Project Alexandria: Towards Freeing Scientific Knowledge from Copyright Burdens via LLMs
2025
Read Project Alexandria: Towards Freeing Scientific Knowledge from Copyright Burdens via LLMs (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-19413.txt.
Introduction
Paywalls and licenses keep much research writing locked away, even though the facts inside could be shared. Christoph Schuhmann and co-authors argue in 2025 that language models can free those facts lawfully. Their project, Alexandria, turns papers into what they call Knowledge Units: structured records of things, traits, and links, stripped of writing style.
Legal analysis under German law and United States fair use doctrine supports the approach, the team says. Tests across four fields found the units kept about ninety-five percent of the facts, judged by quiz answers. The authors share open tools for making the units. They hope the method widens access to knowledge while respecting the rights of authors and publishers.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2025 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-19413
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Project Alexandria: Towards Freeing Scientific Knowledge from Copyright Burdens via LLMs Abstract Paywalls, licenses and copyright rules often restrict the broad dissemination and reuse of scientific knowledge. We take the position that it is both legally and technically feasible to extract the scientific knowledge in scholarly texts. Current methods, like text embeddings, fail to reliably preserve factual content, and simple paraphrasing may not be legally sound. We propose a new idea for the community to adopt: convert scholarly documents into knowledge preserving, but style agnostic representations we term Knowledge Units using LLMs. These units use structured data capturing entities, attributes and relationships without stylistic content. We provide evidence that Knowledge Units (1) form a legally defensible framework for sharing knowledge from copyrighted research texts, based on legal analyses of German copyright law and U.S. Fair Use doctrine, and (2) preserve most ( ∼ \sim 95%) factual knowledge from original text, measured by MCQ performance on facts from the original copyrighted text across four research domains. Freeing scientific knowledge from copyright promises transformative benefits for scientific research and education by allowing language models to reuse important facts from copyrighted text. To support this, we share open-source tools for converting research documents into Knowledge Units. Overall, our work posits the feasibility of democratizing access to scientific knowledge while respecting copyright. Christoph Schuhmann 1∘ Gollam Rabby 3,1∘ Ameya Prabhu 2,4⋄ Tawsif Ahmed 1,2⋄ Andreas Hochlehnert 2,4⋄ Huu Nguyen 1,2,5⋄ Nick Akinci 6⋄ Ludwig Schmidt 2,7† Robert Kaczmarczyk 1,10† Sören Auer 3,8† Jenia Jitsev 1,2,9† Matthias Bethge 2,4† 1 LAION 2 Open- \Psi (Open-Sci) Collective 3 L3S Research Center, Leibniz University Hannover 4 Tübingen AI Center, University of Tübingen 5 Ontocord.ai 6 Heidrich Rechtsanwälte 7 Stanford University 8 TIB—Leibniz Information Centre for Science and Technology 9 Juelich Supercomputing Center 10 Technical University of Munich, Germany Knowledge-Units Database Project Page Codebase 0 0 footnotetext: ∘ Equal lead ⋄ Equal core contribution † Equal supervision Refer to Author Contributions section for details. 1 Introduction Scientific publishing has grown tremendously in recent decades ( White, 2019 ) , but many researchers still lack access to crucial papers ( Suber, 2012 ) . This access gap exists even in the wealthiest academic libraries in the world and is much worse for Researchers in developing countries, small independent labs or for independent scholars and educators. In 2008, Harvard had 98,900 subscriptions, Yale 73,900 and the best-funded research library in India only 10,600 ( Suber, 2012 ) . This disparity, coupled with the unsustainable surge in academic journal subscription costs, has been a pivotal driving force behind the Open Access (OA) movement. Although OA has become more common, this scholarly communication crisis still remains an issue today. In July 2018 up to 200 German institutions lost access to journals of Elsevier ( Else, 2018 ) for five years after unsuccessful negotiations. While the negotiations since succeeded this temporary cut from new publications had a measurable effect on publishing behavior ( Fraser et al., 2023 ) . Furthermore, in 2019 major US universities canceled their subscriptions to certain journals stating unreasonable price surges as the reason ( Gaind, 2019 ) . This barrier slows scientific progress and as such “copyright laws work counter to prevailing scientific norms” ( Stodden, 2009 ) . Why this position paper? Recent advances in language models (LLMs), like GPT-4 ( OpenAI, 2023 ) , Llama ( Touvron et al., 2023 ) , and recently Deepseek R1 ( Guo et al., 2025 ) allow us to democratize access to scholarly knowledge, such as answering questions based on existing scientific research. The core issue lies in scholarly texts containing both information and artistic elements — such as wording, style, and unique phrasing — of which the latter is protected by copyright. With LLMs, for the first time, we can extract knowledge at scale and free scientific content while respecting authors’ rights to copyright. Contribution. In this paper, we take the position that separating the factual information in scholarly works from the copyrighted creative expression is technically and legally feasible . We advocate for a Project Alexandria , to realize this vision by creating Knowledge Units using LLMs, which systematically separate reusable information from the artistic expressions inherent in scholarly writings. Knowledge Units are structured records capturing entities, relationships, and attributes extracted from scholarly texts in a database. Our study tests the legal and technical feasibility of preserving scientific knowledge that researchers and students need to learn or apply. We posit it must satisfy two desiderata: 1. Legal Defensibility. Under interpretations of German copyright law and the U.S. Fair Use doctrine, facts themselves are not subject to copyright protection, only their creative expression. In addition to these jurisdictions, concept of the idea-expression dichotomy is also adopted by many other jurisdictions, such as the UK and India ( Jain, 2012 ; Adhikari, 2021 ) . We provide a legal analysis showcasing that Knowledge Units could preserve only the factual substance — definitions, measurements, causal relationships, and methodological details. They are designed explicitly to exclude the original phrasing and stylistic elements, offering what we believe is a legally permissible way to share scientific knowledge openly. 2. Information Preservation. We evaluate the fidelity of Knowledge Units through performing question-answering (QA) experiments using them, where language models answer multiple-choice questions based on abstracts and full-text articles across biology, physics, mathematics, and computer science. Models provided with Knowledge Units achieve high accuracy, nearly matching the performance of those given the original texts. This provides evidence that the vast majority of relevant information should be accurately captured in this format. Impact. Freeing factual information from copyright restrictions can help more researchers, educators, and language models access and share facts from scholarly work. As a result, researchers worldwide can discuss and build on one another’s findings without legal uncertainty or relying on expensive paywalls. We believe this is a key step toward a more open and inclusive global research community. We present a clear vision, a practical mechanism, and an open-source infrastructure aimed at fostering a more inclusive and collaborative global scientific ecosystem. In the rest of this paper, we present how Knowledge Units work, discuss the legal principles that support this approach, show evidence of high factual retention, and consider alternate perspectives. We conclude by describing future plans to build massive open databases of factual knowledge and encourage the community to adopt this approach. 2 Knowledge Units To extract knowledge from a document, its text is segmented into manageable sections or paragraphs. Each paragraph is subsequently processed by an LM to identify entities, along with their attributes and relationships, resulting in a structured output referred to as a Knowledge Unit (Table 1 ). Knowledge Unit (KU): A set of entities, attributes, and relationships, capturing a short original text excerpt. Each Knowledge Unit captures: • Entities : the core concepts or objects in the paragraph, with relevant attributes. • Relationships : statements that connect or link entities, such as causal or definitional relationships. • Attributes : statements that describe entities according to the excerpt. • Context summary : A few sentences summarizing the previous knowledge units. • Sentence MinHash : A list of MinHashes of the source sentences used to generate this KU. Table 1: Converting