Validity of the total quasi-steady-state approximation in stochastic biochemical reaction networks
Yun Min Song, Kangmin Lee, Jae Kyoung Kim · 2025
Read Validity of the total quasi-steady-state approximation in stochastic biochemical reaction networks by Yun Min Song, Kangmin Lee, Jae Kyoung Kim (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-00776.txt.
Introduction
Yun Min Song, Kangmin Lee, and Jae Kyoung Kim review a shortcut in cell modeling in this 2025 paper. Modelers of chemical networks inside cells often shrink big models with a steady-state shortcut. The total version of that shortcut is trusted for its accuracy in smooth, average models. Random, molecule-by-molecule models are another matter.
The review shows the shortcut can warp behavior in random models. The warp appears even where the shortcut is strictly valid in the smooth setting. False conclusions about cell dynamics can follow. The authors urge modelers to check the shortcut case by case in random simulations. Ease of use, they argue, is no proof of safety.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yun Min Song, Kangmin Lee, Jae Kyoung Kim |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-00776
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Validity of the total quasi-steady-state approximation in stochastic biochemical reaction networks Yun Min Song, Kangmin Lee, Jae Kyoung Kim Abstract Stochastic models for biochemical reaction networks are widely used to explore their complex dynamics but face significant challenges, including difficulties in determining rate constants and high computational costs. To address these issues, model reduction approaches based on deterministic quasi-steady-state approximations (QSSA) have been employed, resulting in propensity functions in the form of deterministic non-elementary reaction functions, such as the Michaelis-Menten equation. In particular, the total QSSA (tQSSA), known for its accuracy in deterministic frameworks, has been perceived as universally valid for stochastic model reduction. However, recent studies have challenged this perception. In this review, we demonstrate that applying tQSSA in stochastic model reduction can distort dynamics, even in cases where the deterministic tQSSA is rigorously valid. This highlights the need for caution when using deterministic QSSA in stochastic model reduction to avoid erroneous conclusions from model simulations. A Preprint 1 Introduction Understanding the complex dynamics of biochemical reaction networks, which are fundamental to cellular processes, relies heavily on mathematical modeling [ 1 ] . For systems with homogeneous spatial distributions of molecules, models based on ordinary differential equations (ODEs) are widely used [ 2 ] . These models represent molecular concentrations as variables and define reaction rates through mass-action kinetics. In contrast, for systems exhibiting spatial heterogeneity, partial differential equations (PDEs) are employed to incorporate spatial variability [ 2 ] . When molecular copy numbers are too low to support a continuous concentration-based description, stochastic effects become significant [ 3 ] . In such cases, stochastic models based on continuous-time Markov chains (CTMCs) provide a more appropriate framework [ 4 ] . These models, like their deterministic counterparts, generally use mass-action kinetics to define propensity functions that govern reaction probabilities. However, analytical solutions for the probability distributions of stochastic models are rarely feasible [ 5 ] , necessitating simulation approaches such as the Gillespie algorithm [ 6 ] . For systems with pronounced spatial heterogeneity, compartment-based spatial stochastic simulation algorithms (spatial SSAs) are commonly used to enhance these simulations [ 7 ] . Stochastic simulations of mass-action kinetics-based models are powerful tools for studying biochemical systems but face significant challenges. Accurately determining reaction rate constants remains difficult [ 8 ] , and systems with disparate reaction timescales often require repeated simulations of fast reactions to capture the dynamics of slower processes [ 9 ] . To mitigate these challenges, simplification techniques such as the quasi-steady-state approximation (QSSA) are employed [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . The QSSA reduces computational complexity by neglecting fast reactions and approximating fast-scale variables in propensity functions with their stochastic QSSAs, expressed as their moments conditioned on slow variables. However, stochastic QSSAs are often analytically intractable [ 5 ] . Consequently, they are frequently replaced with deterministic QSSAs derived from deterministic models [ 14 ] . This substitution results in propensity functions that resemble concentration-dependent non-elementary reaction functions, such as Michaelis-Menten or Hill functions, transformed into count-based forms. This approach has been widely adopted in numerous studies to explore the stochastic dynamics of biochemical reaction networks. [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 ] . For stochastic model reduction using deterministic QSSA, various forms of deterministic QSSA, including the standard QSSA (sQSSA) and total QSSA (tQSSA), are available [ 37 , 38 , 14 ] . Among these, the tQSSA has demonstrated superior performance in accurately capturing the original deterministic dynamics [ 14 ] . For example, while the sQSSA, which leads to the Michaelis-Menten (MM) equations, often distorts the dynamics of the original deterministic system, the tQSSA has proven to be more accurate across a broader range of conditions in deterministic ODE models [ 14 ] and has improved the fidelity of PDE model simplifications [ 39 ] . This enhanced accuracy in deterministic models likely explains the superior performance of stochastic simulations employing tQSSA-based equations (stochastic tQSSA) compared to those using other deterministic QSSAs [ 37 , 38 , 14 , 34 ] . As a result, the stochastic tQSSA has been widely regarded as reliable [ 37 , 38 , 14 , 34 , 40 , 41 , 42 , 12 , 35 , 36 , 43 ] , particularly in scenarios where the deterministic tQSSA is rigorously valid [ 44 ] , such as in rapid reversible binding processes. However, recent studies challenge this assumption, revealing that the stochastic tQSSA is not universally valid [ 45 , 46 , 47 ] . This review critically examines these limitations, showing that stochastic tQSSA can introduce significant distortions in the dynamics of simple gene regulatory network models, even in cases where the deterministic tQSSA accurately captures the original dynamics. These distortions are evident in both homogeneous and heterogeneous spatial contexts, emphasizing the need for caution when applying tQSSA in stochastic simulations. 2 Results 2.1 Deterministic and stochastic tQSSA for gene regulatory network dynamics under spatial homogeneity To evaluate the validity of the stochastic tQSSA, we first derive the deterministic tQSSA and demonstrate its application in simplifying the stochastic model for a gene regulation system. In this model, mRNA (M) is transcribed from DNA (D) at a rate \alpha_{m} and degraded at a rate d_{m} . D reversibly binds to a repressor (P) to form a complex (D:P), which inhibits mRNA transcription. The binding and unbinding rates are denoted by k_{f} and k_{b} , respectively. Assuming homogeneous spatial conditions, the deterministic dynamics of the species’ concentrations can be expressed using mass-action-based ordinary differential equations (ODEs): \displaystyle\frac{dD}{dt} \displaystyle=-k_{f}D\cdot P+k_{b}D\text{:}P, (1) \displaystyle\frac{dP}{dt} \displaystyle=-k_{f}D\cdot P+k_{b}D\text{:}P, \displaystyle\frac{dD\text{:}P}{dt} \displaystyle=k_{f}D\cdot P-k_{b}D\text{:}P, \displaystyle\frac{dM}{dt} \displaystyle=\alpha_{m}D-d_{m}M. By introducing the variables representing the total DNA ( D_{T}=D+D\text{:}P ) and repressor ( P_{T}=P+D\text{:}P ) concentrations instead of P and D\text{:}P , we can rewrite the ODE system as follows: \displaystyle\frac{dD}{dt} \displaystyle=-k_{f}D\cdot(P_{T}-D_{T}+D)+k_{b}(D_{T}-D), (2) \displaystyle\frac{dM}{dt} \displaystyle=\alpha_{m}D-d_{m}M, \displaystyle\frac{dD_{T}}{dt} \displaystyle=0, \displaystyle\frac{dP_{T}}{dt} \displaystyle=0. Here the time derivatives of D_{T} and P_{T} are zero, indicating that these quantities remain constant over time. Generally, the reactions involving the binding and unbinding between DNA and repressor occur in much faster time scales than mRNA production (i.e., k_{f},k_{b}\gg\alpha_{m},d_{m} ). Then D , regulated by only the fast reversible binding reactions, evolves in a much faster time scale than the other slow (or fixed) variables ( M , D_{T} , and P_{T} ), not regulated by the fast reactions. Then, in the fast time scale, D quickly converges to its quasi-steady-state (QSS) while the other slow variables ( M , D_{T} , and P_{T} ) remain constant. The approximation of the QSS (QSSA; D_{tq} ) can be obtained by solving dD/dt=0 : \displaystyle D_{tq}(D_{T},P_{T})=\frac{1}{2}\left\{(D_{T}-P_{T}-K_{d})+\sqrt{(D_{T}-P_{T}-K_{d})^{2}+4D_{T}K_{d}}\right\}, (3) where K_{d}=k_{b}/k_{f} is the dissociation constant. The derived QSSA is called the total QSSA (tQSSA) as it is a function in terms of the total variables (i.e., D_{T} , and P_{T} ). Then we can derive the reduced model by replacing D by the tQSSA ( D_{tq} ) \displaystyle\frac{dM}{dt} \displaystyle=\alpha_{m}D_{tq}(D_{T},P_{T})-d_{m}M, (4) \displaystyle\frac{dD_{T}}{dt} \displaystyle=0, \displaystyle\frac{dP_{T}}{dt} \displaystyle=0. This reduction is mathematically justified