Hecke’s inverse cotangent numbers
Kurt Girstmair · 2025
Read Hecke’s inverse cotangent numbers by Kurt Girstmair (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01349.txt.
Introduction
Kurt Girstmair revisits a set of numbers Hecke introduced in work on Eisenstein series, which Hecke called rational but cumbersome to compute. His 2025 paper shows these numbers are less mysterious than they look. They are essentially generators of certain number fields tied to roots of unity. The name comes from how they arise: inverting a matrix built from better known cotangent numbers.
For a wide class of cases, those where the index is square free, the paper gives a fairly closed form. The numbers appear as blends of roots of unity with rational weights. A second formula uses generalized Bernoulli numbers and Gauss sums. The work connects a historical aside in Hecke's writing to standard objects in algebraic number theory. It replaces case by case computation with structure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kurt Girstmair |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01349
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hecke’s inverse cotangent numbers Kurt Girstmair Abstract In connection with Eisenstein series for the principal congruence subgroup Γ ( n ) \Gamma(n) , Hecke introduced certain numbers, of which he said that they are rational and cumbersome to calculate. We show, however, that these numbers are (essentially) generators of the n n th cyclotomic field or its maximal real subfield. They arise from the well investigated cotangent numbers by matrix inversion, which is why we call them inverse cotangent numbers . We describe them as linear combinations of roots of unity with rational coefficients in a fairly closed form, provided that n n is square-free. We also exhibit a formula for these numbers in terms of generalized Bernoulli numbers and Gauss sums. 1. Introduction Let n\geq 3,r\geq 1 be positive integers. Let j\in\mathbb{Z} be prime to n . In his paper [ 9 ] Hecke introduced the numbers d^{(r)}_{j}=\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{m\in\Z}{m\equiv j\,{\rm mod }\,n}}\frac{\mu(|m|)}{m^{r}}, (1) where \mu denotes the Möbius function. In the case r=1 the summation of the series has to be understood in the sense of \lim_{k\to\infty}\sum_{|m|\leq k}. (2) Hecke said that the numbers d^{(r)}_{j} turn out to be rational (“ergeben sich als rationale Zahlen”). However, he doubtlessly knew that a certain power of \pi is involved in d^{(r)}_{j} , which, by the analogy of 1/\zeta(r) , can only be \pi^{-r} . Indeed, put \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j}=\frac{-i^{r}\pi^{r}}{(r-1)!\,n^{r}}\,d^{(r)}_{j}. (3) Then this number generates the n th cycotomic field (over \mathbb{Q} ) if r is odd, and its maximal real subfield if r is even (see Proposition 2 ). In particular, \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)} is rational only in few cases like n\in\{3,4,6\} , r even. The notation \widehat{\rm{ct}} will turn out to be reasonable. Hecke further said that the computation of d^{(r)}_{j} is fairly laborious if n is not a prime, and will not be discussed in his paper (“Ihre Berechnung ist, wenn nicht gerade N eine Primzahl ist, ziemlich umständlich, und soll hier nicht weiter erörtert werden” (Hecke’s N corresponds to our n )). We will see, however, that even in the case of a small prime number n and a small parameter r (like n=11 , r=4 ) the result is fairly complex (see Section 4). Let us briefly sketch Hecke’s context. He studies the vector space of Eisenstein series of weight r , r\in\mathbb{Z} , r\geq 1 , for the principal congruence subgroup \Gamma(n)=\{A\in\mbox{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z});A\equiv I\mbox{ mod }n\} , where I denotes the unit matrix. Since the cases r=1,2 are more complicated, we assume r\geq 3 for our sketch. Hecke’s primitive Eisenstein series G(z,r,\underline{a}) , \underline{a}=(a_{1},a_{2}) a pair of coprime integers, have an easily computable Fourier expansion, but they do not form a \mathbb{C} -basis of the vector space in question. Therefore, he defines G^{*}(z,r,\underline{a})=\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{1\le j\le n/2}{(j,n)=1}}d^{(r)}_{j^{*}}G(z,r,j\underline{a}), where j^{*} is an inverse of j mod n , and obtains such a basis, provided that the pairs \underline{a} are suitably chosen with respect to cusps. Since the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} are in the n th-cyclotomic field \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{n}) , \zeta_{n}=e^{2\pi i/n} , a computation of these number means a representation as a rational linear combination of powers of \zeta_{n} . We obtain this, in a fairly explicit form, only if \zeta_{n} generates a normal basis of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{n}) . This, however, is true if, an only if, n is square-free (see [ 13 ] ). “Fairly explicit” means up to the inversion of an easily computable rational matrix involving values of Bernoulli polynomials (see Theorem 1 and the examples of Section 4). The numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} are closely connected with the cotangent numbers {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , defined by {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j}=i^{r}\cot^{(r-1)}(\pi j/n),\kern 5.0pt(j,n)=1, (4) where \cot^{(r-1)} stands for the (r-1) th derivative of the cotangent function. So we have \cot^{(0)}=\cot , \cot^{(1)}=-\cot^{2}-1 , and so on. Since the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} arise from the numbers {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} by matrix inversion, they will be called inverse cotangent numbers (see ( 6 )). Cotangent numbers have been studied in the case r=1 in connection with formulas for the relative class number of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{n}) , see, for instance, [ 2 , formula (3.1)] , [ 6 , formulas (3), (4)] , [ 3 ] , [ 14 ] , [ 11 ] , for r\geq 2 also [ 5 ] and [ 6 ] . See also the final remark of this paper. As a consequence of our study, we exhibit the values of series like \sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{m>0,}{(m,n)=1}}\mu(m)\frac{\sin(2\pi m^{*}/n)}{m^{r}},\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{m>0,}{(m,n)=1}}\mu(m)\frac{\cos(2\pi m^{*}/n)}{m^{r}}, where n is square-free, r odd in the first, r even in the second case ( m^{*} has been defined above). These series have rational values up to the factor \pi^{-r} , see Proposition 5 . Finally, we determine the eigenvalues of the matrices used for the definition of the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , see Section 6. This gives another formula for the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} in terms of generalized Bernoulli numbers and Gauss sums, see Theorem 2 . 2. Inverse cotangent numbers Let n,r be as above. The partial fraction decomposition of the cotangent function yields, for j\in\mathbb{Z} , (j,n)=1 , \cot^{(r-1)}(\pi j/n)=(-1)^{r-1}(r-1)!\left(\frac{n}{\pi}\right)^{r}\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{m\in\Z}{m\equiv j\,{\rm mod }\,n}}\frac{1}{m^{r}}. In the case r=1 the series has to be understood in the sense of ( 2 ). Proposition 1 Let n and r be as above. Let {\cal R}=\{j;1\leq j\leq n/2,(j,n)=1\}. For a number j\in\mathbb{Z} , (j,n)=1 , let j^{*} denote the inverse of j mod n , i.e., jj^{*}\equiv 1\mod n , 1\leq j^{*}\leq n . If {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} and \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} are defined by ( 1 ), ( 3 ), and ( 4 ), then \sum_{l\in{\cal R}}{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{sl^{*}}\,\widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{lt^{*}}=\delta_{s,t}, (5) for all s,t\in{\cal R} . Here \delta is the Kronecker delta. Proof. The case r=1 of conditional convergence is somewhat subtle. It was settled in [ 7 ] . In the case r\geq 2 the series for {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{k} are absolutely convergent and can, thus, be multiplied without problems. We obtain that the sum in question equals \sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{m\in\Z}{m\equiv st^*\,{\rm mod }\,n}}\frac{1}{m^{r}}\sum_{l\in{\cal R}}\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{j\in\Z,j\DIV m}{j\equiv lt^*\,{\rm mod }\,n}}\mu(|j|). For a fixed number m , m\equiv st^{*}\mod n , the inner double sum can be written \sum_{l\in{\cal R}}\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{j\DIV m,j>0}{j\equiv lt^*\,\rm{mod}\,n}}\mu(j)+\sum_{l\in{\cal R}}\sum_{\genfrac{}{}{0.0pt}{1}{j\DIV m,j>0}{j\equiv-lt^*\,\rm{mod}\,n}}\mu(j). This is the same as \sum_{j\,|\,m,j>0}\mu(j)=\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}1,&\hbox{ if $m=\pm 1$;}\\ 0,&\hbox{otherwise.}\end{array}\right. However, the case m=-1 would imply s\equiv-t mod n , which is impossible for s,t\in{\cal R} . Therefore, only m=1 and s\equiv t mod n contribute to the whole. \Box In view of ( 5 ), we introduce the matrices {\rm{Ct}}^{(r)}=({\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{jk^{*}})_{j,k\in{\cal R}},\kern 5.0pt\widehat{\rm{Ct}}^{(r)}=(\widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{jk^{*}})_{j,k\in{\cal R}}, the rows and columns of these matrices having the natural order of {\cal R} . Then Proposition 1 can be phrased as \widehat{\rm{Ct}}^{(r)}=({\rm{Ct}}^{(r)})^{-1}. (6) This justifies the name inverse cotangent numbers given to the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} in Section 1. We further note that the numbers {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , and, by ( 6 ), also the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , (j,n)=1 , lie in \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{n}) . Indeed, \mbox{ct}^{(1)}_{j}=i\cot(\pi j/n)=(1+\zeta_{n}^{j})/(1-\zeta_{n}^{j}) , and {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} is a polynomial in i\cot(\pi j/n) with rational coefficients. We also need the action of the Galois group of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{n}) over \mathbb{Q} on the numbers {\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , (j,n)=1 . Let \sigma_{k} , (k,n)=1 , be the Galois automorphism of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{n}) defined by \zeta_{n}\mapsto\zeta_{n}^{k} . Then \sigma_{k}({\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j})={\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{kj},\kern 5.0pt(j,n)=1, (7) The action of \sigma_{k} on the numbers \widehat{\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{j} , j\in{\cal R} , can be found by ( 6 ), namely, by the identity \sigma_{k}(\widehat{\rm{Ct}}^{(r)})\cdot\sigma_{k}({\rm{Ct}}^{(r)})=\sigma_{k}(\widehat{\rm{Ct}}^{(r)})\cdot({\rm{ct}}^{(r)}_{jkl^{*}})_{j,l\in{\cal R}}=I, where I=(\delta_{j,l})_{j,l\in{\cal R}} is the unit matrix. We