Solar prosumage under different pricing regimes: Interactions with the transmission grid Journal: Smart Energy
Dana Kirchem, Mario Kendziorski, Enno Wiebrow, Wolf-Peter Schill, Claudia Kemfert, Christian von Hirschhausen · 2025
Read Solar prosumage under different pricing regimes: Interactions with the transmission grid Journal: Smart Energy by Dana Kirchem, Mario Kendziorski, Enno Wiebrow, Wolf-Peter Schill, Claudia Kemfert, Christian von Hirschhausen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-21306.txt.
Introduction
Dana Kirchem and co-authors wrote an energy study in 2025 on homes that both make and use solar power. Such homes have roof panels and batteries, and they deal with the power grid in new ways. The team asked how the price rules set for these homes shape their choices and the grid.
They ran a linked pair of open computer models of the German power market. They tested flat prices against prices that change by the hour. They also tested prices set by zone against prices set at each grid point. Zone prices drew more roof panel uptake than point prices. Flat prices held uptake back. Local sun levels mattered more than any price rule. Grid strain from these homes stayed small in the model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dana Kirchem, Mario Kendziorski, Enno Wiebrow, Wolf-Peter Schill, Claudia Kemfert, Christian von Hirschhausen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-21306
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Solar prosumage under different pricing regimes: Interactions with the transmission grid Journal: Smart Energy Dana Kirchem, Mario Kendziorski, Enno Wiebrow, Wolf-Peter Schill, Claudia Kemfert, Christian von Hirschhausen Abstract Solar prosumers, residential electricity consumers equipped with photovoltaic (PV) systems and battery storage, are transforming electricity markets. Their interactions with the transmission grid under varying tariff designs are not yet fully understood. We explore the influence of different pricing regimes on prosumer investment and dispatch decisions and their subsequent impact on the transmission grid. Using an integrated modeling approach that combines two open-source dispatch, investment and grid models, we simulate prosumage behavior in Germany’s electricity market under real-time pricing or time-invariant pricing, as well as under zonal or nodal pricing. Our findings show that zonal pricing favors prosumer investments, while time-invariant pricing rather hinders it. In comparison, regional solar availability emerges as a larger driver for rooftop PV investments. The impact of prosumer strategies on grid congestion remains limited within the scope of our model-setup, in which home batteries cannot be used for energy arbitrage. 1 Introduction In many electricity markets, grid-connected consumers can minimize their energy bills by using rooftop PV systems and battery storage to self-generate parts of their electricity consumption. This phenomenon, which has been referred to as solar prosumage von_hirschhausen_prosumage_2017 , schill_prosumage_2017 , is on the rise in electricity markets around the world. In Germany, solar prosumage has been growing significantly in recent years, and projections indicate a continued upward trajectory as the overall PV capacity is planned to quadruple to 400 GW, with rooftop systems accounting for around half of it schmidt2024 . Solar prosumage has also become more relevant in other countries, such as Australia say2018 , say_degrees_2020 , France roulot2018 and the United States tervo2018 . While solar availability remains one of the key determinants of economic viability, such that in countries like Ireland, prosumer incentives are not sufficient for market uptake in the current policy environment bertsch2017 , a study for Spain also demonstrates that even with high solar availability, policy design is crucial for the uptake in prosumage prol2017 . The decision-making of prosumers still largely remains independent of wholesale market price signals, while retail tariffs, feed-in tariffs and PV investment costs play a pivotal role in shaping their investment and dispatch decisions gunther_prosumage_2021 . Among these factors, lower feed-in tariffs can reduce PV investments, while low variable retail tariff parts can reduce PV self-generation and battery investments gunther_prosumage_2021 . Network charges and levies are also relevant for prosumer decisions thomsen2021 . Regarding storage investment costs, home batteries have to be very cheap for high self-consumption to be economically viable for prosumers green2017 . While the effects of solar prosumage on other generation and storage capacities in the power sector have been previously studied schill_prosumage_2017 , their interactions with the electricity grid are not yet fully understood. On distribution grid level, prosumage can lead to additional distribution grid stress, which can be mitigated by policies such as a maximum grid feed-in of rooftop PV neetzow2019 . Furthermore, grid stress can be reduced when prosumage systems are operated with a load and solar availability forecast rather than with the premise of self-consumption maximization moshovel2015 . Evidence regarding the effects of prosumage on the transmission grid is more ambiguous though. Prosumage may help defer transmission grid investments by reducing peak PV feed-in levels schill_prosumage_2017 . This can lead to lower transmission network usage and losses, particularly when prosumage smoothes PV peak feed-in. chen2023 find that on the one hand, the additional renewable energy provided by prosumers can cause transmission charges to decrease. On the other hand, strategic behavior of prosumers could also increase transmission charges. In this context, the implications of electricity tariff design for investments of rooftop PV and home batteries have not yet been connected to transmission grid effects in the current literature Understanding these interactions is relevant for efficient grid planning and operation and for developing market structures that accommodate the growing trend of decentralized self-generation. This study aims to bridge this gap by analyzing how different pricing regimes influence investments in solar photovoltaic capacities and home batteries, and how these in turn impact the transmission grid. To achieve this, we combine two open-source models to quantitatively assess the potential impacts. First, the economic dispatch model ELMOD generates wholesale price time series for future scenarios in 2030 in Germany. These electricity prices serve as the basis for investment decisions into rooftop PV and battery storage using a prosumage module of the model DIETER, which takes into account different tariff design assumptions. Finally, the impacts of these investment decisions on the transmission grid are evaluated with ELMOD. This multi-stage approach allows us to provide a comprehensive analysis of how different pricing regimes influence prosumer behaviour and, consequently, the transmission grid. 2 Methods 2.1 The Model ELMOD ELMOD leuthold_elmod_2008 , egerer_2016 , weibezahn_illustrating_2019 is a comprehensive multi-step electricity market and transmission grid model, incorporating both zonal market clearing with subsequent redispatch and nodal pricing representation. By integrating congestion management, ELMOD aims to compare different market designs and their impact on market outcomes. The tool leverages a DC load flow approach to model power flows and analyze effects on the grid. 2.1.1 Day-Ahead model In the day-ahead model, ELMOD minimizes the marginal costs of electricity generation and storage as well as the costs of unit curtailment according to the objective function in Equation 1 . \displaystyle\min \displaystyle\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{p}^{P}mc_{p,t}\cdot GEN_{p,t}+c^{curt}\cdot\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{z}^{Z}CU_{z,t} \displaystyle+\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{s}^{S}mc_{s,t}\cdot GEN_{s,t} (1) Based on the selected market configuration, either the Zonal Market Balance (Equation 2 ) with exchange constraints or the Nodal Market Balance (Equation 3 ) with DC load flow constraints is implemented. Note that the difference lies in taking into account the net exchange of the zone EX_{z,t}^{net} with its neighboring zones in Equation 2 , while taking into account the injection INJ_{n,t} at each node in Equation 3 . \displaystyle\sum_{p\ in\ z}^{P}GEN_{p,t}+\sum_{s\ in\ z}^{S}(GEN_{s,t}-CHARGE_{s,t})+EX_{z,t}^{net}-CU_{z,t} (2) \displaystyle=\sum_{n\ in\ z}^{N}load_{n,t}-LL_{z,t}, \displaystyle\forall\ z\in Z,t\in T \displaystyle\sum_{p\ in\ n}^{P}GEN_{p,t}+\sum_{s\ in\ n}^{S}(GEN_{s,t}-CHARGE_{s,t}) \displaystyle+INJ_{n,t}-CU_{n,t} (3) \displaystyle= \displaystyle load_{n,t}-LL_{n,t} \displaystyle\forall\ n\in N,t\in T 2.1.2 Redispatch model In the redispatch phase of ELMOD, redispatch costs are minimized according to the objective function in Equation 4 . Total redispatch costs comprise of the redispatch costs of generating units P and storage units S , as well as the curtailment costs of units after the redispatch. \displaystyle\min \displaystyle\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{p}^{P}c^{redisp}\cdot(GEN_{p,t}^{up}+GEN_{p,t}^{down})+\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{p}^{P}c^{curt}\cdot(CU_{p,t}^{redisp}-cu_{p,t}) (4) \displaystyle+\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{s}^{S}c^{redisp}\cdot(GEN_{s,t}^{up}+GEN_{s,t}^{down}) \displaystyle+\sum_{t}^{T}\sum_{s}^{S}c^{redisp}\cdot(CHARGE_{s,t}^{up}+CHARGE_{s,t}^{down}) The redispatch market balance (Equation 5 ) resembles the nodal market balance of the day-ahead model, but with the updated unit and storage operation after the redispatch. \displaystyle\sum_{p\ in\ n}^{P}GEN_{p,t}^{redisp}+\sum_{s\ in\ n}^{S}(GEN_{s,t}^{redisp}-CHARGE_{s,t}^{redisp}) (5) \displaystyle+INJ_{n,t}-CU_{n,t}+\sum_{prs\ in\ n}^{PRS}GEN_{prs,t} \displaystyle=load_{n,t}-LL_{n,t} \displaystyle\forall\ n\in N,t\in T 2.2 The Model DIETER DIETER (Dispatch and Investment Evaluation Tool with Endogenous Renewables) is an open-source power sector model gaete2021 which can incorporate different energy sectors, such as mobility, heating or hydrogen production kirchem2023hydrogen , roth2024 , gaetemorales2024 , gueret2024 . 1 1 1 The model code for this study is available here: https://gitlab.com/diw-evu/projects/prosumage-lp . In its main version, DIETER is a linear program that determines the least-cost capacity investment and dispatch decisions for various electricity generation and storage technologies. In this analysis, we do not use the full model, but only a prosumage module, leaning on gunther_prosumage_2021 . This model