Towards AMS measurements of 91 Nb, 94 Nb and 93 Mo produced in fusion environment
Carlos Vivo-Vilches, Esad Hrnjic, Martin Martschini, Kyra Altindag, Lee W. Packer, Robin Golser, Karin Hain · 2025
Read Towards AMS measurements of 91 Nb, 94 Nb and 93 Mo produced in fusion environment by Carlos Vivo-Vilches, Esad Hrnjic, Martin Martschini, Kyra Altindag, Lee W. Packer, Robin Golser, Karin Hain (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01312.txt.
Introduction
Vivo-Vilches and co-authors work in 2025 toward measuring three long lived radionuclides made inside fusion reactors. Neutron hits on reactor steel create these isotopes, and waste class forecasts need test data to check simulation codes. Their tool is accelerator mass spectrometry with a laser based ion method.
Laser light strips away stable look alike atoms that would swamp the signal. Collision gas adds further suppression for two isotopes. Suppression factors reached tens of thousands in their tests, with interference levels reported for prepared targets. The work sets up waste relevant isotope measures that standard mass tools cannot reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Carlos Vivo-Vilches, Esad Hrnjic, Martin Martschini, Kyra Altindag, Lee W. Packer, Robin Golser, Karin Hain |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01312
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Towards AMS measurements of 91 Nb, 94 Nb and 93 Mo produced in fusion environment Carlos Vivo-Vilches, Esad Hrnjic, Martin Martschini, Kyra Altindag, Lee W. Packer, Robin Golser, Karin Hain Abstract Long-lived radionuclides, such as 91 Nb, 94 Nb and 93 Mo, are expected to be produced in nuclear fusion reactors by reactions of high-energy neutrons with the structural material. Accurate predictions of waste categorization require experimental validation of simulation codes like FISPACT-II. This work explores the use of Ion-Laser InterAction Mass Spectrometry (ILIAMS) at the Vienna Environmental Research Accelerator (VERA) to measure these three radionuclides by accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS). The ILIAMS setup employs laser photodetachment to suppress their respective stable isobars: 91 Zr, 94 Zr and 94 Mo, and 93 Nb. For 91,94 Nb measurements, the NbO 3 – anion is selected, with interferences from 91,94 ZrO 3 – already suppressed just by collisions with the He buffer gas in the ion cooler. The suppression can be further enhanced by overlapping a 355 nm laser with the ion beam. In that way, we reach 91 Zr/ 93 Nb and 94 Zr/ 93 Nb levels of 1.2 × \times 10 –14 and 1.8 × \times 10 –14 , respectively, in commercial Nb 2 O 5 targets. The MoO 3 – anion was suppressed by a factor of 4360, leading to a 94 Mo/ 93 Nb interference of 1.28 × \times 10 –10 in the same targets. For 93 Mo measurements, the MoO 2 – anion is selected, with interference from 93 NbO 2 – suppressed by 637 nm photons by a factor of 5.5 × \times 10 6 . This results in a 93 Nb/ nat Mo level of 1.3 × \times 10 –13 in targets prepared from commercial MoO 3 . These suppressions are not achieved using separation techniques based on the difference in energy loss, even in AMS facilities with terminal voltages above 8.5 MV and foil stripping. Preprint submitted for publication in Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, Special Issue "Proceedings of the 16th International Conference on Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, October 20-26th 2024, Guilin, China" ©This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY 4.0 license https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 Keywords: Accelerator mass spectrometry, Laser photodetachment, ILIAMS, Nuclear fusion, 91,94 Nb, 93 Mo, Isobar suppression 1 Introduction In future nuclear fusion reactors, radionuclides are expected to be produced by the reactions of the high-energy neutrons (14.1 MeV) from the deuterium-tritium (D-T) fusion with the nuclei in the structural material of the reactor. Unlike current nuclear fission reactors, fusion reactors are not anticipated to produce long-lived high level waste. However, research is still required to predict for which materials and under which conditions the waste from fusion reactors will be able to be categorized as low level waste or intermediate level waste 100-300 years after the end of operation. These predictions are performed with computer codes for the simulation of activation of materials, such as FISPACT-II [ 1 ] , whose results rely on the accuracy of the reaction cross sections provided by the libraries used, such as TENDL [ 2 , 3 ] . To validate these codes, experimental campaigns have been conducted at the Joint Experimental Torus (JET) reactor, where foils of different materials intended for use in the ITER reactor were placed inside plasma chamber. After the campaign the activities of several short lived radionuclides were measured in those foils and compared with the ones calculated with FISPACT-II taking into account the fluence and energy distribution of the neutrons, and the irradiation schedule [ 4 , 5 ] . While the weighted average of the ratio between calculated and experimental activities (C/E) for the D-T campaign DTE2 was 0.986 \pm 0.07, for some radionuclides and/or materials this ratio deviated significantly from 1, highlighting the importance of these experimental campaigns. An example is 60 Co, where the C/E ratio is 2.09 \pm 0.04 for stainless steel SS316L and 3.29 \pm 0.03 for SS316L(N) [ 5 ] . Since these measurements were non-destructive, the neutron irradiated foils, with masses between 0.5 g and 1.0 g, are still available for the measurement of long-lived radionuclides. In materials containing molybdenum, three long-lived radioisotopes become important contributors to the external dose 100-300 years after the end of operation: 91 Nb, 94 Nb, and 93 Mo [ 6 ] . The interaction of D-T neutrons with molybdenum produces 94 Nb through the 94 Mo(n,p) 94 Nb and 95 Mo(n,np+d) 94 Nb reactions [ 6 ] . This radionuclide decays by β – -emission to 94 Mo with a half-life of 20300 \pm 1600 a [ 7 ] . In 100% of these decays, two γ particles are emitted, one with an energy of 702.65 keV and another of 871.091 keV [ 8 ] . Therefore, it can be detected by conventional γ-spectrometry, which typically does not require the destruction of the sample or extensive sample preparation [ 9 ] . Lower detection limits can be obtained, though, if the sample is chemically treated to separate 94 Nb from other γ-emitting radionuclides [ 10 , 11 ] . 93 Mo, which decays by electron capture to 93 Nb with a half-life of 4839 \pm 63 a [ 12 ] , is produced in fusion reactors by the interaction of D-T neutrons with molybdenum through the 94 Mo(n,2n) 93 Mo and 92 Mo(n,γ) 93 Mo reactions. Its detection is commonly done by liquid scintillation counting (LSC) of Auger electrons [ 13 ] or by detection of the Nb X-Rays emitted after the decay [ 11 , 14 ] . Even using gas collision cells, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) measurements of 93 Mo are limited by the molecular interference of 92 ZrH + and 92 MoH + [ 15 ] . These studies on the detection of 94 Nb and 93 Mo are motivated by their production in nuclear fission reactors, due to thermal neutron capture on their respective stable isotopes, 93 Nb and 92 Mo. Accordingly, there are hardly any published detection limits for 91 Nb, which cannot be produced by neutron absorption on any stable nuclide. In contrast, 91 Nb is produced in fusion reactors by the interaction of D-T neutrons with molybdenum either directly through the 92 Mo(n,np+d) 91 Nb reaction, or indirectly through the 92 Mo(n,2n) 91 Mo reaction and subsequent decay of 91 Mo ( T_{1/2} = 15.49 min) [ 6 ] . 91 Nb is expected to be the second most active or even the most active radionuclide in the blanket of nuclear fusion reactors 100 years after the end of operation for stainless steel grades with more than 1% of molybdenum content [ 16 ] . The half life of this radionuclide, which decays to 91 Zr by either electron capture (99.83%) or β + emission (0.17%) [ 17 ] , is known only with a high uncertainty, the only published value for it being 680 \pm 130 a [ 18 ] . The detection limits of radiometric techniques do not allow the measurement of 91 Nb, 94 Nb, and 93 Mo in the foils irradiated during the DTE2 campaign at the JET reactor [ 5 ] ,