming Wang, Atanu Rajak, Noah D. Finkelstein |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01525
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Global Blind Spot in Understanding Trigonometric Derivatives: A Multinational Analysis Yossi Ben-Zion, Jianqiang Liu, Chun-Ming Wang, Atanu Rajak, Noah D. Finkelstein Abstract Trigonometric derivatives are fundamental in both mathematics and physics, yet their proper application, particularly the distinction between radians and degrees, poses a significant challenge for college students globally. This study identifies a widespread ”blind spot” in understanding trigonometric derivatives and their implications for physical systems, highlighting a critical gap in physics education. A multinational survey of 769 college students, primarily undergraduate and graduate STEM majors, from Israel, the United States, China, and India assessed their ability to differentiate between radians and degrees in mathematical and physical contexts, focusing on harmonic motion. Results reveal that only 26.3% of students correctly identified that the well-known expressions for trigonometric derivatives hold exclusively in radians, while 70.7% incorrectly assumed both radians and degrees are valid. Notably, students demonstrated improved recognition of radians in physical contexts (59.0% correct responses) compared to mathematical ones, suggesting that students rely on familiar physical equations as cognitive reference points when applying mathematical concepts. These misunderstandings appear worldwide, suggesting a universal challenge. The findings highlight the need for curriculum reforms to better connect mathematical formalism with physical application. I Introduction “An alien culture might not use 360 at all. On the other hand, I believe 2 \pi would be discovered in any advanced civilization.” – R. Shankar, Fundamentals of Physics I Shankar 2019 Shankar’s remark highlights a fundamental reality in mathematical physics: radians are not an arbitrary choice but a natural consequence of how we define and manipulate angular quantities. Despite their fundamental role in calculus and physics, students often fail to grasp why radians, rather than degrees, form the correct mathematical framework for differentiation and physical equations. This confusion extends beyond simple unit conversion; it likely reflects a deeper conceptual gap in the way students bridge mathematical formalism with physical intuition. In this study, we investigate how this misunderstanding manifests across diverse educational backgrounds and international contexts, and examine its implications for learning and applying fundamental principles in physics. The successful learning of physics fundamentally depends on students’ ability to apply mathematical concepts in physical contexts. This connection between mathematical understanding and physics comprehension becomes particularly critical when dealing with trigonometric functions and their derivatives. Recent research in physics education has highlighted persistent challenges students face when transferring mathematical knowledge to physical applications Bollen et al. 2016 ; Yeatts and Hundhausen 1992 ; Wilcox and Pollock 2015a ; Bollen et al. 2015 ; Wilcox and Pollock 2015b ; Nguyen and Rebello 2011 ; Pepper et al. 2012 ; Cui et al. 2006 ; Carli et al. 2020 ; Gifford and Finkelstein 2020 ; Gifford and Finkelstein 2021 . Research also indicates that trigonometry poses significant challenges for physics students at all levels, from beginners to advanced learners. Galle and Meredith Galle and Meredith 2014 , in their study of life science students, identified a common difficulty in understanding the physical applications of trigonometric functions. They highlighted students’ struggles to connect the mathematical representation of trigonometric functions with their physical manifestations, such as harmonic motion or waves. Additionally, students often found it challenging to interpret angular measurements quantitatively, especially when transitioning between graphical representations and algebraic solutions. Breitenberger Weber 2005 further demonstrated how these challenges persist among advanced physics students. His work documented how, despite procedural fluency in basic mathematical analyses, many students fail to grasp the deeper conceptual meaning of trigonometric functions. For instance, students tend to perceive these functions merely as computational tools, without understanding the relationship between their geometric properties and physical applications. This leaves a substantial gap between theoretical comprehension of trigonometry and its use in solving complex physics problems. While previous research has extensively documented students’ difficulties with trigonometry, little attention has been given to the specific impact of angular representation— degrees versus radians— on their ability to correctly apply differentiation in physics. This study aims to fill that gap by systematically analyzing how students across diverse educational systems understand and utilize angle units in differentiation and assessing the implications for problem-solving in physics. Previous studies have focused on general difficulties with trigonometric functions and their applications, but have not sufficiently addressed the critical distinction between these units and their influence on the rate of change of functions in physical systems, such as harmonic motion and other physical systems. Bridging this gap is essential for ensuring that students can apply trigonometry effectively across a wide range of physical problems. Angular measurements are ubiquitous in physics, from basic kinematics to quantum mechanics. These angles can be quantitatively represented using either degrees or radians, with each system having distinct historical and practical origins. The division of a circle into 360 degrees, originating from ancient Babylonian mathematics, remains deeply ingrained in everyday understanding. In contrast, the radian measure, representing the ratio of arc length to radius, emerged as a mathematically natural unit, with 2\pi radians corresponding to a full circle. This duality in representation creates a fascinating interface between mathematical formalism and physical understanding. Remarkably, our research reveals that most students exhibit fundamental gaps in both mathematical distinction and physical application of these representations. These findings transcend academic disciplines, educational levels, and most significantly, cross continental and cultural boundaries, suggesting a global blind spot that demands attention from curriculum designers and instructors in both mathematics and physics. The everyday prevalence of degrees (e.g., ”he made a 180-degree turn in his opinion”) contrasts sharply with the mathematical preference for radians in advanced studies. This dichotomy is reflected in educational progression: students typically first encounter angles in degrees during early mathematics education, with radians introduced later. At the university level, particularly in calculus and trigonometry courses, radians become the exclusive representation, to the extent that degree-based trigonometric functions are rarely used in textbooks and instruction. This discontinuity in teaching different representations and the transition between them can create a fundamental confusion among students, serving as a primary motivation for the current research. In introductory physics courses, especially at the high school level or in algebra-based college physics, there exists a hybrid approach to these representations. Early mechanics and kinematics typically employ degrees, allowing students to visualize problems using familiar units (e.g., projectile motion at 30 degrees rather than \pi/6 radians). However, when discussing periodic motion and using trigonometric functions to represent position as a function of time, instruction often shifts to radians. This transition is often justified with the simple explanation that radians are “more natural” due to their relationship to arc length, without deeper exploration of the mathematical implications. This approach is commonly found in introductory physics textbooks (e.g. Shankar 2019 ; Halliday et al. 2013 ; Serway et al. 2000 ; Tipler and Mosca 2007 ) The critical distinction lies not in the dimensionless nature of these units—both degrees and radians are dimensionless—but in their derivatives. The rate of change in radians differs from that in degrees by a factor of \pi/180 : \frac{d}{dx}\sin(x)=\cos(x)\text{ [in radians]} (1) \frac{d}{dx}\sin(x^{\circ})=\frac{\pi}{180}\cos(x^{\circ})\text{ [in degrees]} (2) This distinction becomes particularly crucial in the context of harmonic oscillation, where the fundamental equation of motion: \frac{d^{2}x}{dt^{2}}=-\omega^{2}x (3) relies on the radian representation for its standard solutions. The familiar expression for position as a