Late-time growth weakly affects the significance of high-redshift massive galaxies
Qianran Xia, Dragan Huterer, Nhat-Minh Nguyen · 2025
Read Late-time growth weakly affects the significance of high-redshift massive galaxies by Qianran Xia, Dragan Huterer, Nhat-Minh Nguyen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-00155.txt.
Introduction
Qianran Xia, Dragan Huterer, and Nhat-Minh Nguyen ask whether tweaks to late-time cosmic growth could explain the surprisingly massive early galaxies seen by the Webb telescope, in a 2025 paper. Growth sets how many dense lumps collapse into galaxies, so changing late growth shifts predictions for the first galaxies. Their test combines structure data near the present with the microwave background from the early universe.
The answer is mostly no: late-time growth changes move the statistical significance of the massive high-redshift objects only weakly. If those galaxies prove truly unexpected, the authors argue, altered growth history is an unlikely escape hatch.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Qianran Xia, Dragan Huterer, Nhat-Minh Nguyen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-00155
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Late-time growth weakly affects the significance of high-redshift massive galaxies Qianran Xia, Dragan Huterer, Nhat-Minh Nguyen Abstract Recent observations by the James Webb Space Telescope have revealed massive galaxies at very high redshift ( z ≃ 7 − 15 z\simeq 7-15 ). The question of whether the existence of such galaxies is expected in the corresponding JWST surveys has received a lot of attention, though the answer straddles areas of cosmology and complex astrophysical details of high-redshift galaxy formation. The growth rate of density fluctuations determines the amplitude of overdensities that collapse to form galaxies. Late-time modifications of growth, combined with measurements at both z ∼ 1 z\sim 1 from large-scale structure and z ∼ 1000 z\sim 1000 from the cosmic microwave background, affect the predictions for the abundance of first galaxies in the universe. In this paper, we point out that the late-time growth rate of structure affects the statistical significance of high-redshift, high-mass objects very weakly. Consequently, if the existence and abundance of these objects are confirmed to be unexpected, the variations in the late-time growth history are unlikely to explain these anomalies. Preprint: 000-000-000 1 Introduction The observation of spectroscopically-confirmed, high-redshift, high-mass galaxies by the James Webb Space Telescope [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] has caused excitement in astrophysics. Does the standard cosmological model allow for such objects to be created mere hundreds of millions of years after the Big Bang? The answer to this question surely depends on the knotty details of high-redshift galaxy formation ( [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] ), stellar formation [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] , dust physics [ 14 , 15 ] and their interplays [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] , all of whose details are not yet well understood. Nevertheless, there have been numerous attempts to quantify the probability of these high-redshift, high-mass events in the standard cosmological model ( [ 19 , 20 ] ) and claims that these objects are at some level of tension with the standard cosmological model [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] . One rather obvious yet relatively unexplored question is how the abundance of high-redshift objects observed by JWST is affected by the growth of cosmic structure. Clearly, a higher growth rate (starting from some fixed amplitude of primordial fluctuations) would imply more z\sim 10 objects of high mass. However the amplitude of structure growth is constrained not only by the CMB at z\simeq 1000 , but also by measurements that constrain the amplitude of the matter power spectrum at z\simeq 0 - 2 . Therefore, the space of possibilities for enhanced growth at z\simeq 10 is limited, barring very unusual scenarios where growth would break from the expected scaling with time in a matter-dominated model to be temporarily enhanced around z\simeq 10 , but then somehow slow back down to its expected scaling with time by z\simeq 2 . In this paper we quantitatively address the question of how the growth of cosmic structure affects the predicted abundance of JWST galaxies. We do not attempt to perform a comprehensive parameter search, nor are we particularly concerned about high-accuracy quantification of the rareness of high-redshift galaxies. Rather, we study the change in the standard statistical measures appropriate for the abundance of rare objects when the growth of structure is smoothly varied. We illustrate our results on a few representative examples, and argue that our results strongly indicate that structure growth does not appreciably affect the statistical significance of high-redshift, high-mass galaxies. 2 Methodology and Data The linear growth of structure is described by the function D(a) , and further by the growth rate f(a)\equiv d\ln D/d\ln a , where a is the scale factor. We make use of the fitting function f(a)\simeq\Omega_{\mathrm{m}}^{\gamma}(a), (1) where \gamma is the growth index [ 24 ] . For a broad range of possible expansion histories within general relativity, one finds \gamma{\simeq}0.55 with a very weak dependence on the dark energy model [ 25 ] ; the linear growth factor is consequently approximated by D(\gamma,a)=\exp[-\int^{1}_{a}d\ln a^{\prime}\,\Omega_{\mathrm{m}}^{\gamma}(a^{\prime})] . We will use the growth index as a tunable parameter that controls the amount of growth at late times. Note the appropriate limits: as \gamma\rightarrow 0 , f(a)\rightarrow 1 and one recovers the growth rate in an Einstein-de Sitter ( \Omega_{\mathrm{m}}=1 ) universe; as \gamma\rightarrow\infty , f(a)\rightarrow 0 and the growth rate is entirely suppressed at late times, when the matter density \Omega_{\mathrm{m}}(a) is below unity. Note that late-time changes to growth enabled by the growth-index parameterization do in principle affect the abundance of galaxies even in the epoch before dark energy becomes significant and the effects of \gamma "turn on" (so at z\gg 1 ). This is because low-redshift data that constrain the amplitude of mass fluctuations effectively normalize the growth at low redshift 1 1 1 This low-redshift normalization is partial, as it is combined with the z\simeq 1000 normalization that comes from the CMB in cases when the CMB data are used. , and thus late-time changes to the growth rate automatically impact the overall growth amplitude, and thus the abundance of objects, at arbitrarily high redshift. In more detail, normalizing the amplitude of mass fluctuations at the present time, \sigma_{8}(\gamma,a)=\sigma_{8}D(\gamma,a), (2) constraints on the present-day amplitude of mass fluctuations \sigma_{8} , along with the growth model parametrized by the growth index \gamma , together affect the amplitude of mass fluctuations and hence the abundance of galaxies at all times. To quantify the probability of high-mass high-redshift galaxies, we use the extreme value statistics [ 26 ] which has been applied in this context previously [ 21 ] . The starting point is the stellar probability distribution function (PDF), \Phi(M^{*}_{\rm max}) , for the most massive galaxy, which is the product of the PDF of the most massive halo \Phi(M^{\rm DM}_{\rm max}) , the baryon fraction f_{b} , and the stellar fractions f_{*} \Phi(M^{*}_{\rm max})=\Phi(M^{\rm DM}_{\rm max})f_{b}f_{*}. (3) Here we assume f_{*} has a truncated lognormal distribution f_{*}=\ln N(\mu,\sigma^{2}) , where \mu=e^{-2} and \sigma=1 , all chosen in [ 21 ] so as to approximately match findings from a combination of halo models and observations. In most of our tests, we leave \gamma free while fixing all the \Lambda CDM cosmological parameters to their Planck [ 27 ] values, specifically the scaled Hubble constant h=0.673 , physical matter and baryon densities \Omega_{m}h^{2}=0.143 and \Omega_{b}h^{2}=0.022 , present-day amplitude of mass fluctuations \sigma_{8}=0.811 , and the scalar spectral index n_{s}=0.965 ; these values also fix the baryon fraction to f_{b}\equiv\Omega_{b}h^{2}/(\Omega_{c}h^{2}+\Omega_{b}h^{2})=0.16 . Near the end of our Results section, we show a test on models selected from a Markov Chain in which all of the cosmological parameters are allowed to vary. Firstly, consider a survey covering a sky fraction f_{\text{sky}} over the redshift interval [z_{\min},z_{\max}] . The total expected number of halos in this volume is n_{\text{tot}}=f_{\text{sky}}\left[\int^{z_{\max}}_{z_{\min}}\int^{\infty}_{0}dzdM\frac{dV}{dz}\frac{dn(M,z)}{dM}\right] (4) To derive the extreme-value statistics, we bin the redshift range in intervals of width \Delta z=0.2 and compute the mass-distribution PDF within each bin. The normalized PDF of halo masses is then g(m)=\frac{f_{\text{sky}}}{n_{\text{tot}}}\left[\int^{z_{\max}}_{z_{\min}}dz\frac{dV}{dz}\frac{dn(m,z)}{dm}\right], (5) which gives the probability density for finding a halo of mass M