The holographic space-time model of inflation and its predictions for the CMB primordial spectra

Sidan A, Tom Banks · 2025

Read The holographic space-time model of inflation and its predictions for the CMB primordial spectra by Sidan A, Tom Banks (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-15108.txt.

Introduction

Sidan A and Tom Banks use a holographic space-time model of inflation to work out what it says for the cosmic microwave background in a 2025 paper. The model gives a base for the first growth of the universe that is far from field theory, the usual frame, and it has no trans-Planckian flaw.

The key step is an old guess: that the waves in a black hole's modular Hamiltonian match its mean value. Spread to all causal diamonds, that guess lets the team fix the exact size of the first scalar and tensor spectra. The fit to sky data is as good as the standard tale, they find.

Catalog record

CREATORSidan A, Tom Banks
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-15108

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The holographic space-time model of inflation and its predictions for the CMB primordial spectra Sidan A, Tom Banks Abstract In 1998 Carlip [ 1 ] and Solodukhin [ 2 ] independently conjectured the equality between fluctuations in the modular Hamiltonian of black holes and its expectation value. Banks and Zurek’s 2021 work [ 3 ] generalized this observation to any causal diamonds. We use this observation to calculate the precise normalization of primordial scalar and tensor power spectra in the Holographic Space-time (HST) model of inflation. In previous work [ 4 ] Banks and Fischler outlined the general calculation of inflationary power spectra in this model, which we review here. Its conceptual basis is radically different from field theoretic inflation and it has no trans-Planckian problem, but its predictions for power spectra will be shown to fit extant data equally well, and the tensor-to-scalar ratio agrees with experimental observations 1 1 1 A brief presentation can be found on the Strings 2025 website [link] . . 1 Introduction The Holographic Space-time (HST) model of inflationary cosmology is an economical and completely finite account of the very early history of the universe. It relies on Jacobson’s [ 5 ] view of Einstein’s equations as the hydrodynamics of the BHJFSB 2 2 2 Bekenstein-Hawking-Jacobson-Fischler-Susskind-Bousso. [ 6 , 7 , 5 , 8 , 9 ] area law for the entropy of generic causal diamonds, to write the quantum theory of the universe as time dependent quantum mechanics in a Hilbert bundle [ 10 ] over the space of geodesics of an FRW universe. Along any give geodesic, at cosmic time t , the evolution operator is a tensor product U_{in}(t)\otimes U_{out}(t) . Following Carlip [ 1 ] and Solodukhin [ 2 ] , as generalized in [ 3 , 10 , 11 ] , U_{in}(t) is a time ordered product of unitary embedding operators of the form e^{-iL_{0}(t_{i})} , where the discrete times are separated by one Planck unit. At each time L_{0} is the Virasoro generator of an abelian Thirring model [ 10 ] built from two-dimensional fermion fields labeled by angular momentum multiplets on the two sphere (the holographic screen of the cosmological apparent horizon). One angular momentum multiplet is added with each Planck time step. The fields live on an interval (the stretched apparent horizon) and have a UV cutoff which is determined by the smallest t for which the Carlip-Solodukhin hydrodynamic analysis of the dynamics is applicable. In principle, this can only be determined by experiment/observation. Theoretically, there must be enough 1+1 dimensional momentum modes for Cardy’s formula to capture the spectral density. This model reproduces the Einstein equation of state of the flat FRW universe with scale factor e^{a(t)}=\sinh^{1/3}(3t/R_{I}), (1) if we stop increasing the size of the Hilbert space at t\sim R and allow time to evolve with the final L_{0}(R_{I}) as Hamiltonian. This universe begins as a finite quantum system, evolves quickly to a sequence of cutoff 1+1 dimensional conformal field theories, whose hydrodynamics is that of the flat p=\rho universe, and asymptotes to a de Sitter universe with radius R_{I} [ 11 ] . For a general space-time, U_{out}(t) is determined by the Quantum Principle of Relativity (QPR): For any pair of intervals along two geodesics, there is a maximal area causal diamond in the overlap of the causal diamonds corresponding to those intervals. That diamond must be identified with isometric tensor factors in each of the fiber Hilbert spaces, and the density matrices assigned to those factors for every choice of initial conditions must have equal entanglement spectra. For the above space-time one can satisfy the QPR for any choice of U_{out} by choosing the tensor factor in the Hilbert space of two trajectories whose overlap diamond at time t has area A_{O} to be the “in” Hilbert space of each at time \sqrt{A_{O}} . The dynamics of our system is built so that for generic initial states along any trajectory, the modular Hamiltonian at any time is the L_{0} generator of the same Thirring model, with the number of fermions determined by the area. So the QPR is automatically satisfied. The QPR puts constraints on U_{out} when we discuss space-times with constrained initial states. In that case a constraint on the past horizon of some causal diamond must have an antecedent on the past horizon of a larger diamond that contains it, and the dynamics on that larger diamond must be consistent with that on the smaller diamond it contains. In a moment we will discuss more realistic cosmologies, where such issues arise. However, we will cheat by using the semi-classical language of particle physics, where the QPR reduces to the usual rules of space-time general covariance. Deriving those rules from the quantum model is a task that remains to be accomplished. The general formalism on which this paper is based was developed in a series of papers going back 25 years. We cannot go through all the details of that formalism here without making the current work too long and indigestible. The relevant references can be found in [ 12 ] . In Appendix A we give a brief review of how a model of matrix valued fermion quantum fields \psi_{i}^{A}(z,t) can produce qualitative properties of black hole physics in de Sitter space. The model described above will be used as a component of a more realistic model of an Inflationary universe. It describes one horizon volume of inflation before the slow-roll era starts, in a completely non-singular quantum mechanical way. It saturates the covariant entropy bound at every time and has no localized excitations and it is never well approximated by quantum field theory in curved space-time. Independent horizon volumes are considered separate physical systems, initially out of causal contact, rather than arising from short wavelength modes in a single horizon volume which get stretched to larger size. This is the way HST models avoid the trans-Planckian problems of field theory inflation. Finally we should note that HST models are conceptually very different from other models of “holographic cosmology” that have appeared in the literature [ 13 , 14 ] . They are characterized by having all fundamental degrees of freedom localized on the boundaries of causal diamonds in a background space-time. In the current version of the models, these degrees of freedom form a 1+1 dimensional CFT built from fermion fields labeled by solutions of the Dirac equation on the holographic screen of a diamond. Bulk excitations in the diamond are realized as constrained low entropy states of these variables. 2 From Holographic Inflation to the Hot Big Bang As stated, the model described above has no localized excitations. The Schwarzschild de Sitter (dS) black hole entropy formula shows that localized excitations in the asymptotic de Sitter space in which we apparently live are constrained states of a finite dimensional quantum system [ 15 ] . The static dS energy is related to the number of constrained q-bits by 2\pi RE=N{\rm ln}\ 2 . An explicit quantum model of this was first constructed in [ 16 ] . For a fixed total energy, the maximal localized entropy concentrates all of the energy in a single black hole. We’ve seen

Read the complete text