Risk Measures for DC Pension Plan Decumulation
Peter A. Forsyth, Yuying Li · 2025
Read Risk Measures for DC Pension Plan Decumulation by Peter A. Forsyth, Yuying Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-16364.txt.
Introduction
Peter Forsyth and Yuying Li weighed how to state risk when a retiree spends down a pension pot. Their paper, from twenty twenty-five, deals with defined contribution plans. Such plans have spread as the old promise based plans fade. The spend down phase needs a plan for draws over time. Cast as a control task, it needs a clear prize and a clear risk.
The prize is plain: total draws over the retired span. Risk, to most, is to run dry. The team tests three left tail risk forms, from mean shortfall to the chance of shortfall. They show that, on set terms, the best controls for prize and risk lines share a form. Readers who plan pensions get a firm way to weigh dry risk.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Peter A. Forsyth, Yuying Li |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-16364
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Risk Measures for DC Pension Plan Decumulation Peter A. Forsyth, Yuying Li Abstract As the developed world replaces Defined Benefit (DB) pension plans with Defined Contribution (DC) plans, there is a need to develop decumulation strategies for DC plan holders. Optimal decumulation can be viewed as a problem in optimal stochastic control. Formulation as a control problem requires specification of an objective function, which in turn requires a definition of reward and risk. An intuitive specification of reward is the total withdrawals over the retirement period. Most retirees view risk as the possibility of running out of savings. This paper investigates several possible left tail risk measures, in conjunction with DC plan decumulation. The risk measures studied include (i) expected shortfall (ii) linear shortfall and (iii) probability of shortfall. We establish that, under certain assumptions, the set of optimal controls associated with all expected reward and expected shortfall Pareto efficient frontier curves is identical to the set of optimal controls for all expected reward and linear shortfall Pareto efficient frontier curves. Optimal efficient frontiers are determined computationally for each risk measure, based on a parametric market model. Robustness of these strategies is determined by testing the strategies out-of-sample using block bootstrapping of historical data. Keywords: decumulation, stochastic control, risk JEL codes: G11, G22 AMS codes: 91G, 65N06, 65N12, 35Q93 1 Introduction Internationally, there is a growing movement to replace Defined Benefit (DB) pension plans with Defined Contribution (DC) plans. A study of the P7 countries 1 1 1 Australia, Canada, Japan, Netherlands, Switzerland, UK, US reveals that in terms of fraction of total pension assets, DC plans have increased from 37% in 2003 to 58% in 2023 ( Thinking Ahead Institute, 2024 ) . In terms of individual countries, Australia has 88% of pension assets in DC plans, while Japan has only 5% of pension assets in DC plans. In the Netherlands, all DB plans will transition to collective DC plans by 2028. 2 2 2 “The End of the Dutch Defined Benefit Model A Steeper Euro Swap Curve Ahead,” https://www.pimco.com/eu/en/insights/the-end-of-the-dutch-defined-benefit-model-a-steeper-euro-swap-curve-ahead The trend towards DC plans seems inevitable, since corporations and governments no longer desire to take on the risk of providing the guarantees implicit in DB plans. During the accumulation phase of a DC plan, the burden of deciding on an asset allocation usually is relegated to the investor. However, upon retirement, the DC plan holder is faced with an even bigger challenge. During the decumulation stage of a DC plan, the retiree must decide on a withdrawal schedule and an asset allocation. Surveys have revealed that retirees fear running out of savings more than death ( Hill, 2016 ) . Consequently, it seems clear that the retiree wants to to withdraw as much as possible, but avoid ruin. The decumulation problem has been termed “the nastiest, hardest problem in finance,” by William Sharpe ( Ritholz, 2017 ) . While it is often suggested that retirees purchase annuities to reduce the risk of depletion of savings, annuities are not popular with DC plan holders ( Peijnenburg et al., 2016 ) . MacDonald et al. (2013) suggest that avoidance of annuities may be entirely rational. 3 3 3 See also “When do you need insurance?” https://donezra.com/217-when-do-you-need-insurance/ For example, in the North American context, true inflation protected annuities are virtually unobtainable. An extensive study of decumulation strategies can be found in Bernhardt and Donnelly (2018) . Some recent strategies which involve pooling longevity risk, such as a modern tontine ( Fullmer, 2019 ; Weinert and Gründl, 2021 ; Forsyth et al., 2024 ) appear promising. However, these types of plans are still in their infancy. The standard wealth management advice given to retirees is usually some variant of the ubiquitous 4% rule ( Bengen, 1994 ) . This rule suggests that retirees should (i) invest in a portfolio of 50% bonds and 50% equities, rebalanced annually and (ii) withdraw 4% of the initial capital each year (adjusted for inflation). We can consider that this advice is given to a 65-year old retiree, who wants to be sure that he/she does not run out of savings if he/she lives to age 95. 4 4 4 The probability of a 65-year old Canadian male living to age 95 is about 0.13 . This advice is justified on the basis of historical rolling 30 year periods, using US data. A retiree following this advice would never have run out of savings over any of these rolling thirty year periods. Various adjustments to this rule have been suggested many times, see e.g. Guyton and Klinger (2006) . However, both the advice and historical tests can be criticized. Rolling thirty-year periods obviously have very high correlations. Use of constant weight stock allocation is somewhat simplistic, as is use of a constant (in real terms) withdrawal rate. In fact Irlam (2014) used dynamic programming methods to conclude that deterministic (i.e. glide path) allocation strategies are sub-optimal. 5 5 5 A constant weight strategy is trivially deterministic. More recently, Anarkulova et al. (2023) suggest that the safe withdrawal rate might be much lower than the the 4% rule. In contrast to rolling historical periods, Anarkulova et al. (2023) use block bootstrap resampling to test withdrawal strategies. We will also use bootstrap resampling to test our results in this paper. Nevertheless, the four per cent rule has seen wide adoption since the original publication over thirty years ago, and can be regarded as the default advice. Contrary to commonly held beliefs, it appears that retirees are somewhat flexible in annual spending. A survey in Bannerje (2021) indicates that retirees actually adjust their lifestyle (i.e. what are perceived as fixed expenses) to match their cash flows. In fact, recent surveys indicate that, if anything, many retirees underspend on the basis of their financial assets ( Rappaport, 2019 ; Ackerly et al., 2021 ) . Browning et al. (2016) suggests that these assets are being held as a reserve against unexpected medical expenses. However, Canada has a comprehensive public health care system, yet Hamilton (2001) finds that senior Canadian couples 85 and older either save or give away about 25% of their income. All these facts indicate that we should allow some flexibility in withdrawals from pension savings, in order to ameliorate sequence of return risk. Perhaps the most rigorous approach to the decumulation problem is to formulate this as a problem in optimal stochastic control. The controls in this case, are (i) the asset allocation, i.e. the stock/bond split and (ii) the withdrawal amounts (real) per year, subject to maximum and minimum constraints. Of course, the first task in formulating an optimal control problem is to specify the objective function. One possibility is to formulate the decumulation problem in terms of a utility function, combining the withdrawals and final portfolio value. However, it seems clear (from the popularity of the four per cent rule), that investors prefer to delineate the trade off between risk (running out of savings) and reward (maximizing withdrawals). We will consider basically the same problem as formulated by Bengen (1994) . As a result, the obvious measure of reward is the total of the withdrawals (inflation adjusted) over a 30 year period. However, the choice of