Systems-of-Systems for Environmental Sustainability: A Systematic Mapping Study
Ana Clara Araújo Gomes da Silva, Gilmar Teixeira Junior, Lívia Mancine C. de Campos, Renato F. Bulcão-Neto, Valdemar Vicente Graciano Neto · 2025
Read Systems-of-Systems for Environmental Sustainability: A Systematic Mapping Study by Ana Clara Araújo Gomes da Silva, Gilmar Teixeira Junior, Lívia Mancine C. de Campos, Renato F. Bulcão-Neto, Valdemar Vicente Graciano Neto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-20021.txt.
Introduction
Ana Gomes da Silva and co-authors map research on systems-of-systems for the environment, in a 2025 study. A system-of-systems joins many independent systems into one larger whole. Such joined systems could manage natural resources more wisely. Green uses have been reviewed for smart cities, but not for the whole field.
The team ran a structured search across four scientific databases. Hundreds of papers were screened down to a few dozen that fit. Most work clusters in smart cities and smart power grids. Uses like green farming and wildfire prevention remain thin. The map lists the main hurdles researchers face and the open chances they miss. Funders can see where the field is crowded and where it is empty.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ana Clara Araújo Gomes da Silva, Gilmar Teixeira Junior, Lívia Mancine C. de Campos, Renato F. Bulcão-Neto, Valdemar Vicente Graciano Neto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-20021
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Systems-of-Systems for Environmental Sustainability: A Systematic Mapping Study Ana Clara Araújo Gomes da Silva, Gilmar Teixeira Junior, Lívia Mancine C. de Campos, Renato F. Bulcão-Neto, Valdemar Vicente Graciano Neto Abstract Environmental sustainability in Systems-of-Systems (SoS) is an emerging field that seeks to integrate technological solutions to promote the efficient management of natural resources. While systematic reviews address sustainability in the context of Smart Cities (a category of SoS), a systematic study synthesizing the existing knowledge on environmental sustainability applied to SoS in general does not exist. Although literature includes other types of sustainability, such as financial and social, this study focuses on environmental sustainability, analyzing how SoS contribute to sustainable practices such as carbon emission reduction, energy efficiency, and biodiversity conservation. We conducted a Systematic Mapping Study to identify the application domains of SoS in sustainability, the challenges faced, and research opportunities. We planned and executed a research protocol including an automated search over four scientific databases. Of 926 studies retrieved, we selected, analyzed, and reported the results of 39 relevant studies. Our findings reveal that most studies focus on Smart Cities and Smart Grids, while applications such as sustainable agriculture and wildfire prevention are less explored. We identified challenges such as system interoperability, scalability, and data governance. Finally, we propose future research directions for SoS and environmental sustainability. I Introduction Environmental sustainability has been a central theme in science and public policy formulation. Environmental challenges such as climate change, deforestation, and pollution have driven this global agenda, leading to the development of environmental policies, international agreements, and innovative technological solutions [ 1 , 2 ] . To mitigate these impacts, innovative technological solutions are essential, and Systems-of-Systems (SoS) emerge as a promising approach, enabling the integration of multiple independent systems to achieve common goals. [ 3 ] Although SoS have been widely studied in domains such as Smart Cities , Smart Grids , and ecosystem management [ 4 ] , their relationship with environmental sustainability remains fragmented and underexplored [ 5 ] . To bridge this gap, this study conducts a Systematic Mapping Study (SMS) to analyze the role of SoS in natural resource management and the promotion of sustainable practices. The focus is on constituent systems, such as drones and cyber-physical systems, applied to environmental conservation, wildfire prevention, and biodiversity preservation. The research follows rigorous protocols for selection, extraction, and data synthesis [ 6 ] , allowing for the identification of patterns and trends in the use of SoS for sustainability. The remainder of this study is organized as follows: Section II provides an overview of SoS and Sustainability; Section III details the research method; Section IV discusses the results; and Section V concludes the study, addressing limitations and future research directions. II SoS and Sustainability SoS can be classified into different subtypes depending on the level of autonomy and coordination among their constituent systems [ 3 ] . The most relevant subtypes include Directed SoS, which has centralized management, Acknowledged SoS, which allows limited autonomy among constituents, and Collaborative SoS, where independent systems interact voluntarily. In environmental applications, these classifications influence how sustainability-oriented SoS are structured and managed. Emerging technologies such as the Internet of Things (IoT) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) play a central role in enabling these systems [ 7 ] , allowing real-time environmental data collection and analysis [ 8 ] . Additionally, they enable early disaster detection, optimization of water and energy resource usage, and support for decision-making in environmental policies [ 9 ] . The literature presents several successful cases of SoS applications for sustainability. One example is the implementation of Smart Grids, which integrate multiple renewable energy sources into intelligent electrical networks, optimizing electricity supply and consumption [ 10 ] . These networks enable more efficient energy distribution management, reducing waste and contributing to the decarbonization of the electricity sector [ 11 ] . SoS play a key role in biodiversity conservation by integrating multiple independent systems to monitor ecosystems and support conservation strategies. These systems enable large-scale environmental observation, allowing for improved decision-making in habitat preservation and resource management. The use of remote sensing, automated data collection, and real-time analytics enhances biodiversity protection, helping to mitigate threats such as deforestation and habitat degradation. Studies suggest that the synergy between SoS and sustainability has been widely discussed as a promising approach to addressing complex environmental challenges [ 12 , 13 ] . However, research indicates that the effective adoption of these systems depends on overcoming technical and institutional barriers, including interoperability, cybersecurity, and data governance [ 14 , 15 ] . Additionally, the literature highlights that advancing SoS for sustainability requires closer collaboration between governments, industries, and the scientific community, promoting integrated strategies to enable scalable and resilient solutions [ 16 ] . III Mapping Method This study was conducted under the principles of systematic literature studies, following the guidelines of a Systematic Mapping Study (SMS) as established by Kitchenham and Charters [ 6 ] . III-A Step 1: Planning The study objective was formulated using the GQM (Goal Question Metric) approach proposed by Basili and Weiss [ 17 ] . The goal of this study was to analyze examples of SoS applied to environmental sustainability as reported in the specialized literature, with the purpose of characterizing them from the perspective of researchers in the context of sustainable natural resource management and mitigation of environmental impacts . This objective led to the formulation of five research questions (RQs) and one research sub-question (RSQ): RQ01: What SoS domain is reported in the study? Justification: Specifying the SoS domain addressed, such as Smart Cities, Smart Grids, or Smart Farming, is essential for mapping the study’s application areas, facilitating the analysis of similarities and differences between domains and their respective needs. RSQ1.1: Within the identified domain, which SoS subtype is best suited for natural resource management? Justification: Mapping the specific characteristics that make certain systems more effective in this context facilitates their replication and adaptation in other areas. RQ02: What are the main challenges faced? Justification: Analyzing the challenges and opportunities of integrating SoS for sustainability allows us to understand the barriers encountered and the potential benefits of implementing these systems on a large scale, guiding future research and public policies. RQ03: What types of constituents are reported? Justification: Understanding the components that make up the SoS is essential for assessing system complexity, interoperability, and the specific roles of each element in achieving the overall system goals. RQ04: What are the main functionalities of the reported constituent systems? Justification: Mapping how systems collaborate to achieve the overall objectives of the SoS also allows for assessing how these functionalities can be optimized or replicated in other contexts. RQ05: What are the missions and emerging behaviors? Justification: Understanding how systems interact and what unexpected or innovative outcomes may arise from these interactions is crucial. This provides insights into the adaptability and overall impact of the SoS. III-B Step 2: Mapping Protocol The SMS followed a rigorous protocol composed of the following steps: (i) definition of the search string, (ii) selection of databases, (iii) application of inclusion (CI) and exclusion (CE) criteria, (iv) selection process, and (v) data extraction and analysis. For conducting the study, we used the