The intriguing outcomes of double degenerate mergers
* · 2025
Read The intriguing outcomes of double degenerate mergers by * (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-00411.txt.
Introduction
When two white dwarf stars merge, the result is not always a supernova blast. Lilia Ferrario reviews the range of outcomes in this 2025 talk text. White dwarfs are the dense cores left when stars like the Sun die. Pairs of them can spiral together and merge, a setup called a double degenerate merger.
Some mergers leave behind a single, heavier white dwarf instead of exploding. Others blow up only in part and leave an odd remnant behind. A merger can also collapse the core into a fast-spinning neutron star or a magnetar, a neutron star with a very strong magnetic field. Merging dwarfs have even been proposed as sources of long gamma-ray bursts and fast radio bursts. The review weighs which outcome follows from which starting pair.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | * |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-00411
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The intriguing outcomes of double degenerate mergers * Abstract This review talk explores the diverse outcomes of white dwarf mergers, emphasising that not all double degenerate mergers result in supernovae. Possible outcomes include the formation of a more massive WD, partial explosions that leave behind unusual remnants, and merger-induced collapse leading to the formation of rapidly spinning neutron stars or magnetars. Additionally, merging WDs have been proposed as potential progenitors for long γ \gamma -ray bursts and Fast Radio Bursts. [a]Lilia Ferrario 1 Introduction Merging stars in binaries are common events in the universe, but the outcomes of these mergers remain under debate due to the many uncertainties arising from the wide range of possible initial conditions (e.g., masses, separations, stellar rotations, metallicity) and aspects of binary evolution that are often not yet fully understood, such as the common envelope phase. Only about 25% of white dwarfs (WDs) in the local sample are found in binary systems ( [ 19 ] ), compared to an approximately 50% incidence of binarity observed among intermediate-mass stars on the main sequence. While [ 19 ] proposed that this discrepancy might be due to many WDs being obscured by the glare of their more luminous companions and thus missing from the WD census, [ 82 ] showed that the low percentage of WDs in binaries is primarily caused by post-main-sequence merging events. Merging can occur at different stages of the evolution of a binary, e.g., during one of the common envelope phases of binary evolution, or as two compact stars are drawn together by gravitational wave (GW) emission. Potential outcomes include: 1. the formation of a more massive WD ( [ 16 , 37 , 22 ] ); 2. supernovae of type Ia (SNe Ia), routinely used to probe the geometry and the accelerating expansion of the universe ( [ 71 , 65 , 59 ] ); 3. an explosion that leaves behind a peculiar WD which could be a fragment of the exploding WD ( [ 87 , 64 ] ) or its runaway companion WD ( [ 75 ] , [ 18 ] ); 4. a merger-induced collapse leading to the formation of a rapidly spinning neutron star [ 67 ] . 5. the formation of long \gamma -ray bursts ( [ 84 ] ) and Fast Radio Bursts ( [ 44 ] ). In the following sections, I will review some of the different channels that lead to some of the most spectacular and powerful astrophysical events and to the formation of exotic remnants. The key characteristics of a class of WDs that result from the merger of two WDs are outlined in Section 2 . In Section 3 it is discussed how double-degenerate mergers represent a significant pathway for SNe Ia explosions. In Section 4 it is proposed that the merging of two WDs can lead to the generation of rapidly spinning magnetars which could be associated with the phenomena that surround the formation of long \gamma -ray bursts (LGRBs). In Section 5 it is suggested that the merging of double WD systems could be associated to the formation of Fast Radio Bursts. The main findings are summarised in Section 6 . 2 Merged White Dwarfs WDs that are the outcome of double WD mergers are expected to exhibit several distinct characteristics, namely: 1. Rapid Rotation: Generally, WDs rotate slowly, with typical spin velocities of \lesssim 40 km/s. However, those formed through double degenerate (DD) mergers are expected to rotate significantly faster, thus distinguishing themselves from the WD population that originates from single star evolution. 2. Magnetic Fields: Strong magnetic fields can arise from a dynamo mechanism triggered by differential rotation during the merger process. It is thus expected that a larger incidence of magnetism should be observed among WDs that originate from DD mergers. 3. Masses and Peculiar Composition: Post-merger WDs may have masses larger than the average mass of WDs ( \sim 0.6 M ⊙ ) and may display peculiar atmospheric chemical compositions due to nuclear burning and the loss of their envelope during the merging event. 2.1 Carbon-enriched DQ WDs Figure 1 : Carbon abundance against temperature of DQ WDs. The C-enriched DQs are plotted in green and the ordinary DQs in blue. The size of the circles is proportional to the mass of the WD (from [ 37 ] ). DQ WDs are a subclass of WDs whose spectra are dominated by atomic and molecular carbon. C-enriched DQ WDs not only exhibit spectral features similar to those of standard DQ WDs but also possess additional characteristics suggesting a completely different origin. In particular, they display the hallmarks of mergers, as outlined in Section 2 , along with kinematic properties typically associated with old Galactic populations. The characteristics and origin of these WDs have been thoroughly examined by e.g., [ 37 , 11 , 5 , 40 ] , and have revealed that they are denoted by relatively high temperatures ( 10,000-25,000 ,K), significant carbon enrichment, high masses ( M\geq 0.8 ,M ⊙ ), and high incidence of magnetism ( \sim 70% of the members of this class are magnetic). Thus, these C-enriched WDs should not be confused with the ordinary cool DQ WDs, where helium convection brings carbon to the surface. Figure 1 highlights significant differences in carbon abundance, temperature, and mass between the two types of DQ WDs. Additionally, the mass distribution in Figure 2 highlights that the hot and warm C-enriched DQs are much more massive than the ordinary DQs whose average mass is comparable to that of typical WDs arising from single star evolution. Figure 2 : Mass distribution of DQ WDs. The ordinary DQs are in blue. The C-enriched warm DQs are in green and the hot ones in red (from [ 35 ] ). C-enriched DQs appear young based on their temperatures and cooling ages, as illustrated by the blue histogram in the top panel of Figure 3 , which shows their ages under the assumption of single-star evolution. However, their kinematics and spatial distributions suggest much greater ages, typical of very old populations such as the Galactic thick disc or halo, as shown by the green histogram in the same figure. This apparent contradiction can be resolved if these WDs formed through the merger of two WDs, producing remnants that retain the kinematic characteristics of the original double WD system while presenting as young WDs. Figure 3 : Top panel: Distributions of the measured cooling ages (blue) and of (real) ages determined by the eccentricity of their Galactic orbits (green). Lower panel: simulated age distributions for the DD mergers.The simulated data apply to the Gaia magnitude G<20 synthetic sample (from [ 37 ] ). The work of [ 37 ] shows that about half of the C-enriched DQ sample exhibit kinematic properties consistent with the Galactic thick disc or halo. This proportion is likely underestimated due to the assumption of radial velocities of 0 km s -1 for a quarter of the C-enriched sample. The top panel of Figure 4 illustrates the velocity \sqrt{U^{2}+W^{2}} versus V (Toomre diagram), where U , V , and W are the Galactic space velocity components. Stars can be broadly categorised based on their total