Exploring the Origin of Solar Energetic Electrons II: Investigating Turbulent Coronal Acceleration

Ross Pallister, Natasha L. S. Jeffrey, Morgan Stores · 2025

Read Exploring the Origin of Solar Energetic Electrons II: Investigating Turbulent Coronal Acceleration by Ross Pallister, Natasha L. S. Jeffrey, Morgan Stores (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-19105.txt.

Introduction

Ross Pallister, Natasha Jeffrey, and Morgan Stores probe where the Sun's fastest electrons get their energy. Their two thousand twenty-five paper is the second in a series on this question. Hard X-ray sources near the Sun and particles caught in space hint at a shared source region. That region sits somewhere in the corona, the Sun's hot outer air. Its size and traits are still poorly pinned down.

The team runs a parameter study on a simulated acceleration region. They vary the speed of turbulent acceleration, its spread, and the region's length. Each change shifts the energy spectrum of electrons measured far from the Sun. The shifts fall in a range that can be checked against real data. The work narrows what the true region must look like.

Catalog record

CREATORRoss Pallister, Natasha L. S. Jeffrey, Morgan Stores
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-19105

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Exploring the Origin of Solar Energetic Electrons II: Investigating Turbulent Coronal Acceleration Ross Pallister, Natasha L. S. Jeffrey, Morgan Stores Abstract Non-thermal particle acceleration in the solar corona is evident from both remote hard X-ray (HXR) sources in the chromosphere and direct in-situ detection in the heliosphere. Correlation of spectral indices between remote and in-situ energy spectra presents the possibility of a common source acceleration region within the corona, however the properties and location of this region are not well constrained. To investigate this we perform a parameter study for both the properties of the ambient plasma of a simulated acceleration region and the turbulent acceleration profile acting on an initially isotropic thermal electron population. We find that the independently varying the turbulent acceleration timescale τ a ​ c ​ c \tau_{acc} , acceleration profile standard deviation σ \sigma and acceleration region length L L result in in-situ spectral index variation of between 0.5 and 2.0 at 1.0 AU for < 100 <100 keV electrons. Short timescale turbulent scattering in the flaring corona steepens the spectra by ∼ 0.5 \sim 0.5 . It was also found that the in-situ spectral index δ \delta derived from the peak electron flux produces a spectral index ∼ 1.6 \sim 1.6 harder than that from a full-flare X-ray photon flux (of spectral index γ \gamma ) simulated with the same intermediate parameters. Previous studies have indicated an approximate δ ≈ γ \delta\approx\gamma relationship for selected flares with measured in-situ electron and X-ray photon observations, suggesting that an extended source region with non-uniform plasma and/or acceleration properties may be necessary to reproduce this relationship. I Introduction Solar transient events such as solar flares are highly efficient particle accelerators with observational estimates suggesting a large fraction of the released magnetic energy, at least 10-50%, is partitioned into energetic particles ( Emslie et al. 2012 ; Warmuth & Mann 2016 ; Aschwanden et al. 2017 , e.g., ) . Our understanding of this acceleration mechanism(s) is complicated by the existence of different flare-associated energetic populations, at the Sun and/or released into heliosphere. Whether these populations are produced by the same mechanisms and in the same regions are open questions. Energetic electrons in the range of 1-100 keV are routinely observed in flares by remote sensing X-ray and radio observations, while electrons released into the heliosphere can be observed via their radio emissions and in-situ near Earth and other heliospheric locations with instrumentation onboard Wind ( Lin et al. 1995 ) , STEREO ( Kaiser et al. 2008 ) , Solar Orbiter (SolO) ( Müller et al. 2020 ) and Parker Solar Probe (PSP) ( Fox et al. 2016 ; Kasper et al. 2016 ) . A key metric used in analysing energy spectra (flux or fluence) is the spectral index. Non-thermal acceleration typically results in a non-thermal tail at energies above the base thermal distribution, with shallower gradients or smaller spectral indices (“harder spectra”) typically correlating with a greater degree of non-thermal acceleration. Direct analysis of in-situ electron spectra has been widely performed, including for sub-100 keV energy ranges ( Mewaldt et al. 2005 ; Rodríguez-García, L. et al. 2023 ; Lorfing et al. 2023 , e.g. ) . Previous studies such as Krucker et al. 2007 , examined flares between 2002-2005, during which, 57% of Wind events (i.e., the detection of flare-associated energetic electrons) had corresponding hard X-ray (HXR) emission from energetic electrons “at the Sun”, i.e., those electrons moving on newly formed closed flare loops towards the dense solar chromosphere ( Holman et al. 2011 ; Kontar et al. 2011 , e.g. ) . For so-called ‘prompt’ events, where a time correlation is found between in-situ events and X-ray bursts at the Sun, Krucker et al. 2007 established a correlation between the non-thermal spectral indices of HXR emission observed at the chromosphere and that of electrons detected in-situ in the heliosphere. This indicates a connection between the acceleration mechanisms and/or plasma conditions experienced by coronal electrons during flaring events, and potentially a common source region for both observed populations. To explore this possibility, simulations can be used to produce artificial data for both chromospheric HXR and in-situ electron spectra. By initialising an electron population in a shared “acceleration” region, both datasets can be subject to the same acceleration mechanisms and plasma environment. In Paper I ( Pallister & Jeffrey 2023 ) a parameter search for the ambient plasma properties of a coronal acceleration region was conducted. The purpose of this was to first focus on how the plasma environment itself affected electron ejecta into the heliosphere independent of non-thermal acceleration. A beamed non-thermal electron population was injected into a short, hot, dense coronal region and subsequently transported through a cold, sparse heliospheric region out to 1.0 AU. The population was subject to both collisional and non-collisional scattering effects, in addition to adiabatic focusing by a guiding B -field modelled as the interplanetary Parker spiral. The electron fluence and peak electron flux distributions were studied at multiple positions through Sun-Earth space for appropriate diagnostics, making note of changes in these diagnostics subject to varying coronal region length L , temperature T and electron number density n . It was found that for sufficiently large and dense coronal acceleration regions the temperature could be constrained by the maximum electron fluence and peak flux values below 20 keV even with instruments at \approx 1.0 AU and energy resolutions as low as 3 keV, comparable to data obtained by recent in-situ instruments on board spacecraft such as SolO. The purpose of constraining the parameters of a source acceleration region is to better identify the location within the corona where this acceleration takes place. We expand the approach outlined in Paper I to the properties of the acceleration itself. To this end, we change the initial electron population from beamed and non-thermal to isotropic and thermal (based on the ambient plasma temperature). In addition to collisional and non-collisional scattering and adiabatic focusing effects, we also apply turbulent acceleration to better investigate how properties of the surrounding region affect the process of acceleration itself rather than its impact on an imposed pre-accelerated population. If so, we can determine whether certain plasma environments are prohibitive to producing non-thermal distributions typically detected in-situ. Solar flare observations using EUV spectral line observations suggest the presence of extended regions of turbulence, via non-thermal line broadening ( Stores et al. 2021 ; Kontar et al. 2017 , e.g. ) , and in recent years, the dynamic nature of the flare environment has favoured stochastic acceleration mechanisms ( Petrosian 2012 , e.g.,) such as magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) plasma turbulence ( Goldreich & Sridhar 1995 ) . In Section II , we summarise the transport model outlined in greater detail in Paper I ( Pallister & Jeffrey 2023 ) and expand it to include a turbulent acceleration term. In Section III , we study how the energy spectra of coronal ejecta change with varying properties of turbulent acceleration, alongside changing plasma properties for an initially thermal population. In Section IV we propagate these ejecta populations out to 1.0 AU and investigate how their spectral indices evolve across the heliosphere. Finally in Section V we pair a simulated in-situ dataset

Read the complete text