Sufficiency of the counterfactual account of Lüders’ rule to rule out ontological models of quantum mechanics

Alisson Tezzin, Bárbara Amaral, Jonte R. Hance · 2025

Read Sufficiency of the counterfactual account of Lüders’ rule to rule out ontological models of quantum mechanics by Alisson Tezzin, Bárbara Amaral, Jonte R. Hance (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-15615.txt.

Introduction

Alisson Tezzin, Bárbara Amaral, and Jonte Hance argue that one natural reading of a quantum update rule rules out a whole class of classical-style models. Their 2025 paper works in quantum foundations. Ontological models try to describe quantum systems with hidden real states and guide much work on what counts as classical.

Lüders rule tells how a quantum state updates after a measurement. The authors argue the rule itself implies a what-if, counterfactual update style. Under that style, hidden-state models must update by conditional probability. That forced update makes forecasts for chained measurements ignore their order. Real quantum behavior does depend on order, so the models clash with the formalism. Even context-aware variants fall to the argument.

Catalog record

CREATORAlisson Tezzin, Bárbara Amaral, Jonte R. Hance
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE133 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-15615

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sufficiency of the counterfactual account of Lüders’ rule to rule out ontological models of quantum mechanics Alisson Tezzin, Bárbara Amaral, Jonte R. Hance Abstract Ontological models, as used in the generalised contextuality literature, play a central role in current research on quantum foundations, providing a framework for defining classicality, constructing classical analogues of key quantum phenomena, and examining the ontology of quantum states. In this work, we show that a counterfactual account of Lüders’ rule—– which we argue is naturally implied by the mathematical structure of the rule itself —–renders such models inherently incompatible with the quantum formalism. This incompatibility arises because the counterfactual update requires ontological models to update their states according to conditional probability, which in turn which in turn renders predictions of sequential measurements order-independent. This implies that ontological models, even contextual ones, must either act differently to what we would expect given (this, typically implicitly-assumed account of) quantum state update rule, or cannot model quantum behaviour. I Introduction One of the most debated fundamental problems in modern physics is whether quantum formalism’s description of nature is complete, or if it could be supplemented with additional, or “hidden”, variables [ 28 , 12 , 7 , 50 , 10 , 25 , 5 ] . While hidden variable theories have been constructed which (partially or fully) reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics [ 10 , 11 , 91 , 5 ] , various impossibility theorems, notably Bell’s [ 6 , 8 ] and Kochen and Specker’s [ 50 ] , have shown that such attempts inevitably violate certain consistency conditions which we would arguably want from a successful description of reality [ 47 , 46 , 6 , 50 ] . Bell demonstrated the impossibility of reproducing the predictions of quantum mechanics with those local hidden variable theories which also obey statistical independence (i.e., where our choice of which measurement(s) to perform in each run of an experiment is in no way correlated with said hidden variable [ 37 , 40 ] ). Kochen and Specker, on the other hand, proved the impossibility of assigning values to all quantum observables in a way that preserves functional relations between them (e.g., if the value of the physical quantity \hat{A} is \alpha , where the value of \hat{A}^{2} is \alpha^{2} , etc) [ 50 , 45 , 51 ] . This obstructs what we now call noncontextual hidden variable descriptions [ 1 , 51 , 19 ] . Bell’s and Kochen and Specker’s seminal works gave rise to two major modern research areas: nonlocality [ 16 , 69 , 68 ] and contextuality [ 19 , 2 , 78 ] . Research in quantum foundations, and on contextuality and nonlocality in particular, has recently been dominated by an operational approach to physics [ 33 , 67 , 34 , 62 , 69 , 19 , 78 , 1 ] . This approach treats operational notions (such as preparations, transformations, and measurements) as the basic concepts of physical theories, and views the role of such theories as to specify probabilities of events associated with these operations [ 78 , 69 , 67 ] . To accommodate contextuality in this framework, Spekkens reinterpreted it as the impossibility of assigning the same ontological representation for operationally equivalent experimental procedures, resulting in his notion of generalised contextuality [ 78 , 81 ] . Ontological representations of experimental procedures are defined within what are known as ontological models, a form of hidden variable model which it is claimed generalises Kochen and Specker’s formulation to cover any operational theory [ 74 ] . The framework in which these models are defined is referred to as the Ontological Models Framework (OMF). The ultimate aim of this generalised contextuality research programme is to establish a universally applicable notion of classicality [ 74 , 72 , 71 , 73 ] . Generalised contextuality quickly expanded as a research field following Spekkens’ original paper, sparking extensive investigations into geometric analyses, noncontextuality inequalities, polytopes, and other analytical tools to study and understand its principles [ 76 , 89 , 72 , 71 ] . It has also been linked to significant phenomena in thermodynamics [ 24 , 54 ] , quantum Darwinism [ 3 ] , cloning [ 53 ] , quantum interrogation [ 90 ] , and other areas. In this paper, we explore the quantum state update rule (Lüders’ rule [ 55 ] ) to establish and equivalence between the pairwise compatibility of all observables in a scenario, and the existence of an ontological model for that scenario. This extends our recent result [ 84 ] for deterministic models to stochastic ones. We focus on ontological models because, similarly to that case, measurements are thought of updating “one’s information about what the ontic state of the system was prior to the procedure being implemented” [ 78 ] , whereas quantum states are treated as statistical mixtures of (i.e., probability measures over) such underlying states. Additionally, quantum states (and wavefunctions in particular) are viewed as an “ensemble average” of real ontic states of the system, which behave in ways we would expect real states of the world to — unlike wider hidden variable models, which can nominally be as contrived as we like [ 65 , 21 , 20 , 87 , 88 ] . Since we consider Lüders’ rule, our analysis does not apply — at least not straightforwardly — to hidden-variable reformulations of quantum mechanics that directly [ 38 ] exclude the collapse postulate, such as the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory [ 25 , 10 , 11 , 65 ] . As in Ref. [ 84 ] , we start by defending a counterfactual account of Lüders’ rule: instead of being updated by propositions in the simple past (“a measurement of \hat{A} was made, and the value \alpha was obtained”), we argue that quantum states are theoretically updated to ensure the validity of propositions in the first conditional (“ if a measurement is made of \hat{A} , the result will be found to be \alpha ”) [ 26 ] . This is to say that, contrary to the typical description of updated states as post-measurement states , updated states are theoretically constructed as pre -measurement states, with the qualifier post -measurement state regarded instead as a merely circumstantial attribute. This approach aligns with multiple perspectives on quantum mechanics and, as we show, is supported by the mathematical formulation of Lüders’ rule itself [ 63 , 17 , 27 , 59 , 60 ] . We then argue that. by this account, Lüders’ rule translates to ontological models as conditional probability, because considerations about interactions with measuring apparatuses are automatically removed in this counterfactual description. Using Bayes’ rule and Kolmogorov’s extension theorem [ 83 ] , we show that a set of quantum observables admits a state-updating ontological model (where states are updated via conditional probability) if and only if that set consists of pairwise compatible observables. In particular, a single pair of incompatible observables is sufficient to rule out a scenario being representable by an ontological model. The impossibility of modelling incompatible observables with state-updating ontological models follows from the order-dependence of quantum predictions for sequential measurements

Read the complete text