Applications of the Quantum Phase Difference Estimation Algorithm to the Excitation Energies in Spin Systems on a NISQ Device
Boni Paul, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, Kenji Sugisaki, B. P. Das · 2025
Read Applications of the Quantum Phase Difference Estimation Algorithm to the Excitation Energies in Spin Systems on a NISQ Device by Boni Paul, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, Kenji Sugisaki, B. P. Das (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-19809.txt.
Introduction
Boni Paul and co-authors ran a quantum gap finder on today's noisy hardware in two thousand twenty-five. Energy gaps decide how spin systems behave. Classic phase estimation needs heavy controlled operations. Their phase difference method skips those controls. Two eigenstates are superposed to read the gap directly. Small Heisenberg spin chains were the test systems.
Arrangements ranged from symmetric to frustrated. Coupling strengths varied across the trials. The algorithm held up on a real noisy device. Matchgate tricks kept circuits shallow enough. Early fault-tolerant claims were verified in practice. Quantum chemists watch such gap tools closely. The work shows NISQ machines doing honest physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Boni Paul, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, Kenji Sugisaki, B. P. Das |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-19809
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Applications of the Quantum Phase Difference Estimation Algorithm to the Excitation Energies in Spin Systems on a NISQ Device Boni Paul, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, Kenji Sugisaki, B. P. Das Abstract The Quantum Phase Difference Estimation (QPDE) algorithm, as an extension of the Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE), is a quantum algorithm designed to compute the differences of two eigenvalues of a unitary operator by exploiting the quantum superposition of two eigenstates. Unlike QPE, QPDE is free of controlled-unitary operations, and is suitable for calculations on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. We present the implementation and verification of a novel early fault-tolerant QPDE algorithm for determining energy gaps across diverse spin system configurations using NISQ devices. The algorithm is applied to the systems described by two and three-spin Heisenberg Hamiltonians with different geometric arrangements and coupling strengths, including symmetric, asymmetric, spin-frustrated, and non-frustrated configurations. By leveraging the match gate-like structure of the time evolution operator of Heisenberg Hamiltonian, we achieve constant-depth quantum circuits suitable for NISQ hardware implementation. Our results on IBM quantum processors show remarkable accuracy ranging from 85% to 93%, demonstrating excellent agreement with classical calculations even in the presence of hardware noise. The methodology incorporates sophisticated quantum noise suppression techniques, including Pauli Twirling and Dynamical Decoupling, and employs an adaptive framework. Our findings demonstrate the practical viability of the QPDE algorithm for quantum many-body simulations on current NISQ hardware, establishing a robust framework for future applications. I Introduction Quantum computing has emerged as a transformative field with the potential to revolutionize approaches across various domains, including secure communications [ 1 ] , financial modeling [ 2 ] , machine learning [ 3 ] , combinatorial optimization [ 4 ] , and materials and drug discovery [ 5 ] . One of its key strengths lies in its ability to address problems that are intractable for classical computers, especially those involving quantum many-body systems. Classical computational techniques often face significant challenges due to the exponential growth in complexity, especially when trying to calculate larger and strongly correlated systems, while quantum computers are expected to handle them efficiently [ 6 ] . Researchers have developed various quantum algorithms to effectively determine energy eigenvalues within quantum systems. Two notable techniques are the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) [ 7 , 8 ] and Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE) [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . VQE employs a combination of quantum and classical computing principles, optimizing variational parameters in a parameterised quantum circuit to minimize the energy expectation value to find the ground state, which is well-suited for today’s available noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) [ 12 ] devices. However, VQE also encounters challenges like complex optimization with barren plateaus, rapid increase in shot count to reduce statistical error, reliance on classical optimizers, increased error rates with deeper circuits, difficulty in designing an efficient ansatz, and so on [ 13 ] . Conversely, fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQC) are often seen as a distant possibility. QPE as an FTQC algorithm is expected to provide a more accurate eigenvalue estimate but it requires deep and complex quantum circuits. This complexity renders QPE demanding in terms of resources and prone to errors with the quantum devices currently available. Additionally, the process of calculating energy differences between quantum states typically requires multiple executions for each state in QPE or VQE, amplifying the computational efforts and highlighting the necessity for quantum algorithms that can more efficiently compute energy gaps with reduced resource usage. We emphasize that the estimation of energy differences between two eigenstates is an important task, especially in chemistry, because the information we can extract from experiments (e.g., spectroscopic measurements) is usually the energy differences, such as excitation energies, ionization energies, and reaction energy barriers, rather than the total energy itself. A Quantum Phase Difference Estimation (QPDE) [ 14 ] algorithm proposed by one of the authors of this paper addresses these challenges by offering a more efficient alternative for the energy gap estimation. It is designed to compute the difference between two eigenvalues of a unitary operator directly, using the quantum superposition of two eigenstates, and it is free of controlled-unitary operations. The latter feature is important especially when executing the algorithm on hardware with limited connectivity, while crosstalk errors further exacerbate implementation challenges. It should be noted that the control-unitary free implementations of the QPE algorithms have also been discussed in recent papers. [ 15 , 16 ] As quantum hardware progresses, particularly with developments in FTQC, algorithms like QPDE will become increasingly important. QPDE offers a scalable and practical solution for quantum simulations on both immediate experimental applications and long-term use in large-scale quantum simulations. While much of the existing research has focused on using this QPDE algorithm for challenges in quantum chemistry, such as vertical ionization energies, singlet–triplet energy gaps, and vertical excitation energies [ 14 ] , total energies [ 17 ] , and numerical energy gradients [ 18 ] . It also shows promise in atomic and molecular physics for fine structure splitting calculations [ 19 ] . Recently, QPDE demonstration using superconducting quantum processor has also been reported [ 20 ] , with the aid of MPO-based classical compression of the quantum circuit and error suppression module provided by Q-CTRL [ 21 ] . Moreover, spin models, while relatively simpler, serve as an excellent testing ground for this quantum algorithm on real quantum devices, offering important benchmarks for future studies involving more complex quantum many-body systems. Spin systems represent a foundational class of quantum many-body models that play a pivotal role in understanding a wide array of physical phenomena. These systems exhibit a diverse range of behaviours, including quantum coherence, magnetic ordering, phase transitions, and frustration. By applying the QPDE algorithm to spin systems, it becomes possible to perform highly accurate energy gap calculations, yielding deeper insights into their quantum characteristics. In this study, we focused on the spin-state energy gap of two and three-spin systems described by the Heisenberg Hamiltonian as illustrated in Fig. 1 , and demonstrated a QPDE-based direct calculation of the energy gap using IBM Quantum processors. Through the multi-step pipeline optimization, the quantum circuit for the time evolution operator becomes a constant depth independent of the Trotter step, which allows us to compute the spin state energy gap with >87 % accuracy. 1 2 J_{12}=1 E_{T}=-\frac{1}{2} , E_{S}=\frac{3}{2} E_{S}-E_{T}=2.0 Two-Spin System 1 2 3 J_{12}=1 J_{23}=1 E_{Q}=-1 , E_{D_{2}}=0 E_{D_{2}}-E_{Q}=1 3 Spin Linear Chain 1 2 3 J_{12}=1 J_{23}=1 J_{13}=1 J_{12}=J_{23}=J_{13}=1 E_{Q}=-1.5 E_{D_{2}}=E_{D_{1}}=1.5 E_{D_{2}}-E_{Q}=3.0 3 Spin Frustrated Triangle 1 2 3 J_{12}=1 J_{23}=1 J_{13}=2 J_{12}=J_{23}=1 , J_{13}=2 E_{Q}=-2 , E_{D_{1}}=1 , E_{D_{2}}=3 E_{D_{2}}-E_{Q}=5.0 E_{D_{1}}-E_{Q}=3.0 3 Spin Non-Frustrated Triangle 1 2 3 J_{12}=1 J_{23}=1.1 J_{12}=1,J_{23}=1.1,J_{13}=0 E_{D_{1}}-E_{Q}=3.15 3 Spin Asymmetric Linear Chain Figure 1 : Schematic representation of various spin systems and their resulting simplified excitation energies. Here, J_{ij} is coupling strength between spins i and j . E_{T} , E_{S} , E_{Q} , and E_{D_{i}} represent triplet, singlet, quartet, and doublet energies, respectively. The paper is organized as follows: Section II presents the Heisenberg spin model and the QPDE algorithm. Section III investigates excitation energies in small spin systems with different geometries, considering both symmetric and asymmetric spin interactions using the QPDE algorithm. Finally, Section IV