The distance of quasar outflows from the central source: The first consistent values from emission and absorption determinations.

Mayank Sharma, Nahum Arav, Qinyuan Zhao, Maryam Dehghanian, Doyee Byun, Gwen Walker, Luming Sun, Lu Shen, Yulong Gao, Guilin Liu, Junfeng Wang · 2025

Read The distance of quasar outflows from the central source: The first consistent values from emission and absorption determinations. by Mayank Sharma, Nahum Arav, Qinyuan Zhao, Maryam Dehghanian, Doyee Byun, Gwen Walker, Luming Sun, Lu Shen, Yulong Gao, Guilin Liu, Junfeng Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-18825.txt.

Introduction

Mayank Sharma and co-authors reported in 2025 the first case where two methods gave matching distances for the same quasar outflow. Gas flowing out of a quasar can push on its host galaxy, but its effect depends on how far it sits from the central source. One method maps the outflow in emission with a field spectrograph. The other reads absorption lines in the spectrum.

For the outflow in quasar 3C 191, both methods gave a distance near five kiloparsecs, and the speeds and energies matched as well. The team used new telescope data for the absorption work and rechecked older data from a second telescope. Readers get a strong cross-check: the cheaper absorption method, used on many quasars, now has direct support from a mapped case.

Catalog record

CREATORMayank Sharma, Nahum Arav, Qinyuan Zhao, Maryam Dehghanian, Doyee Byun, Gwen Walker, Luming Sun, Lu Shen, Yulong Gao, Guilin Liu, Junfeng Wang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-18825

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The distance of quasar outflows from the central source: The first consistent values from emission and absorption determinations. Mayank Sharma, Nahum Arav, Qinyuan Zhao, Maryam Dehghanian, Doyee Byun, Gwen Walker, Luming Sun, Lu Shen, Yulong Gao, Guilin Liu, Junfeng Wang Abstract Measuring the distance of quasar outflows from the central source ( R R ) is essential for determining their importance for AGN feedback. There are two methods to measure R R : 1) A direct determination using spatially resolved Integral Field Spectroscopy (IFS) of the outflow in emission. 2) An indirect method which uses the absorption troughs from ionic excited states. The column density ratio between the excited and resonance states yields the outflow number density. Combined with a knowledge of the outflow’s ionization parameter, R R can be determined. Generally, the IFS method probes R R range of several kpc or more, while the absorption method usually yields R R values of less than 1kpc. There is no inconsistency between the two methods as the determinations come from different objects. Here we report the results of applying both methods to the same quasar outflow, where we derive consistent determinations of R R ≈ \approx 5 kpc. This is the first time where the indirect absorption R R determination is verified by a direct spatially resolved IFS observation. In addition, the velocities (and energetics) from the IFS and absorption data are also found to be consistent. Therefore, these are two manifestations of the same outflow. In this paper we concentrate on the absorption R R determination for the outflow seen in quasar 3C 191 using VLT/X-shooter observations. We also reanalyze an older absorption determination for the outflow based on Keck/HIRES data and find that revised measurement to be consistent with ours. Our companion paper details the IFS analysis of the same object. I Introduction Active galactic nuclei (AGN) feedback serves as an important link in the co-evolution of supermassive black holes (SMBHs) and their host galaxies. It has thus become an essential feature of modern theories of galaxy formation [ 24 , 84 , 52 , e.g.,] and state-of-the-art cosmological simulations [ 38 , 29 , 36 , e.g.,] . In the quasar mode of AGN feedback, powerful outflows are driven by SMBHs accreting close to the Eddington limit. The energy and momentum carried by these outflows can be re-deposited in the surrounding medium and thus contribute to various feedback processes. To assess this contribution quantitatively, it is important to determine the spatial extent of the outflowing gas ( R ), its mass ( M ), mass flow rate ( \dot{M} ) and kinetic luminosity ( \dot{E}_{k} ) from observations. Observational signatures of quasar outflows are detected primarily: (a) in emission, as spatially-resolved galactic scale winds studied using Integral Field Spectroscopy (IFS) (and other techniques such as long-slit spectroscopy) and (b) in absorption, as blueshifted troughs in the quasar spectrum observed as a result of the intersection of our line of sight with the outflowing gas. Both these analysis techniques have been utilized greatly over the last two decades for their distinct advantages. The absorption analysis is much richer in spectroscopic information and has thus allowed the study of a wide range of physical parameters (e.g., density and ionization state) in the outflows. The detection of absorption troughs from metastable excited states plays a crucial role in the analysis as their population ratio with the resonance state is a reliable indicator of the outflow’s number density. The ionization state is typically determined through a detailed photoionization modeling of the outflow, and combined with the number density leads (using eqn. 4 ) to an indirect determination for the distance of the outflow from the central source [ 47 , 32 , 72 , 12 , 39 , 3 , 16 , 17 , 4 , 67 , 43 , 25 , 26 , 70 , 69 , 93 , 96 , 95 , 50 , 20 , 22 , 19 , 21 , 90 , 33 , e.g.,] . While these studies have revealed a wide range for the distance by placing the outflows at a few pc to several kpc, most of them are still found to be at distances less than a few kpc [ 7 , 94 ] . IFS analysis on the other hand directly measures the spatial extent of large-scale outflows and provides valuable insights into their morphology and kinematic structure. Recent IFS studies have highlighted the prevalence of kpc scale outflows in AGNs [ 73 , 2 , 79 , 80 , 49 , 48 , 66 , 65 , 64 , 57 , 56 , 92 , 58 , 83 , 86 , 76 , 88 , e.g.,] . Emission line diagnostics also exist for determining the electron number density of these outflows [ 53 , 11 ] , however they are subject to larger uncertainties as inconsistencies have been revealed between different commonly used methods [ 31 ] . Although these two methods of distance determinations have led to different scales for the outflows, they are not inconsistent with each other. This is because these methods have either been applied to different objects, or to different outflow phases for the same object [ 74 , 98 , 15 , e.g.,] . However, attempts to verify the indirect distance determination from absorption analysis through IFS mapping have also only seen limited success [ 64 , also see section V.2 for a detailed discussion] , thus highlighting the missing link between these two analysis techniques. In this paper (and the companion paper by 97 ), we present the first consistent distance determination for a quasar outflow from the two analysis techniques, in the form of an ionized outflow in quasar 3C 191. This paper details the absorption analysis for the outflow while its IFS analysis is detailed in [ 97 ] . 3C 191 (J2000: RA=08:04:47.97; DEC: +10:15:23.70) is a radio-loud quasar with a bipolar radio structure spanning \sim 5 arcsec ( \sim 42 kpc at the quasar redshift) [ 77 , 1 ] . It was one of the first quasars to show an extensive absorption system in its spectrum as identified by 18 and 85 . The detection of Si ii ground and excited states with high dispersion observations allowed an estimation for the electron number density with n_{e}\sim 10^{3} cm -3 and the distance of the outflow component from the central source was determined to be R\sim 10 kpc [ 10 , 91 ] . However, 47 analyzed a high-resolution spectrum of 3C 191 and obtained n_{e}\sim 300 cm -3 and R\sim 28 kpc for the outflow component. Thus, while there is a slight disagreement between these analysis for the physical parameters (also addressed in section 4.6 of 47 ), they nonetheless suggest a galactic scale absorption line outflow. This makes the outflow in 3C 191 a great choice for a complementary analysis using both absorption and IFS techniques. In this paper, we present a study of the X-shooter [ 89 ] spectrum of the quasar 3C 191 obtained on the Very Large Telescope (VLT). Section II.1 describes the observation and how the redshift and normalized spectrum were obtained for our

Read the complete text