Linking Critical Heights in Solar Active Regions with 3D CME Speeds: Insights from Automated and Manual PIL Detection Methods Journal: ApJ
Harshita Gandhi, Alexander W James, Huw Morgan, Lucie Green · 2025
Read Linking Critical Heights in Solar Active Regions with 3D CME Speeds: Insights from Automated and Manual PIL Detection Methods Journal: ApJ by Harshita Gandhi, Alexander W James, Huw Morgan, Lucie Green (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-00683.txt.
Introduction
Harshita Gandhi and co-authors present a 2025 solar physics study on eruptions that blast plasma from the Sun. The fastest of these eruptions, called coronal mass ejections, cause the strongest space weather at Earth. Their speed is hard to judge early, so the team tested a clue from the source region.
The clue is the critical height, the altitude where the magnetic field above an active region starts to decay fast. The authors measured it for 37 eruptions using both automated and manual maps of polarity lines. Three-dimensional speeds came from fitting a shell model to images from several viewpoints. With the automated method, speed and critical height matched with a 71 percent correlation. Higher source regions did tend to launch faster eruptions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Harshita Gandhi, Alexander W James, Huw Morgan, Lucie Green |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-00683
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Linking Critical Heights in Solar Active Regions with 3D CME Speeds: Insights from Automated and Manual PIL Detection Methods Journal: ApJ Harshita Gandhi, Alexander W James, Huw Morgan, Lucie Green Abstract In a space weather context, the most geoeffective coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are fast CMEs from Earth-facing solar active regions. These CMEs are difficult to characterize in coronagraph data due to their high speed (fewer observations), faintness, Earthward orientation (halo CMEs), and disruptions from associated high-energy particle storms. Any diagnostic aiding in early CME speed identification is valuable. This study investigates whether the 3D speeds of 37 CMEs are correlated with the critical heights of their source regions, to test the hypothesis that if the critical height is located at a higher altitude in the corona, the weaker magnetic field environment will enable a faster CME to be produced. Critical heights near CME onset are calculated by identifying polarity inversion lines (PIL) in magnetogram data using automated and manual methods. 3D speeds are determined by fitting a Graduated Cylindrical Shell (GCS) model to multi-viewpoint coronagraph images. For the automated method, we find a high correlation of 71% ± \pm 8% between CME speed and critical height, dropping to 48% ± \pm 12% when using CME plane-of-sky speeds, on which most previous similar studies are based. An attempt to improve the critical height diagnostic through manual PIL selection yields a lower correlation of 58% ± \pm 13%. The higher correlation from the automated method suggests that encompassing the full PIL structure is a better measure of the magnetic conditions that influence CME dynamics. Our results highlight the potential for critical height as a continuously computable diagnostic for forecasting the 3D speeds of Earth-directed CMEs. I Introduction Solar phenomena, particularly coronal mass ejections ( Hundhausen 1999 ; Forbes 2000 , CMEs;) , play a crucial role in shaping space weather, impacting both terrestrial and space-based technologies ( Schwenn 2006 ; Pulkkinen 2007 ) . Although CMEs typically take 1-3 days to reach Earth, current forecasting capabilities are limited to post-eruption periods. This limitation is especially pronounced for CMEs, whose Earth-directed trajectory makes their early detection and speed estimation challenging in near-real-time coronagraph data ( Gopalswamy et al. 2007 ) . Given that fast-moving CMEs can reach Earth in less than a day, understanding pre-eruptive phases and identifying predictive parameters in active regions is crucial for improving lead times and advancing space weather forecasting ( Gopalswamy et al. 2007 ; Alexakis & Mavromichalaki 2019 ; Taylor 2020 ; Zhang et al. 2021 ; Besliu-Ionescu & Mierla 2021 ) . CMEs result from the sudden destabilization of a coronal magnetic field region, following an extended phase of magnetic stress accumulation and free magnetic energy build-up within active regions ( Forbes et al. 2006 ; Schmieder et al. 2015 ; Chen 2017 ; Majumdar et al. 2022 ) . This energy build-up culminates in the eruption phase, where, under conditions of insufficient downward magnetic tension from overlying fields, plasma and magnetic fields are expelled into interplanetary space. Observations from solar telescopes equipped with remote-sensing instruments, such as coronagraphs, Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) and X-ray imagers, spectrographs, and magnetographs, provide data across these phases, while theoretical models based on magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) offer insight into the complex physics governing CME initiation and evolution. The current understanding of CME initiation mechanisms divides them into resistive (e.g., magnetic reconnection) and ideal MHD instabilities, such as the torus instability ( Kliem & Török 2006 ) . Torus instability occurs when a toroidal-shaped magnetic structure, such as a flux rope, experiences an outward hoop force that overcomes the inward magnetic tension from the overlying field ( Deng & Welsch 2017 ) . Following this understanding of CME initiation mechanisms, the concept of the magnetic decay index ( Kliem & Török 2006 ) , n , emerges as a key theoretical tool in the study of CME dynamics. It is a measure of quantifying how the strength of the poloidal component of an external magnetic field, B ext,p (the component that contributes to the tension force), changes with the radial distance, R , measured from the photosphere. It is defined as: n=-\frac{d\ln B_{\text{ext,p}}}{d\ln R} (1) A structure becomes susceptible to rapid expansion and may erupt as a CME if it exists within an external magnetic field where the decay index exceeds a critical threshold, n_{c} = 1.5, a principle initially established by Bateman 1978 and further explored by Kliem & Török 2006 in the context of CME dynamics. This critical value n_{c} for torus instability can vary depending on the specific characteristics of CME source regions. This variation affects CME dynamics, as regions with a higher decay index are typically associated with faster CMEs due to the stronger outward magnetic force overcoming the confining magnetic tension. ( Liu 2007 ; Xu et al. 2012 ; Deng & Welsch 2017 ; Cheng et al. 2020 ) . Subsequent theoretical investigations have identified ranges of critical decay index of 1.1 to 1.3 for linear flux ropes and 1.5 to 1.9 for circular configurations, with empirical studies confirming average critical values around 1.2±0.2 and 1.6±0.1 for quiescent filaments and active channel flux ropes ( Fan & Gibson 2007 ; Démoulin & Aulanier 2010 ; Fan 2010 ; Cheng et al. 2020 ) The critical height is the altitude above the photosphere where the decay index reaches its critical value n_{c} , typically around 1.5 for torus instability. At this height, the restraining forces from the overlying magnetic fields become insufficient to confine the outward magnetic pressure gradient, enabling a CME eruption. The initial acceleration of a CME is strongly influenced by the magnetic conditions at this height ( Patsourakos et al. 2010 ; James et al. 2022 ) , with the CME’s speed closely linked to the magnetic environment of its eruption site ( MacQueen & Fisher 1983 ; Zhang & Dere 2006 ) . We hypothesize that higher critical heights are correlated with faster CME speeds because they correspond to source regions with weaker coronal magnetic fields above the torus instability onset that allow flux ropes to accelerate more effectively after reaching the threshold ( n_{c}(h) =1.5). When the onset of the torus instability occurs higher up in the corona (i.e. from a higher critical height), the erupting flux rope must travel a shorter distance through the weak upper corona on its way into the heliosphere and therefore experiences less retardation from magnetic tension than a CME that erupts from lower down in the corona. This will allow the flux rope to accelerate more effectively after reaching the torus instability threshold.. Calculating critical height from magnetic field extrapolations significantly bridges the observational gap in early CME development, where visible signs of instability are not yet apparent ( Zuccarello et al. 2015 ) . The importance of determining the critical height lies in its ability to provide a quantifiable metric for assessing the likelihood of CME eruptions ( James et al. 2022 ) . In this context, critical height serves as a valuable marker derived from extrapolated magnetic field configurations above the photosphere, identifying regions where the axis of the flux rope is at the critical height. The complexity of CME source regions, alongside the