Higher derivative holography and temperature dependence of QGP viscosities
Thomas Apostolidis a, Umut Gürsoy b, Edwan Préau b · 2025
Read Higher derivative holography and temperature dependence of QGP viscosities by Thomas Apostolidis a, Umut Gürsoy b, Edwan Préau b (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-19195.txt.
Introduction
Thomas Apostolidis, Umut Gürsoy, and Edwan Préau use gravity based models in 2025 to study how a hot soup of quarks and gluons flows. This plasma filled the early universe and is made today in heavy ion collisions. Fresh analyses of collision data show that its resistance to flow changes with heat in a non plain way, for both shear and bulk flow.
The team adds higher order corrections to a five dimensional model of the plasma. They fix the model's free parts by matching the collision based findings. Their work also yields the bulk flow resistance of a known holographic theory as a side product. Treated in the standard stepwise way, the corrections clash with the data. The paper explores ways to resolve that clash, which bears on how well gravity models can mirror real plasma.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thomas Apostolidis a, Umut Gürsoy b, Edwan Préau b |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-19195
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Higher derivative holography and temperature dependence of QGP viscosities Thomas Apostolidis a, Umut Gürsoy b, Edwan Préau b Abstract Recent Bayesian analyses of heavy ion collision data have established a non-trivial temperature dependence of the shear and bulk viscosity per entropy. Motivated by this, we consider higher derivative corrections to realistic, bottom-up holographic models of quark-gluon plasma based on five-dimensional Einstein-dilaton theories and determine the dilaton potentials in the higher derivative terms by matching the Bayesian analyses. A byproduct of our analysis is the bulk viscosity that follows from the holographic V-QCD theory. Higher derivative corrections when treated perturbatively lead to tension with existing data. We investigate possible resolutions. † † subheader: 1 Introduction Heavy-ion collisions at RHIC and LHC provide a unique window into the transport properties of QCD; see, e.g. Busza:2018rrf for a recent review. The transport properties of the quark-gluon plasma produced in these experiments can be characterized by the transport coefficients that enter the hydrodynamic description of the fluid, most prominent of which are the shear and the bulk viscosities that are usually defined per entropy, i.e. \eta/s and \zeta/s respectively 1 1 1 Another coefficient at first-order in the hydrodynamic derivative expansion, conductivity, is relevant at finite quark density or in the presence of electromagnetic fields, which are ignored here. . Knowledge of these coefficients requires computing stress tensor retarded Green’s functions at finite temperature. The only available first-principles method, lattice QCD, is not quite suitable for this task: it is based on the Euclidean formulation, and the analytic continuation to the Lorentzian signature contains large systematic errors, as this requires knowledge of the entire particle spectrum of QCD; see Meyer:2007ic ; Meyer:2007dy . Recently, a more phenomenological approach, based on Bayesian analysis of heavy-ion data, became available Nijs:2020ors ; Nijs:2020roc ; JETSCAPE:2020mzn , see section 2 . Here, one models the evolution of the quark-gluon plasma by hydrodynamics, e.g. 14-moment Müller-Israel-Stewart model Denicol:2014vaa , supplemented by initial conditions for the energy-momentum distribution of nucleons, e.g. provided by the Trento model Moreland:2014oya and a standard freezout procedure Cooper:1974mv to obtain the hadron distributions that are subsequently matched onto experimental data. This provides a probability distribution for the transport coefficients that characterize the hydrodynamic model. This approach also contains significant systematic errors resulting mainly from the modeling of the initial conditions and hydrodynamic evolution and the choice of the data sets used for matching. This can be clearly seen by comparing Bayesian analyses of Jetscape JETSCAPE:2020mzn versus Trajectum Nijs:2020ors ; Nijs:2020roc ; see Figures 1 and 2 . A crucial aspect that resulted from these analyses is the non-trivial temperature dependence of \eta/s and \zeta/s . Yet another complementary tool is provided by the holographic correspondence Maldacena:1997re ; Gubser:1998bc ; Witten:1998qj . A triumph of this approach was the calculation of \eta/s Policastro:2001yc at strong coupling that resulted in the universal value 1/(4\pi) that agrees well with the aforementioned Bayesian analyses Nijs:2020ors ; Nijs:2020roc ; JETSCAPE:2020mzn . Five-dimensional “bottom-up” holographic models of QCD-like large-N gauge theories have been developed to include the salient features of the theory such as confinement, gapped hadron spectrum, chiral symmetry breaking, QCD anomalies, etc. The type of models we will consider in this work are the large N improved holographic QCD (ihQCD) model Gursoy:2007cb ; Gursoy:2007er and its extension to include fundamental matter Jarvinen:2011qe in the Veneziano limit Veneziano:1976wm , with large N and large number of flavors with their ratio fixed. These theories naturally incorporate the running of the ’t Hooft coupling through a non-trivial profile of the dilaton \Phi in the holographic dimension. The latter is prompted by introduction of a dilaton potential V(\Phi) , whose large \Phi asymptotics (corresponding to the IR of the QFT, and the deep interior of the bulk geometry) are judiciously chosen such that the theory is confining. The extension of ihQCD and V-QCD to finite temperature was studied in Gursoy:2008bu ; Gursoy:2008za ; Gursoy:2009jd and Alho:2012mh ; Alho:2013hsa respectively, and incorporation of electromagnetic fields — relevant for off-central heavy-ion collisions and neutron star mergers — was considered in Gursoy:2016ofp ; Gursoy:2017wzz . All these holographic theories are built on two-derivative Einstein gravity, which universally fixes the value of \eta/s=1/(4\pi) Buchel:2003tz . In particular, the aforementioned non-trivial temperature dependence observed in experiment requires inclusion of 1/N or higher derivative corrections, realized, respectively, as loop and \alpha^{\prime} contributions in string theory. On the other hand, the temperature dependence of \zeta/s is already present at the two-derivative level and was investigated in the holographic models of QCD-like theories in Gubser:2008sz ; Gursoy:2009kk . See Buchel:2007mf ; Gubser:2008sz ; Buchel:2008uu ; Gursoy:2009kk ; Eling:2011ms ; Buchel:2011wx ; Buchel:2011uj ; Ballon-Bayona:2021tzw ; Demircik:2023lsn ; Demircik:2024bxd ; Buchel:2023fst ; CruzRojas:2024etx for a non-exhaustive list of other literature on bulk viscosity in the context of holography. Hence, one needs to incorporate the higher derivative corrections to Einstein-dilaton type holographic models to capture the nontrivial temperature profile of both \eta/s and \zeta/s , as first observed in Cremonini:2012ny . Such corrections have been considered early on in the context of violations of the conjectured KSS bound \eta/s\geq 1/(4\pi) Kovtun:2003wp ; Kovtun:2004de ; see e.g. Kats:2007mq ; Brigante:2007nu ; Myers:2008yi and Cremonini:2011iq for a review. However, these investigations were concerned with holographic duals of conformal field theories which are not suitable for QCD. On the other hand, literature on stringy corrections to holographic theories of QCD-like non-conformal and confining theories is rather limited 2 2 2 See Buchel:2010wf for the first such example. . Stringy corrections to ihQCD are discussed in Gursoy:2007cb ; Kiritsis:2009hu ; Alho:2015zua but not in the context of transport. Higher curvature corrections to shear transport in duals of Einstein-dilaton theories were studied in detail in Cremonini:2012ny , but no reliable temperature profile was available from heavy-ion data back then for neither \eta/s nor \zeta/s , so these corrections were not sufficiently constrained. Recently, there has been a revival of interest in determining the transport coefficients in holographic theories, including higher curvature corrections. While Demircik:2023lsn ; Demircik:2024bxd introduced a novel method to compute all transport coefficients by varying the background solutions, which in principle can be extended directly to higher curvature theories Gallegos , Buchel, Cremonini and Early Buchel:2023fst extended the standard techniques to beyond the supergravity approximation in generic theories, which is precisely the problem we want to address in this paper. The question we start with is whether we can construct realistic (in the aforementioned sense) holographic theories for the quark-gluon plasma beyond the supergravity approximation, which postdict the non-trivial temperature profile of \eta/s and \zeta/s observed in the Bayesian analyses JETSCAPE:2020mzn ; Nijs:2020ors ; Nijs:2020roc . This is a sensible approach to characterizing transport in strongly interacting quark-gluon matter, as it attempts to merge the two existing approaches, Bayesian analysis of heavy-ion data and holography, in the absence of a first-principle derivation. Specifically, we consider a 5D Einstein-dilaton theory with a dilaton potential V(\Phi) and with fourth order derivative corrections. Among the three types of corrections, i.e. R^{2} , R_{\mu\nu}^{2} and R_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}^{2} , one can show, by means of a field redefinition of the metric g_{\mu\nu}\to g_{\mu\nu}+ag_{\mu\nu}R+bR_{\mu\nu} with a and b constants, that only the last one contributes to the shear-viscosity per entropy \eta/s when the