The mean value property (corrected version)

Vilmos Totik · 2025

Read The mean value property (corrected version) by Vilmos Totik (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-17471.txt.

Introduction

Vilmos Totik writes on the mean value property in a 2025 paper, presented here in a corrected version. The property links a function's value at a point to averages over balls or spheres around it, and it sits close to the heart of harmonic function theory. Totik takes up elementary problems about several forms of the property. He traces their connections both to harmonic functions and to random walks, where averaging over steps plays a kindred role.

Catalog record

CREATORVilmos Totik
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-17471

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The mean value property (corrected version) Vilmos Totik Abstract This is a corrected version of the paper ”The mean value property, Mathematical Intelligencer , 37 (2015), 9–16.”. In the original paper an incorrect claim was stated about the connection of harmonic functions and minimal surfaces. In the present version that incorrect claim is eliminated and the relation in question is explained in more details in Section 8; the rest of the paper has not been changed. “…what mathematics really consists of is problems and solutions.” (Paul Halmos) 1 Some problem challenges I like problems and completely agree with Paul Halmos that they are from the heart of mathematics ( [ 7 ] ). This one I heard when I was in high school. Problem 1. Show that if numbers in between 0 and 1 are written into the squares of the integer lattice on the plane in such a way that each number is the average of the four neighboring numbers, then all the numbers must be the same. Little did I know at that time that this problem has many things to do with random walks, the fundamental theorem of algebra, harmonic functions, the Dirichlet problem or with the shape of soap films. A somewhat more difficult version is Problem 2. Prove the same if the numbers are assumed only to be nonnegative . Since 1949 every fall there is a unique mathematical contest in Hungary named after Miklós Schweitzer, a young mathematician perished during the siege of Budapest in 1945. It is for university students without age groups, and about 10-12 problems from various fields of mathematics are posted for 10 days during which the students can use any tools and literature they want. 1 1 1 The problems and solutions up to 1991 can be found in he two volumes [ 3 ] and [ 12 ] I proposed the following continuous variant of Problem 1 for the 1983 competition ( [ 12 , p. 34] ). Problem 3. Show that if a bounded continuous function on the plane has the property that its average over every circle of radius 1 equals its value at the center of the circle, then it is constant. When “boundedness” is replaced here by “one-sided boundedness”, say positivity, the claim is still true, but the problem gets considerably tougher. Problem 4. The boundedness in Problem 3 can be replaced by positivity. We shall solve these problems and discuss their various connections. Although the first problem follows from the second one, we shall first solve Problem 1 because its solution will guide us in the solution of the stronger statement. It will be clear that there is nothing special about the plane, the claims are true in any dimension. • If nonnegative numbers are written into every box of the integer lattice in {\tenopen R}^{d} in such a way that each number is the average of the 2d neighboring numbers, then all the numbers are the same. • If a nonnegative continuous function in {\tenopen R}^{d} has the property that its average over every sphere of radius 1 equals its value at the center of the sphere, then it is constant. It will also be clear that similar statements are true for other averages (like the one taken for the 9 touching squares instead of the 4 adjacent ones). Label a square of the integer lattice by its lower-left vertex, and let f(i,j) be the number we write into the (i,j) square. So Problem 1 asks for proving that if f(i,j)\in[0,1] and for all i,j we have f(i,j)=\frac{1}{4}\Bigl(f(i-1,j)+f(i+1,j)+f(i,j-1)+f(i,j+1)\Bigr), (1) then all f(i,j) are the same. Note that some kind of limitations like boundedness or one-sided boundedness is needed, for, in general, functions with the property ( 1 ) need not be constant, consider e.g. f(i,j)=i . ( 1 ) is called the discrete mean value property for f . First we discuss some of its consequences. 2 The maximum principle Assume that f satisfies ( 1 ) and it is nonnegative. Notice that if, say, f takes the value 0 at an (i,j) , then it must be zero everywhere. Indeed, then ( 1 ) gives that f(i-1,j) , f(i+1,j) , f(i,j-1) and f(i,j+1) all must be also 0, i.e. all the neighboring values must be zero. Repeating this we can get that all values of f must be 0. The same argument works if f takes its largest value at some point, so we have Theorem 1 (Minimum/maximum principle) If a function with the discrete mean value property on the integer lattice attains somewhere its smallest/largest value, then it must be constant. In particular, this implies a solution to Problem 1 if we assume that f has a limit at infinity (i.e. f(i,j)\to\alpha for some \alpha as i^{2}+j^{2}\to\infty ). Unfortunately, in Problem 1 we do not know in advance that the function has a limit at infinity, so this is not a solution. Call a subset G of the squares of the integer lattice a region if every square in G can be reached from every other square of G by moving always inside G to neighboring cells. The boundary \partial G of G is the set of squares that are not in G but which are neighboring to G . See Figure 1 for a typical bounded region, where the boundary consists of the darker shaded squares. Figure 1: Suppose each boundary square contains a number like in Figure 1 . Consider the number filling problem: • Can the squares of G be filled in with numbers so that the discrete mean value property is true for all squares in G ? • In how many ways can such a filling be done? This problem is called the discrete Dirichlet problem, we shall see its connection with the classical Dirichlet problem later. The unicity of the solution is easy to get. Indeed, it is clear that the maximum/minimum principle holds (with the proof given above) also on finite regions: Theorem 2 (Maximum principle) Let f be a function with the discrete mean value property on a finite region, and let M be its largest value on G\cup\partial G . If f attains M somewhere in G , then f is the constant function. This gives that if a function with the mean value property is zero on the boundary, then it must be zero everywhere, and from here the unicity of the solution to the discrete Dirichlet problem follows (just take the difference of two possible solutions). Perhaps the most natural approach to the existence part of the number filling problem is to consider the numbers to be filled in as unknowns, to write up a system of equations for them which describes the discrete mean value property and the boundary properties of f , and to solve that system. It can be readily shown that this linear system of equations is always solvable. But there is a better way to show existence that also works on unbounded regions. 3 Random walks Consider a random walk on the squares of the integer lattice, which means that if at a moment we are in the lattice square (i,j) , then we

Read the complete text