Privacy vs. Profit: The Impact of Google’s Manifest Version 3 (MV3) Update on Ad Blocker Effectiveness
Karlo Lukic ID, Lazaros Papadopoulos ID · 2025
Read Privacy vs. Profit: The Impact of Google’s Manifest Version 3 (MV3) Update on Ad Blocker Effectiveness by Karlo Lukic ID, Lazaros Papadopoulos ID (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01000.txt.
Introduction
Karlo Lukic and Lazaros Papadopoulos test ad blockers in a 2025 paper on Google's Manifest Version 3 update for Chrome extensions. The update replaced the powerful WebRequest interface with the more limited DeclarativeNetRequest interface, and many users feared ad blockers would grow weaker as a result.
The authors ran a browser-based experiment across samples of ad-supported websites, comparing the old and new versions of four widely used ad blockers. They found no statistically significant drop in ad blocking or anti-tracking under the new system, and in some cases the new versions blocked slightly more trackers. Providers, they conclude, adapted well to the change.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Karlo Lukic ID, Lazaros Papadopoulos ID |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 93 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01000
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Privacy vs. Profit: The Impact of Google’s Manifest Version 3 (MV3) Update on Ad Blocker Effectiveness Karlo Lukic ID, Lazaros Papadopoulos ID Abstract Google’s recent update to the manifest file for Chrome browser extensions, transitioning from manifest version 2 (MV2) to manifest version 3 (MV3), has raised concerns among users and ad blocker providers, who worry that the new restrictions, notably the shift from the powerful WebRequest API to the more restrictive DeclarativeNetRequest API, might reduce ad blocker effectiveness. Because ad blockers play a vital role for millions of users seeking a more private and ad-free browsing experience, this study empirically investigates how the MV3 update affects their ability to block ads and trackers. Through a browser-based experiment conducted across multiple samples of ad-supported websites, we compare the MV3 to MV2 instances of four widely used ad blockers. Our results reveal no statistically significant reduction in ad-blocking or anti-tracking effectiveness for MV3 ad blockers compared to their MV2 counterparts, and in some cases, MV3 instances even exhibit slight improvements in blocking trackers. These findings are reassuring for users, indicating that the MV3 instances of popular ad blockers continue to provide effective protection against intrusive ads and privacy-infringing trackers. While some uncertainties remain, ad blocker providers appear to have successfully navigated the MV3 update, finding solutions that maintain the core functionality of their extensions. Preprint, compiled August 24, 2026 Note. This is the camera-ready version accepted to Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies (PoPETs), Volume 2026, Issue 1 . The official version with page numbers and DOI will appear on the PoPETs website when the 2026(1) issue is released. Please cite as: K. Lukic and L. Papadopoulos. “Privacy vs. Profit: Impact of Google’s MV3 on Ad-Blocker Effectiveness.” Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies , 2026(1) (forthcoming). K eywords manifest version 3 (MV3), ad blocker, online advertising, online tracking 1 Introduction Browser extensions are small software programs that can improve the capabilities of a web browser. Among them, ad blockers stand out. These web privacy tools help users block advertisements (ads) and website trackers, improving their browsing experience and level of privacy [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Around 31.5% of internet users worldwide use an ad blocker, indicating widespread use and popularity [ 4 ] . A crucial component of browser extensions (hereafter, "extensions") is the manifest file, which outlines the extension’s capabilities [ 5 , 6 ] . In simple terms, this file acts as an instruction manual for the extension. It specifies what the extension can do and how it can interact with the user’s browser and visited websites, outlining its capabilities. In December 2020, Google introduced an update from manifest version 2 (MV2) to manifest version 3 (MV3; [ 7 ] ). Google positions this update as a strategy to improve the privacy, security, and performance of Chrome browser users who rely on extensions [ 8 , 9 ] . However, other stakeholders, particularly users and ad blocker providers, view this update as a strategy to reduce the effectiveness of ad blockers, potentially increasing the ad revenue of Google and website publishers [ 10 ] . The MV3 update restricts the ability of ad blockers to intercept and modify network requests, which has raised concerns about their possibly reduced effectiveness in blocking ads and trackers. Nevertheless, since the MV3 update has been announced, ad blocker providers have worked intensely to close the gap and provide a seemingly identical experience under the new restrictions. Despite these efforts users remain concerned about the impact of the MV3 update on ad-blocking effectiveness and consequently their privacy [ 11 , 12 ] . These user concerns show that Google’s underlying motivation for the update remains opaque, primarily because its internal decision-making processes and strategic incentives are not fully visible to the public. The MV3 update might deliberately weaken the ad-blocking and anti-tracking effectiveness of ad blockers, thereby consolidating Google’s control over user data and increasing its ad revenue. This outcome would align with patterns in digital advertising, where companies actively work to bypass user interventions, like ad blockers, to protect and expand their monetization potential (e.g., [ 13 ] ). Alternatively, the MV3 update could represent a strategic move toward increased user privacy. Previous research has shown that only a small number of blocking rules are effectively used by ad blockers [ 14 ] , leaving much room for optimization. Further, by reducing potential avenues for intrusive data collection, Google might aim to strengthen user trust, a factor that research in privacy economics (e.g., [ 13 ] ) suggests can lead to more user engagement. Such research has shown that enhanced privacy protections are often correlated with increased platform loyalty, as users tend to favor services that safeguard their data. As it is both technically and economically unclear whether the MV3 update reduces ad blocker effectiveness, we empirically investigate its effects on ad blockers. Therefore, this study measures the impact of Google’s MV3 update on ad blocker effectiveness, focusing on their ad-blocking and anti-tracking effectiveness. Specifically, the study addresses the following research questions: • RQ1 : Does the effectiveness of MV3 ad blockers in blocking ads and trackers change when compared to that of their MV2 counterparts? • RQ2 : Does the effectiveness of individual MV3 ad blockers differ from their own MV2 counterparts by the same ad blocker provider? • RQ3 : Does the effectiveness of using multiple MV3 ad blockers simultaneously differ from using individual MV3 ad blockers? The first research question aims to assess whether the transition from MV2 to MV3 impacts the effectiveness of MV3 ad blockers overall. It focuses on whether MV3 ad blockers are more restricted in blocking ads and trackers compared to their MV2 counterparts. The second research question builds on this comparison by examining the effectiveness of individual MV3 ad blockers compared to their MV2 counterparts. Since most ad blocker providers state that their MV3 instances use either a reduced or modified set of blocking rules derived from their MV2 instances [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] , MV2 instances of ad blockers serve as natural benchmarks. By directly comparing each MV3 ad blocker to its MV2 counterpart, including Adblock Plus, AdGuard, Stands, and uBlock Origin, we assess how ad blocker providers have adapted to the MV3 update. This comparison is particularly relevant for users transitioning to MV3, as it provides insights into whether some MV3 ad blockers remain as effective as their MV2 counterparts, while others may exhibit reduced effectiveness. Thus, the second research question aims to help users choose the most effective MV3 ad blocker amid the MV2 to MV3 update. It also evaluates whether different ad blocker providers have adjusted differently to the MV3 update [ 17 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . The third research question addresses whether using multiple MV3 ad blockers simultaneously impacts ad-blocking and anti-tracking effectiveness compared to using individual MV3 ad blockers. This research question is relevant because it addresses concerns expressed by ad blocker providers about the potentially reduced effectiveness of the MV3 ad blocker when it is used simultaneously with multiple other MV3 ad blockers [ 23 ] . This concern is substantiated by the global rule