Quantum critical electro-optic and piezo-electric nonlinearities

Christopher P. Anderson †, Giovanni Scuri, Aaron Chan, Sungjun Eun, Alexander D. White, Geun Ho Ahn, Christine Jilly, Amir Safavi-Naeini, Kasper Van Gasse, Lu Li, Jelena Vučković † · 2025

Read Quantum critical electro-optic and piezo-electric nonlinearities by Christopher P. Anderson †, Giovanni Scuri, Aaron Chan, Sungjun Eun, Alexander D. White, Geun Ho Ahn, Christine Jilly, Amir Safavi-Naeini, Kasper Van Gasse, Lu Li, Jelena Vučković † (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-15164.txt.

Introduction

Christopher Anderson and co-authors harness a phase change for light control in a 2025 paper. Tuning light with electric fields falters in the cold, where many quantum devices must run. Guided by the link between phase shifts and nonlinear response, the team picked a crystal that sits near a quantum phase edge. That crystal, strontium titanate, holds a rare quantum paraelectric state.

Its light tuning strength can be dialed and passes 500 in the units used, a record class result for cold work. Piezoelectric response shows the same boost. The team frames the effect as quantum critical, born of the near transition state. Strong cold tuning could unlock modulators for quantum networks that now stall at low temperature.

Catalog record

CREATORChristopher P. Anderson †, Giovanni Scuri, Aaron Chan, Sungjun Eun, Alexander D. White, Geun Ho Ahn, Christine Jilly, Amir Safavi-Naeini, Kasper Van Gasse, Lu Li, Jelena Vučković †
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-15164

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum critical electro-optic and piezo-electric nonlinearities Christopher P. Anderson †, Giovanni Scuri, Aaron Chan, Sungjun Eun, Alexander D. White, Geun Ho Ahn, Christine Jilly, Amir Safavi-Naeini, Kasper Van Gasse, Lu Li, Jelena Vučković † Abstract Electro-optics, the tuning of optical properties of materials with electric fields, is key to a multitude of quantum and classical photonics applications 1 . However, a major obstacle preventing many emerging use cases is inefficient modulation in cryogenic environments, as traditional tuning mechanisms degrade at low temperatures 39 ; 41 . Guided by the connection between phase transitions and nonlinearity, we identify the quantum paraelectric perovskite SrTiO 3 (STO) as the strongest cryogenic electro-optic photonic material. As a result of the unique quantum paraelectric phase of STO, we demonstrate a dynamically tunable linear Pockels coefficient ( r 33 r_{33} ) exceeding 500 pm/V at T = 5 T=5 K, and study its full temperature and bias dependence. We also measure an enhanced piezo-electric coefficient ( d 33 d_{33} ) above 90 pC/N. Both of these coefficients exceed all previously reported values for cryogenic materials, including lithium niobate ( r 33 ≈ 24 r_{33}\approx 24 pm/V) and barium titanate ( r 42 ≈ 170 r_{42}\approx 170 pm/V) 4 ; 41 ; 5 . Furthermore, by tuning STO towards quantum criticality with oxygen isotope substitution 6 we more than double the optical and piezo-electric nonlinearities, demonstrating a linear Pockels coefficient above 1100 pm/V. Our results probe the link between quantum phase transitions, dielectric susceptibility, and optical nonlinearities, unlocking opportunities in cryogenic optical and mechanical systems, and provide a framework for discovering new nonlinear materials. Developments in nonlinear optical materials underpin a wide range of scientific and technical advances, from driving communications worldwide to the creation of entangled photons 7 ; 1 . On the other hand, piezo-electric materials find use in energy harvesting, actuators, medical devices, and beyond 8 . To date, the leading materials for both of these applications are largely ferroelectrics, commonly of the perovskite structure ABO 3 (Fig. 1 a). While this class of materials share a crystal structure, different materials, such as lithium niobate (LN), lithium tantalate (LT), barium titanate (BTO) and lead zirconate titanate (PZT) have drastically different strengths of these nonlinearities 4 ; 9 ; 41 ; 10 ; 32 . In fact, the strongest nonlinear materials only show a narrow temperature range where the piezo-electric and electro-optic effects are maximized. This is a critical problem for cryogenic and quantum applications, which commonly desire operation temperatures at or below T=5 K to match cryostat technology based on liquid helium. For example, quantum transducers between the microwave and optical domains require strong nonlinearity in both the optical and/or mechanical domain to create scalable modular quantum computers 12 ; 38 . With high nonlinearity, such systems would also enable high speed, low power interconnects for low-temperature applications in high energy physics and superconducting classical computing– mitigating the wiring and heating problems with microwave cryogenic control and readout 14 ; 15 . Optimized cryogenic electro-optic optical switches would also form the backbone of photonic-based quantum computing 16 ; 17 and provide the needed cryogenic photonic controls for defect centers, trapped atoms, and ions 18 ; 19 ; 20 . For mechanical systems, strong cryogenic piezo-electric effects are also desired in space-based missions for adaptive optics, actuators, and cryogen fuel transfer, for example 21 . Unfortunately, ferroelectric nonlinearities, plasma dispersion and thermo-optic tuning mechanisms usually decrease dramatically at cryogenic temperatures 41 ; 39 . Therefore, there is a distinct need for nonlinear materials optimized for low temperatures. Figure 1: Searching for nonlinear materials: The link between susceptibility and phase transitions | a , Schematic structure of ABO 3 perovskites. The motion of the B ( Ti ) ion (purple arrow) mediates the electrical polarization P . b , Schematic of the interrelated nature of nonlinearity ( \chi^{(2)} , \chi^{(3)} ), susceptibility ( \chi^{(1)} ), and phase transitions at Curie temperature T_{c} . c , Calculated magnitude of P\epsilon_{r} from the Landau-Ginzburg-Devonshire (LGD) model as a function of temperature T and applied field, E (a.u). With T>T_{c} the system is in the paraelectric state, while for T<T_{c} it is ferroelectric. The green circles denote the room temperature Pockels coefficient r for leading ferroelectric perovskites. Approaching T_{c} from either side of the phase transition results in the largest nonlinearity. d , Comparison of the (bulk) Curie temperature ( T_{c} ) of different ferroelectric and paraelectric leading electro-optic and piezo-electric materials. e , The Gibbs free energy from the LGD model as a function of the B ion displacement/electrical polarization. In STO, the zero point energy is high enough (horizontal dotted line) that the system never polarizes to one of the two energy wells, shown in blue. Instead, quantum fluctuations cause a stabilization of a nonpolar state (purple arrow). f , Schematic phase diagram for STO. QCP is the quantum critical point. The tuning parameter can arise from multiple mechanisms ( 18 O isotope fraction in this work). Linking nonlinearity and phase transitions We begin with a theoretical understanding of the origin of both piezo-electric and electro-optic nonlinearities in paraelectric and ferroelectric systems, and use this understanding to guide and optimize the identification of new materials for cryogenic operation (Fig. 1 b). To start, Miller’s rule in optics is an empirical relationship linking nonlinear and linear optical susceptibilities, applicable to a wide range of materials 22 ; 23 ; 1 . It can be directly linked to a classical Lorentz model under the assumption of weak anharmonic perturbation 25 . Miller’s rules state that the nonlinear susceptibilities (such as \chi^{(2)} , three-wave mixing) are proportional to the product of the linear susceptibilities ( \chi^{(1)} ) at the frequencies that describe the nonlinearity. Here, the proportionality constant, \delta , is related to the electrical polarization, P . As a result of Miller’s rules, for the electro-optic effect, we find (details in SI Section S1 ): \chi^{(2)}_{EO}\propto n^{4}P\epsilon_{r} (1) n , \epsilon_{r} are the index of refraction and quasi-static relative dielectric constant, respectively. With the electro-optic Pockels coefficient r=2\chi^{(2)}_{EO}/n^{4} , then, r\propto P\epsilon_{r} for most optical materials. Beyond this heuristic, there is an even deeper link between the dielectric behavior and the nonlinearity of paraelectric and ferroelectric perovskites. Surprisingly, the linear electro-optic effect and the linear piezo-electric effect can be directly linked to the corresponding quadratic nonlinearities: the Kerr 12 ; 3 and electrostrictive effects 28 ; 7 . These have a common form across materials. For example, electrostriction is the basis of electromechanical coupling in all insulators 7 . Valid for both the paraelectric and ferroelectric state, the response of either an electrically biased system or a system with a spontaneous or remnant polarization can be framed as the result of a biasing polarization ( P_{b} ). As a result, we find the Pockels coefficient r and the piezo-electric coefficient d , in Voigt notation (SI Section S2 ): r_{ij}\approx 2g_{ij}\epsilon_{r}P_{b,j} (2) d_{ij}\approx 2q_{ij}\epsilon_{r}P_{b,j} (3) The result is that both Pockels and piezo-electric nonlinearities are proportional to the product of the dielectric constant and the bias polarization, the same as the treatment by Miller for optics (Equation 1 ). We therefore propose this new, general metric for piezo-electricity and

Read the complete text