What is ontic and what is epistemic in the Quantum Mechanics of Spin?
Ariel Caticha · 2025
Read What is ontic and what is epistemic in the Quantum Mechanics of Spin? by Ariel Caticha (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-21214.txt.
Introduction
Caticha asks what is real and what is known in the spin part of quantum rules. His frame, called Entropic Dynamics, rebuilds the rules from clear claims on both sides. Sums and shape-of-data tools do the main work in that frame. The new step adds spin to the frame for the first time. The real side holds a grain with a set place in space. It also holds a two-state mark, the odd trait Pauli first flagged.
Chance shifts then match the Pauli form, as one would expect. Less clear at first, spin tools and drive terms count as known-side parts. Speed terms and turn terms share that same known-side rank. To the old ask of what spins, Caticha gives a blunt reply. In this frame, he says, no thing spins at all.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ariel Caticha |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-21214
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What is ontic and what is epistemic in the Quantum Mechanics of Spin? Ariel Caticha Abstract Entropic Dynamics (ED) provides a framework that allows the reconstruction of the quantum formalism by insisting on ontological and epistemic clarity and adopting entropic methods and information geometry. Our present goal is to extend the ED framework to account for spin. The result is a realist ψ \psi -epistemic model in which the ontology consists of a particle described by a definite position plus a discrete variable that describes Pauli’s peculiar two-valuedness. The resulting dynamics of probabilities is, as might be expected, described by the Pauli equation. What may be unexpected is that the generators of transformations – Hamiltonians and angular momenta including spin, are all granted clear epistemic status. To the old question ‘what is spinning?’ ED provides a crisp answer: nothing is spinning . 1 Introduction The framework of Entropic Dynamics (ED) allows the formulation of dynamical theories as an application of the method of maximum entropy [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] . It allows, among other things, a derivation of the Schrödinger equation including its linear and complex structure, and it also clarifies the most controversial aspect of quantum mechanics (QM) — its interpretation [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ] . The controversy centers around the question of what is real or ontic at the microscopic quantum level. Furthermore, it is not clear either how the epistemic aspects of the theory are handled. Are probabilities already present at the microscopic level or do they only arise at the macroscopic classical level when measurements are performed? Could we perhaps need some altogether different type of quantum or exotic probability? In the ED approach the main concern is to achieve ontological and epistemological clarity and, therefore, before any further discussion it may be desirable to be explicit about the terminology: The paradigmatic ontic concept is matter; a quantity is said to be ‘ontic’ when it refers to something real, substantial. The paradigmatic epistemic quantities are probabilities and wave functions; a concept is ‘epistemic’ when it refers to the state of belief, opinion, or knowledge of an agent (who, for our current purposes, we shall assume to be an ideally rational agent). Models such as ED that invoke ontic variables ( e.g. , position) while the wave function remains fully epistemic are often described as “realist \psi -epistemic models.” There exist powerful no-go theorems that rule out large families of such models — the so-called “ontological” models — because they disagree with QM. For an extended list of references and a discussion of how ED evades those no-go theorems see [ 6 ] . Briefly, ED is realist and \psi -epistemic, but it is not an ontological model. On a related issue, it is important to emphasize that the distinction ontic/epistemic is not the same as the distinction objective/subjective. Probabilities, for example, are always fully epistemic (because they codify credences or degrees of belief) but they can lie anywhere in the spectrum from objective to subjective. To be explicit: probabilities in QM are fully objective, but in other contexts probabilities can be subjective because two agents could hold different beliefs as a result of different priors or different data. This paper, however, is not about philosophy; it is about extending the ED framework to the discussion of the quantum mechanics of spin. In 1923 Pauli introduced a “peculiar, classically not describable two-valuedness” [ 7 ] [ 8 ] associated to spin and to the exclusion principle. Spin is an angular momentum and that, in itself, is not particularly strange, but ever since Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit’s 1925 idea of spin [ 9 ] , the nature of what, if anything, is actually spinning, and the nature of the peculiar two-valuedness has been and continues to be a subject of interest and of numerous studies. The standard Copenhagen interpretation is silent on these questions; it forgoes the possibility of any visualizable spin models. In other interpretations, however, spin can be an ontic variable that is variously attributed either to a spinning particle, or to the helical motion of a point particle as guided by a wave function, and the latter might be a Bohmian wave function, a Pauli spinor, a Dirac spinor, a real spinor function in the language of geometric algebra, or stochastic mechanics, or more closely related to quantum information. A non-exhaustive list of references includes [ 10 ] - [ 23 ] ; in particular, [ 14 ] and [ 16 ] deal with the interpretation of relativistic spin and the Dirac equation, and [ 21 ] [ 22 ] [ 23 ] contain a wealth of recent references, both to foundational and more computational applications. None of these models, however, provide insights as to why the Pauli equation takes the particular form it does ( e.g. , how does one derive the linearity, the adoption of complex numbers, and so on). In a previous work [ 24 ] [ 25 ] we presented a nonrelativistic ED model for a single spin-1/2 point particle. The position of the particle was assumed to be the only ontic variable and spin was recovered as a property of its epistemic wave function . The model was successful in the sense that it provided a reconstruction of the single-particle Pauli equation but two features have hindered its satisfactory extension to several particles. The first is that the four real degrees of freedom of the single particle spinor allow an elegant geometric interpretation in terms of a probability density plus the three Euler angles that define the rotation from a fixed lab frame to a spatially varying “spin” frame attached to the particle [ 24 ] . Unfortunately, this very appealing feature does not generalize to several particles because it is not in general possible to attach a separately rotating spin frame to each individual particle. One specific goal of the present paper is to provide an ED reconstruction of the Pauli equation that could in principle be extended to several particles because it does not rely on individual spin frames. The second feature is relevant to the eventual extension to identical particles. The purpose of deploying an information-based framework such as ED to reconstruct QM is to provide natural explanations for the typical quantum effects — interference, entanglement, tunneling, etc. The Pauli exclusion principle, however, has so far proved resistant in the sense that it could only be implemented by force, that is, by an ad hoc, unexplained antisymmetrization of the wave function. Here we take a first step towards a more natural explanation. It turns out that, among all quantum effects, the exclusion principle is unique in that it is remarkably robust. While effects such as interference, entanglement, tunneling, etc., are all destroyed by noise, the exclusion principle can survive under the most extreme conditions such as, for example, in the interior of stars. A natural explanation would follow from the observation that quantum effects that are sensitive to noise and decoherence can all be traced to the wave function, that is, to the epistemic sector of ED. The robustness of the exclusion principle strongly suggests that its explanation