Dust coagulation assisted by streaming instability in protoplanetary disks

Ryosuke T. Tominaga, Hidekazu Tanaka · 2025

Read Dust coagulation assisted by streaming instability in protoplanetary disks by Ryosuke T. Tominaga, Hidekazu Tanaka (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01137.txt.

Introduction

Ryosuke Tominaga and Hidekazu Tanaka ask whether a known swirling effect in planet-forming disks can also help dust grains grow. The effect, the streaming instability, packs grains into dense clumps that can collapse into planetesimals, but it works best with large grains, and collisions usually smash grains before they grow that big.

Running local simulations, the team tracked grain paths inside moderate clumps and measured how fast grains meet and how often. The meeting speeds were tiny, about a tenth of a percent of the sound speed or less, so grains should stick rather than shatter. Meetings were also frequent, on timescales of ten orbits or fewer, fast enough to beat the inward drift that removes grains. The clumping thus eases both barriers to forming planetesimals.

Catalog record

CREATORRyosuke T. Tominaga, Hidekazu Tanaka
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01137

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dust coagulation assisted by streaming instability in protoplanetary disks Ryosuke T. Tominaga, Hidekazu Tanaka Abstract The streaming instability is a promising mechanism for planetesimal formation. The instability can rapidly form dense clumps that collapse self-gravitationally, which is efficient for large dust grains with the Stokes number on the order of 0.1. However, dust growth models predict that collisional fragmentation prevents dust grains from growing to such sizes. We perform local simulations of the streaming instability and measure characteristic collision velocities and collision rates of dust grains based on their trajectories in moderate clumping. The collision velocities are on the order of 0.1 percent of the sound speed or lower, implying that dust grains can overcome the fragmentation barrier via the clumping. We also find that the collision rates are appreciably high regardless of the low collision velocities. Corresponding timescales are on the order of ten Keplerian periods or shorter, suggesting that dust grains can overcome the drift barrier as well. This streaming-instability-assisted (SI-assisted) coagulation greatly relaxes the conditions for planetesimal formation as recently implied. Athena [ 76 ] , NumPy [ 29 ] , Matplotlib [ 31 ] , SciPy [ 82 ] I Introduction Formation of planetesimals from dust grains is one of the key steps in plant formation. There are some obstacles known to prevent dust coagulation in protoplanetary disks. One of the major obstacles is the radial drift of dust toward the central star [ 87 , 85 , e.g.,] , which is caused by different orbital velocities of dust and gas. While dust grains tend to move at Keplerian velocities, gas moves at sub-Keplerian velocities because of a pressure gradient force in the radial direction. Because of the headwind of gas, the dust grains lose angular momentum and move inward. The maximum drift speed is on the order of 0.01 au/yr in protoplanetary disks. Such fast drifting motion prevents dust grains from growing larger before they reach the central star [ 13 , e.g.,] . Another obstacle is collisional fragmentation [ 10 , e.g.,] . Experiments and numerical simulations suggested critical velocities beyond which dust grains are disrupted [ 11 , 12 , 83 , e.g.,] . Critical velocities depend on material properties, including chemical composition and monomer size of dust aggregates [ 18 , 22 , e.g.,] . According to Wada et al. [83] , the critical velocity for water ice aggregates with 0.1 \mu\mathrm{m} -sized monomers is \sim 50\;\mathrm{m/s} , which is comparable to the maximum drift speed. Recent studies have shown that \mathrm{CO}_{2} ice is much less sticky than water ice [ 52 , 53 ] . They suggested that the critical velocity for \mathrm{CO}_{2} ice is about 10 times lower than that for water ice. Thus, fragmentation may prevent dust coagulation even in a cold outer region when dust is covered by \mathrm{CO}_{2} ice mantles [ 58 , 55 , see also] . One of the promising mechanisms to circumvent the obstacles is hydrodynamic instabilities [e.g., 71 , 43 , and references therein] . Among them, the streaming instability (SI) is the leading and extensively studied mechanism [ 92 , e.g.,] . The SI is driven by aerodynamic interaction between drifting dust and gas [ 72 , 73 , 49 , e.g.,] and can increase local dust densities by orders of magnitude [ 37 , 4 , e.g.,] . Numerical simulations of the SI have shown that the local dust density can exceed the Roche density, meaning that resulting dust clumps gravitationally collapse into planetesimals [ 35 , 38 , 70 , 61 , 1 , e.g.,] . In contrast to the gravitational instability [ 60 , 68 ] , the SI does not require self-gravity and is thus expected to operate at various stages of the disk evolution in terms of dust mass. Conditions for planetesimal formation via the SI have been investigated in previous studies [ 14 , 89 , 44 , 47 ] . They performed vertically stratified simulations for multiple parameter sets and derived critical dust-to-gas ratios as a function of the Stokes number, \mathrm{St} , which is the dimensionless stopping time of dust. Carrera et al. [14] found the critical dust-to-gas surface density ratio to be \simeq 0.02 for \mathrm{St}\simeq 0.1 and larger for smaller \mathrm{St} . Although the critical values have been updated in the subsequent studies, they also show that the critical dust-to-gas ratio decreases as \mathrm{St} increases to \mathrm{St}\sim 0.1 [ 89 , 44 , 46 ] . Lim et al. [47] simulated the SI with forced gas turbulence in stratified simulations. They found that the condition is well described in terms of midplane dust-to-gas ratios, and the critical value is \simeq 1 for \mathrm{St}=0.1 and a few times higher for \mathrm{St}=0.01 (see Figure 4 therein). The critical values are similar among the runs with different strength of the turbulence. These studies indicate that the SI can form planetesimals if dust grains grow to the size of \mathrm{St}\sim 0.01-0.1 . The required \mathrm{St} may be even smaller since Yang et al. [89] and Li & Youdin [44] observed strong clumping in runs with \mathrm{St}=10^{-3} . The amount of concentrated dust grains via the SI depends on \mathrm{St} . Johansen & Youdin [37] showed cumulative dust density distributions obtained from their unstratified simulations (see their Figure 11). They showed that more dust grains reside in overdense regions for \mathrm{St}=1 than for \mathrm{St}=0.1 . According to the stratified simulations with multiple dust species [ 4 ] , the mass fraction of dust grains in overdense regions seems largest for \mathrm{St}\sim 10^{-0.5} . The concentration of smaller dust grains ( \mathrm{St}<0.1 ) is limited, and the mass fraction of dust grains in dense regions can be an order of magnitude smaller than for \mathrm{St}\sim 0.1-1 . Recent high-resolution simulations with \mathrm{St}=0.01 also showed that the dust densities exceed the Roche density only at limited grid cells [ 46 ] . Besides, the previous numerical simulations have shown that it takes long time for the dust density to reach the Roche density when \mathrm{St} is small. According to Li & Youdin [44] , duration time of this pre-clumping phase can be a few hundreds of the Keplerian periods for \mathrm{St}\sim 10^{-2} unless dust-to-gas surface density ratios are initially high enough. This would be problematic for planetesimal formation in local regions such as a gas bump. Carrera & Simon [15] simulated the SI in a gas bump and showed that the clumping with \mathrm{St}\simeq 0.01 is so slow that the dust densities do not exceed the Roche density before the dust crosses the bump [ 17 , see also] . These studies suggest that planetesimal formation via the SI requires sufficiently large \mathrm{St} (e.g., 0.1-0.3) from a viewpoint of planetesimal formation efficiency. The required dust size seems comparable to the drift-limited size [ 13 , e.g., see] . The dust growth model predicts much smaller \mathrm{St} when the critical velocity is lower than \sim 10\;\mathrm{m/s} and fragmentation hinders dust growth [ 24 , e.g., see] . As mentioned above, dust grains will experience such disruptive collisions even in a cold region because of the low critical velocity for \mathrm{CO}_{2} ice. Therefore, an additional mechanism to circumvent the fragmentation barrier

Read the complete text