Simulating Noncausality with Quantum Control of Causal Orders
Anna Steffinlongo, Hippolyte Dourdent · 2025
Read Simulating Noncausality with Quantum Control of Causal Orders by Anna Steffinlongo, Hippolyte Dourdent (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-15579.txt.
Introduction
Anna Steffinlongo and Hippolyte Dourdent show that a realizable quantum device can mimic an impossible causal pattern. Their paper appeared in two thousand twenty-five. Noncausal processes let every party sit in every other's past and future. The Lugano process is a famous example. It breaks causal inequalities, yet no lab can build it directly. The quantum switch, by contrast, is real but yields only causal correlations.
A recent link ties the Lugano process to a measurement puzzle called SHIFT. Building on that link, the authors implement SHIFT with a quantum switch. Classical messages run through the switch while inputs stay quantum. Successful discrimination then witnesses the Lugano structure. Noncausality gains a simulated foothold in real hardware.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anna Steffinlongo, Hippolyte Dourdent |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-15579
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulating Noncausality with Quantum Control of Causal Orders Anna Steffinlongo, Hippolyte Dourdent Abstract Logical consistency with free local operations is compatible with non-trivial classical communications, where all parties can be both in each other’s past and future—a phenomenon known as noncausality. Noncausal processes, such as the “Lugano (AF/BW) process”, violate causal inequalities, yet their physical realizability remains an open question. In contrast, the quantum switch—a physically realizable process with indefinite causal order—can only generate causal correlations. Building on a recently established correspondence [Kunjwal & Baumeler, PRL 131, 120201 (2023)] between the SHIFT measurement, which exhibits nonlocality without entanglement, and the Lugano process, we demonstrate that the SHIFT measurement can be implemented using a quantum switch of classical communications in a scenario with quantum inputs. This shows that the structure of the Lugano process can be simulated by a quantum switch and that successful SHIFT discrimination witnesses causal nonseparability rather than noncausality. Finally, we identify a broad class of “superposition of classical communications” derived from classical processes without global past capable of realizing similar causally indefinite measurements. We examine these results in relation to the ongoing debate on implementations of indefinite causal orders. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction I.1 State of the art In local operations and classical communication (LOCC) protocols, each party can perform arbitrary quantum operations on their system, while communication remains classical [ 23 ] with a causally well-defined order on the operations. In single-round scenarii, LOCC can enable specific joint measurements. For instance, the basis \{\mathinner{|{00}\rangle},\mathinner{|{01}\rangle},\mathinner{|{1+}\rangle},\mathinner{|{1-}\rangle}\} cannot be measured locally by Alice and Bob using only shared randomness [ 23 , 51 ] . However, it can be with LOCC: Alice measures her qubit in the \{\mathinner{|{0}\rangle},\mathinner{|{1}\rangle}\} basis, sends her outcome a to Bob, who then measures in \{\mathinner{|{0}\rangle},\mathinner{|{1}\rangle}\} if a=0 or in \{\mathinner{|{\pm}\rangle}=(\mathinner{|{0}\rangle}\pm\mathinner{|{1}\rangle})/\sqrt{2}\} if a=1 . Nevertheless, certain product-state bases remain locally unmeasurable under LOCC [ 15 ] , a phenomenon termed “nonlocality without entanglement” (NLWE). The SHIFT basis exemplifies such an ensemble: \displaystyle\{\mathinner{|{000}\rangle},\mathinner{|{+01}\rangle},\mathinner{|{01+}\rangle},\mathinner{|{01-}\rangle}, \displaystyle\mathinner{|{1+0}\rangle},\mathinner{|{-01}\rangle},\mathinner{|{1-0}\rangle},\mathinner{|{111}\rangle}\} (1) Classical communications without definite causal orders can bypass NLWE. In bipartite scenarii, local operations within classical causal loops (LOCC*) coincides with separable operations [ 2 ] . More generally, operational closed-timelike curves based on post-selected teleportations [ 52 , 14 , 63 ] enable perfect discrimination of any set of linearly independent quantum states [ 18 ] . However, these structures are often viewed as pathological due to their ability to solve complex problems efficiently [ 18 , 6 ] and generate logical antinomies under free operations [ 12 , 9 ] . To avoid these pathologies, the “process matrix formalism” [ 46 ] was developed to describe global processes while preserving the validity of ordinary local physics laws. Its classical, deterministic counterpart—“ process functions ” [ 10 , 7 ] models consistent classical communication under free local operations. A simple characterization exists for all N- partite processes [ 65 ] and, remarkably, process functions without definite causal order have been identified for N\geq 3 [ 11 , 1 , 65 ] . These, termed “noncausal” , generate correlations that violate causal inequalities [ 46 , 16 ] . Kunjwal and Baumeler [ 43 ] showed that the SHIFT basis corresponds to a tripartite noncausal process function – the Lugano (AF/BW) process [ 1 , 11 ] , where each party’s input depends non-trivially on the others’ outputs, with no global past, future, or restrictions on their local operations, \displaystyle x:=c(b\oplus 1),\hskip 14.22636pty:=a(c\oplus 1),\hskip 14.22636ptz:=b(a\oplus 1) (2) with x,y,z and a,b,c respectively labeling the input and output bits of Alice, Bob, and Charlie. Local operations with the Lugano process implement the projective measurement in the SHIFT basis, and this SHIFT measurement simulates the Lugano process by implementing its classical channel in a causal quantum circuit which, combined with retro-causal identity channels, realizes the noncausal process. This advantage of Local Operations with Process Function “LOPF” over LOCC extends to to a broader class of multipartite noncausal Boolean processes without global past, which can be transformed into NLWE multiqubit bases, trading the causality of correlations for local measurability. Whether these noncausal structures are physically realizable remains open. The Lugano process is unitarily extendible, a criterion for physical implementability [ 5 ] , and can be modeled via time-delocalized subsystems [ 48 , 73 ] , observer-dependent local events [ 37 ] , or a routed quantum circuit [ 68 ] . However, causal inequality violations are unlikely in fixed spacetime obeying relativistic causality [ 70 , 71 ] , suggesting reliance on closed timelike curves. Known physically realizable processes with indefinite causal order – quantum circuits with quantum control of causal orders (QC-QCs) [ 74 ] , including the “quantum switch” [ 20 ] – only produce causal correlations [ 4 , 47 , 74 , 54 ] . Whether the Lugano process emerges in general relativity or at the interface of quantum theory and gravity [ 39 , 40 ] , and how to realize the SHIFT measurement locally, remains a priori unknown. I.2 Contribution We demonstrate how the SHIFT measurement can also be implemented by local operations with quantum control of classical communications. Equivalently, the noncausal structure of the Lugano process can be simulated with such a quantum switch in a scenario with quantum inputs [ 29 ] . This implies that successful SHIFT discrimination is only an “operational signature of noncausal correlations” [ 43 ] in the specific LOPF scenario. More generally, implementing the SHIFT measurement rather certifies the weaker notion of causal nonseparability, namely the inability to express a process as a convex mixture of processes with definite causal order. We derive a QC-QC similar to the quantum switch from a unitary extension of the Lugano process matrix, yielding a SHIFT implementation we term “local operations with superposition of classical communications (LOSupCC).” We identify a broad class of such “SupCC” processes that implement measurements exhibiting both NLWE and causal nonseparability, and relate our results to the ongoing debate on implementating indefinite causal orders (see Appendix G ). II Results II.1 The SHIFT-Lugano correspondence We present a slightly modified but equivalent formulation of the SHIFT-Lugano correspondence from [ 43 ] , focusing on constructing the SHIFT measurement via local operations using the Lugano process. The construction of the classical channel underlying the Lugano process via implementing a SHIFT measurement in a causal quantum circuit is provided in Appendix A . Consider the tripartite scenario in Fig. 1 . Alice, Bob and Charlie control separate labs with input spaces \mathcal{H}^{A} , \mathcal{H}^{B} , and \mathcal{H}^{C} . Throughout, we restrict to finite-dimensional systems and, in particular, assume that these local Hilbert spaces are two-dimensional, so that each party holds a qubit. Each performs a fixed local quantum projective measurement, denoted (M_{a|x}^{A}=\mathinner{|{a|x}\rangle\!\langle{a|x}|}^{A})_{a},(M_{b|y}^{B}=\mathinner{|{b|y}\rangle\!\langle{b|y}|}^{B})_{b} and (M_{c|z}^{C}=\mathinner{|{c|z}\rangle\!\langle{c|z}|}^{C})_{c} , with settings x,y,z\in\{0,1\} and outcomes a,b,c\in\{0,1\} . (We denote the space of linear operators on \mathcal{H}^{X} as \mathcal{L}(\mathcal{H}^{X}) and write concisely \mathcal{H}^{XY}=\mathcal{H}^{X}\otimes\mathcal{H}^{Y} , superscripts indicate on what spaces operators act.) Furthermore, we assume that these local operations are connected via a Boolean process function (see [ 43 ] , Appendix). In the tripartite case, this process can be expressed as a set of functions mapping the outputs of two parties into the input of the third, \{w_{A}:(b,c)\rightarrow x\hskip