Can Bohmian mechanics be considered complete?

Aurélien Drezet 1 , Arnaud Amblard 1 · 2025

Read Can Bohmian mechanics be considered complete? by Aurélien Drezet 1 , Arnaud Amblard 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-20851.txt.

Introduction

Aurélien Drezet and Arnaud Amblard ask whether a rival reading of quantum mechanics can be complete in a 2025 paper, written for the theory's centenary. Bohmian mechanics pictures particles guided by a wave, offering a clear story of what exists. The most common reading treats the wave as a kind of law rather than a physical thing.

The authors defend a more causal, plural view, drawing analogies with optics and flowing fluids. Within that frame they review attempts that use mechanical analogies to push past limits of current Bohmian theory, and perhaps of quantum mechanics itself. The paper is a philosophical and historical assessment rather than new experiments, aimed at readers weighing interpretations of the quantum world.

Catalog record

CREATORAurélien Drezet 1 , Arnaud Amblard 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE115 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-20851

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can Bohmian mechanics be considered complete? Aurélien Drezet 1 , Arnaud Amblard 1 Abstract In this work celebrating the centenary of quantum mechanics, we review the principles of de Broglie Bohm theory, also known as pilot-wave theory and Bohmian mechanics. We assess the most common reading of it (the Nomological interpretation based on the notion of primitive ontology in tridimensional space) and defend instead a more causal and pluralistic approach, drawing on classical analogies with optics and hydrodynamics. Within this framework, we review some of the approaches exploiting mechanical analogies to overcome the limitations of current Bohmian theory and perhaps quantum mechanics itself. I Introduction One hundred years ago, quantum mechanics was founded following Heisenberg’s fundamental work on matrix mechanics Heisenberg ; Waerden . These brilliant results were amplified and developed by Heisenberg in collaboration with Born, Jordan, Pauli, Dirac Waerden and under the patronage of Bohr, who in 1927 concluded this prolific period with the introduction of the principle of complementarity Bohr , the keystone of what later became known as the Copenhagen school. At the same time, Schrödinger, building on de Broglie’s ideas, founded wave mechanics in 1926 and introduced the famous equation that bears his name Schrodinger . The two approaches of Heisenberg on the one hand and Schrödinger on the other differed fundamentally in their methods and objectives. Whereas Heisenberg, inspired by Mach’s positivism and the work of Bohr, Kramers and Sommerfeld, sought to eliminate unobservable quantities from quantum theory, Schrödinger wanted to obtain a mechanical image of the electron in the classical sense, but representing it as a vibration extended in space. Schrödinger’s interpretation of his wave function \Psi(q,t) (defined at time t at coordinate point q:=[q_{1},...,q_{3N}] in the 3N -dimensional configuration space for N particles) was strongly criticized by Heisenberg and Bohr, and the story goes that it was finally Born who officially proposed in 1926 Born to interpret the density |\Psi(q,t)|^{2} as a probability density in configuration space (i.e., eliminating trajectories and determinism from quantum theory). The official, orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics thus completely absorbed the Schrödinger wave equation into its general formalism, providing it with a powerful tool without changing the corpus of principles of the Copenhagen interpretation. In fact, in this theory, the probability |\Psi(q,t)|^{2}d^{3N}q represents the probability of observing at time t the system in the 3N -dimensional d^{3N}q configuration space element. However, this is by no means a probability of occurrence or presence in the classical sense, as the particles are not assumed to have trajectories or even pre-exist experimental measurement (in this respect, the situation is very different from the classical statistical mechanics used to justify thermodynamics). We could in principle stop our little summary of the great history of quantum mechanics here, but that would of course be a gross oversimplification. Indeed, up to now we’ve completely overlooked de Broglie, who in 1923 developed a very different image of quantum theory debroglie1925 . In fact, unlike the Copenhagen school, which was strongly dominated by the positivist and instrumentalist currents of his time, de Broglie sought to unify quantum theory and classical physics in a mechanical vision in which particles have trajectories but are guided by waves debroglie1927 ; Solvay ; debroglie1930 . This essentially deterministic vision differed greatly from Born’s probabilistic and stochastic version, which profoundly rejected any return to an approach involving particle trajectories in space-time or configuration space. De Broglie’s point of view also differed sharply from Schrödinger’s approach, which eliminated trajectories and retained only the wave. To celebrate the birth of quantum mechanics, we propose to look back at the birth of de Broglie’s theory, which has often been overlooked. The aim will be to recall the assumptions on which this original dynamical approach is based, and also to discuss the particular conditions and constraints of this theory that would allow it to be generalized. Indeed, as de Broglie’s approach is essentially based on an analogy with classical mechanics (as we shall recall, starting with the Hamilton Jacobi equation), the question immediately arises as to whether this analogy is complete. Indeed, the Hamilton Jacobi approach, which is linked to fluid dynamics and the Euler-Bernoulli equation, is not the most generic description of an inviscid continuous fluid. In fact, extensions were discussed in the 1950s by Takabayasi Takabayasi and Schönberg Schonberg after Bohm’s rediscovery of de Broglie’s theory in 1952 BohmI . In this article, we would like to re-analyze these somewhat forgotten approaches in the context of modern de Broglie-Bohm theory BohmHiley ; Holland ; Teufel ; Durr . This article is organized as follows: In section II , we will review the basics of de Broglie Bohm theory, with particular reference to Madelung’s hydrodynamic formalism. In section III , we discuss the ’mainstream’ interpretation of de Broglie Bohm’s theory at present, i.e. the so-called ’nomological’ interpretation of Dürr, Goldstein Zanghì (DGZ) DGZ1 ; Allori . We criticize this interpretation and show its physical limitations. In section IV , we show how we can move beyond the nomological interpretation and seek to extend the accepted Bohmian theory. In this section, we focus on the Bohm-Vigier research program Bohmchaos ; Vigier taken up by Valentini Valentini ; Valentini2020 , which seeks to relax the statistical equilibrium conditions that usually give the famous Born rule in |\Psi|^{2} . In section V , we look at interpretations that seek to modify Bohm’s theory from a dynamic point of view. This essentially includes Bohm’s approaches involving stochastic terms. However, we are rather critical of this program and prefer to consider in section VI the extension of de Broglie Bohm theory involving a vorticity field associated with particle velocity. We show that this type of theory could nicely extend the framework of the de Broglie-Bohm approach, while defining a field that could potentially link up with the research proposed by Bohm-Vigier and Valentini. Finally, we conclude and summarize our analysis in section VII . II The de Broglie-Kennard-Bohm theory and the Madelung hydrodynamical approach First, we will briefly summarize the method de Broglie developed to obtain his wave-guided particle mechanics, based on Schrödinger’s wave theory. In fact, both de Broglie’s Solvay ; debroglie1930 and Schrödinger’s Schrodinger approach made extensive use of classical analogies with the famous Hamilton-Jacobi (HJ) mechanics, where classical particles are guided by a function S(q,t) known as the HJ action (for a technical discussion see Landau ; GoldsteinB ; Brillouin ; Holland ). In this formalism, the guiding formula for the system described by the position variable q(t) is given by: \displaystyle m_{k}\frac{d}{dt}q_{k}(t)=\partial_{k}S(q(t),t) (1) with \partial_{k}:=\frac{\partial}{\partial q_{k}} and m_{k} the particles masses k=1,...,3N (here m_{k} are degenerated three by three: m_{1}=m_{2}=m_{3} ,…, m_{3N-2}=m_{3N-1}=m_{3N} ). This dynamics corresponds to the nonrelativistic HJ equation \displaystyle-\partial_{t}S(q,t)=\sum_{k}\frac{1}{2m_{k}}(\partial_{k}S(q,t))^{2}+V(q,t) \displaystyle=\sum_{k}\frac{m_{k}}{2}(\dot{q}_{k})^{2}+V(q,t) (2) in the presence of external potential V(q,t) (we use \partial_{t}:=\frac{\partial}{\partial t} ). -\partial_{t}S plays the role of the energy and the HJ relation is more generally written -\partial_{t}S=H(q,p,t) with H the Hamiltonian and p=\partial_{q}S(q,t):=[p_{1}=\partial_{k}S(q,t),...,p_{3N}=\partial_{3N}S(q,t)] the momenta of the particles. De Broglie’s beautiful central idea is to retain the guiding formula Eq. 1 but modify the HJ wave equation Eq. 2 by replacing it with the Schrödinger equation \displaystyle i\partial_{t}\Psi(q,t)=\sum_{k}\frac{-1}{2m_{k}}\partial^{2}_{k}\Psi(q,t)+V(q,t)\Psi(q,t) (3) (in the following we assume natural units \hbar=c=1 ). The

Read the complete text