Optimal COVID-19 Vaccine Prioritization by Age Depends Critically on Inter-group Contacts and Vaccination Rates

Iker Atienza-Diez, Gabriel Rodriguez-Maroto, Saúl Ares, Susanna Manrubia · 2025

Read Optimal COVID-19 Vaccine Prioritization by Age Depends Critically on Inter-group Contacts and Vaccination Rates by Iker Atienza-Diez, Gabriel Rodriguez-Maroto, Saúl Ares, Susanna Manrubia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-19292.txt.

Introduction

Who should get a scarce vaccine first is a math ask with a body's answer, and the math turns on how folk mix. Iker Atienza-Diez and three co-authors ran the full grid for Spain in 2025: nine age bands, six shot speeds, and two maps of who meets whom, one free and one locked down. Three hundred sixty-two thousand orders were weighed in all, with re-infection in the frame.

With free mixing, the best order barely strays from old-to-young, and the gain is a sliver. Lock the mixing down, as in 2020, and the prize grows fat at mid shot speeds: spread can be halted outright. The team stress the weld: shot plans and contact cuts win or lose as one act, not two.

Catalog record

CREATORIker Atienza-Diez, Gabriel Rodriguez-Maroto, Saúl Ares, Susanna Manrubia
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-19292

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Optimal COVID-19 Vaccine Prioritization by Age Depends Critically on Inter-group Contacts and Vaccination Rates Iker Atienza-Diez, Gabriel Rodriguez-Maroto, Saúl Ares, Susanna Manrubia Abstract The limited availability of COVID-19 vaccines has prompted extensive research on optimal vaccination strategies. Previous studies have considered various non-pharmaceutical interventions, vaccine efficacy, and distribution strategies. In this work, we address the combined effects of inter-group contacts and vaccination rates under contact reduction, analyzing the Spanish population’s demographic and age group contact patterns and incorporating reinfection dynamics. We conduct an exhaustive analysis, evaluating 362,880 permutations of 9 age groups across 6 vaccination rates and two distinct, empirically quantified scenarios for social contacts. Our results show that at intermediate-to-high vaccination rates with unrestricted social contacts, optimal age-based vaccination strategies only slightly deviate from older-to-younger prioritization, yielding marginal reductions in deaths and infections. However, when significant reductions in social contacts are enforced —similar to the lockdowns in 2020—, there are substantial improvements, particularly at moderate vaccination rates. These restrictions lead to a transition where infection propagation is halted, a scenario that became achievable during the pandemic with the observed vaccination rates. Our findings emphasize the importance of combining appropriate social contact reductions with vaccination to optimize age-based vaccination strategies, underscoring the complex, nonlinear dynamics involved in pandemic dynamics and the necessity for tailored, context-specific interventions. I Introduction Compartmental models have been broadly used to characterize the dynamics of infection propagation in a variety of scenarios. Though most studies have addressed the impact of refining basic susceptible-infected-recovered dynamics Kermack and McKendrick 1927 to include a multiplicity of additional states Hethcote 2000 , others have thoroughly explored the effect of various external interventions. The use of such models has become widespread, addressing issues such as the effect of contention measures Arenas et al. 2020 ; Wong et al. 2020 ; Ventura et al. 2022 , of the immune state of the population Weitz et al. 2020 , of population density Wong and Li 2020 , or of vaccine rollout Wagner et al. 2022 , among others. One of the major strengths of modeling approaches is that they offer the possibility of comparing various scenarios under similar conditions. Altogether, such studies have refined our understanding of epidemic dynamics and of the role played by multiple relevant variables. The availability of a vaccine against SARS-CoV-2 largely before the infected population attained a sufficiently high immunity level to halt propagation prompted the study of optimal protocols to administer available vaccine doses Matrajt et al. 2021 ; Schulenburg et al. 2022 ; Gonzalez-Parra et al. 2024 . Due to the high, positive correlation of SARS-CoV-2 mortality with age of the infected individual, there was a largely preferred protocol of administration where vaccination of the elderly was prioritized, to continue in decreasing age order once most vulnerable groups had been protected. Results obtained through models incorporating a variety of scenarios, but implementing COVID-19 features, systematically supported that mortality and years of life lost were minimized if the population over 60 to 70 years old was given priority Bubar et al. 2021 ; Tran et al. 2021 ; Zhao et al. 2021 ; Gonzalez-Parra et al. 2024 ; Nguyen et al. 2023 . Some of these studies used data from sociological studies elaborated in the absence of social contact limitations or, in the best case, implemented such limitations in a phenomenological way, using for instance effective values of the reproduction number in the simulations Bubar et al. 2021 ; Zhao et al. 2021 . However, modifications in social contact patterns during an epidemic event can change due to both non-pharmaceutical interventions and as a result of unsupervised responses of individuals Pan et al. 2020 ; Manrubia and Zanette 2022 in a highly heterogeneous way Caselli et al. 2022 . During the COVID-19 pandemic, patterns of contact between individuals were severely modified Ayouni et al. 2021 , differently affecting citizens involved in public services, children, or elders, for example. In this contribution, we carry out an exhaustive exploration of age-based vaccination protocols by measuring the reduction in deaths and infections obtained under various scenarios. Our baseline situation considers an age-structured population with 9 age groups and a specific demographic structure: the Spanish population. In our first scenario, no restrictions to social contacts are implemented, though empirical data regarding inter- and intra-group contacts is used Mistry et al. 2021 . Under the previous conditions, we carry out simulations with a compartmental model that takes into account partial immunity and, therefore, reinfection of individuals, as well as vaccination at various rates. All possible orderings of the population, attending to the age of the different groups defined in our study, are simulated. This is a total of 9!=362,880 possibilities for each vaccination rate. As a result, we are able to identify the best possible protocol and quantify its benefits with respect to the baseline case. The whole study is repeated when lockdown measures are implemented, using the results of two studies Backer et al. 2021 ; Gimma et al. 2022 that have measured contact reduction in different age groups. Our findings align with results in the literature under no contact restrictions, showing clearly that the largest benefit in terms of mortality reduction is obtained when vaccination prioritizes elderly people. However, we obtain a substantial advantage of vaccinating first people in their thirties under lockdown conditions. In this second situation, reductions in mortality and in number of infections can be simultaneously optimized under similar vaccinating strategies. We also show that there is a non-trivial interaction between the degree of social contacts and the vaccination rate, and that only a suitable combination of both variables can yield the largest beneficial effects. II Model and Data II.1 SIYRD: a model with reinfection and vaccination In a previous study Rodriguez-Maroto et al. 2023 , we introduced SIYRD, a compartmental model with five different classes: Susceptible (S), Infected (I), Reinfected (Y), Recovered (R) and Dead (D) individuals. The model implemented two main novelties: vaccination (S individuals move to class R upon vaccination) and reinfection (R individuals can move to the reinfected class Y). Only vaccination of susceptible individuals is considered, and an equivalence between vaccination and disease overcoming regarding the immune state is assumed. Empirical studies have found no significant differences in recovered individuals between the immune effects elicited by vaccination or by infection Bubb and et al 2021 ; Shenai et al. 2021 , thus supporting this hypothesis. Numerical and analytical studies of the SIYRD model showed that the introduction of reinfections causes the appearance of very long transients where the disease behaves as quasi-endemic. Extending the model to include a synthetic population divided into two age groups revealed that at high vaccination rates —whenever disease impact intensifies with age— the optimal vaccination strategy shifts from prioritizing the elderly to prioritizing younger individuals. Here, our main goal is the exhaustive exploration and quantification of this observed effect in realistic scenarios. To this end, we extend the SIYRD model to encompass 9 different age groups. This allows us to implement the demographic structure of the population and inter- and intra-group empirical contact matrices in two situations: without and with limitations to social contacts. The numerical analysis uses data from Spanish demography and COVID-19 data, though it

Read the complete text