Characterisation of circular light rays in a plasma
Volker Perlick · 2025
Read Characterisation of circular light rays in a plasma by Volker Perlick (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-18831.txt.
Introduction
Volker Perlick characterizes the light rays that circle endlessly inside a plasma surrounding a rotating or static compact object. The plasma is unmagnetized, pressure-free, and made of electrons and ions, sharing the spacetime's axial symmetry and stationarity. Circular rays matter because they mark where light can orbit, shaping shadows and lensing.
His main tool is a pair of potentials, one for forward and one for backward rays, whose critical points are exactly the circular light rays. With no plasma, their level surfaces reduce to the classic relativistic von Zeipel cylinders. The potentials' gradients split the effective force into centrifugal and Coriolis parts, with plasma affecting only the first. Examples on four spacetimes illustrate the theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Volker Perlick |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-18831
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Characterisation of circular light rays in a plasma Volker Perlick Abstract It is the purpose of this paper to give a characterisation of circular light rays in a plasma on an axially symmetric and stationary spacetime. We restrict to the case of an unmagnetised, pressure-free electron-ion plasma and we assume that the plasma shares the symmetry of the spacetime. As a main tool we use two potentials, one for prograde and one for retrograde light rays, whose critical points are exactly the circular light rays in the plasma. In the case that the plasma density vanishes, the corresponding equipotential surfaces reduce to the relativistic Von Zeipel cylinders which have been discussed in many papers since the 1970s. In a plasma, the gradients of the potentials give the centrifugal and the Coriolis forces experienced by a light ray, where the plasma has an influence only on the centrifugal force. The introduction of these potentials allows us to generalise topological methods that have been successfully used for proving the existence or non-existence of circular vacuum light rays to the plasma case. The general results are illustrated with examples on Minkowski, Schwarzschild, Kerr and NUT spacetimes. 1 Introduction If gravitating objects are sufficiently compact, the light-bending effect of their gravitational fields may be so strong that some light rays are circular. Examples for such objects, which are sometimes called ultracompact , are black holes and wormholes and there are also speculations that ultracompact stars might exist. The existence of circular light rays has important consequences for the light-bending effects in general. In particular, circular light rays that are unstable against perturbations in the radial direction are associated with light rays that asymptotically spiral towards them, giving rise to infinite bending angles and to the formation of a shadow . For reviews on the latter we refer to Cunha and Herdeiro [ 1 ] and to Perlick and Tsupko [ 2 ] . When discussing the light bending of gravitating objects, it is justified in most cases to treat the light rays as lightlike geodesics of the spacetime metric, i.e., to disregard any influence of a medium. For some applications, however, this influence might be non-negligible. This is true, in particular, in the radio regime if the medium is a sufficiently dense plasma. E.g., for a light ray that crosses the ionosphere of our Earth or the Solar corona, it is known that there is a measurable influence of the medium on the travel time and on the spatial path of a light ray unless the frequency is much bigger than 10 MHz or 100 MHz, respectively. It is not unplausible to assume that near a black hole the plasma density might be even higher, i.e., to assume that near a black hole light rays of even higher frequencies could be influenced by a plasma in a non-negligible way. This gives a good motivation for investigating the influence of a plasma on the lensing features of an ultracompact object. Gravitational light deflection on a general-relativistic spacetime in the presence of a plasma has been investigated by many authors. The first papers on this subject date back to the 1960s when the Shapiro time delay of light rays (in the radio regime) that pass through the Solar corona was at the centre of interest. Muhleman et al. [ 3 , 4 ] calculated, on the basis of the linearised Schwarzschild metric, the time delay and the bending angle of such light rays. Light bending in a plasma, without the weak-field approximation, on the Schwarzschild spacetime and in the equatorial plane of a Kerr metric, was first calculated by Perlick [ 5 ] . This was followed by many other papers on light bending by a gravitational field in the presence of a plasma. Here, in particular the work by Bisnovatyi-Kogan and Tsupko [ 6 , 7 ] has to be mentioned, which considerably pushed the subject, and two papers by Perlick and Tsupko [ 8 , 9 ] where the influence of a plasma on lensing by a Kerr black hole was discussed in detail. In all these papers, the simplest model of a plasma was used, namely a non-magnetised pressure-less electron-ion plasma. It is the purpose of the present paper to present a mathematical formalism that allows to investigate the existence of circular light rays in the presence of a plasma. As outlined in the preceding paragraphs, this is motivated by the two facts that the existence of circular light rays is of crucial relevance for the light bending and that the influence of a plasma might be non-negligible in some cases of interest. To that end, we restrict to axially symmetric and stationary spacetimes and we assume that the plasma shares these symmetries. Moreover, as in the works quoted above, we restrict to the simple case of a non-manetised pressure-less electron-ion plasma. As a main tool, we define two potentials, one for prograde and one for retrograde light rays, in such a way that the critical points of these potentials give the locations of circular light rays. If there is no plasma, the corresponding equipotential surfaces reduce to the relativistic Von Zeipel cylinders which were introcuded by Marek Abramowicz, originally for axially symmetric and static spacetimes, already in the 1970s and have been discussed in numerous papers, see in particular Abramowicz [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . These equipotential surfaces have many interesting properties. What is most important for our purpose is the fact that they give us the circular light rays which are located exactly where the potentials have critical points. The generalised potentials that will be introduced in this paper have the same crucial property in the plasma case. With the help of these potentials we can visualise the behaviour of light rays in an instructive way: If a light ray is sent tangent to a circle, the gradient of the corresponding potential points in the direction in which this light ray is deflected from this circle. The corresponding “force” acting on the light ray can be interpreted as the sum of a “centrifugal force” and a “Coriolis force”. Interestingly, we will see that only the centrifugal force is influenced by the plasma. However, as already mentioned it is most important that the location of circular light rays is given by the critical points of the corresponding potential. In addition to just visualising the light-deflection properties in a suggestive way, this mathematical construction allows us to generalise theorems on the existence of circular light rays that have been established with topological methods, using the Brouwer deegree of appropriate maps, by Cunha et al. [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] , to the plasma case. It should be emphasised that throughout the paper Einstein’s field equation is not used, so the general results apply to the case that the plasma is self-gravitating and equally well to the case that the gravitational field of the plasma is neglected. The latter case is, probably, more interesting in view of applications to astrophysics, so in our examples we consider only vacuum solutions to Einstein’s field equation, namely Minkowski, Schwarzschild, Kerr and NUT spacetimes. In Section 2 we briefly review the Hamiltonian formalism