MAGO-SP: Detection and Correction of Water-Fat Swaps in Magnitude-Only VIBE MRI

Robert Graf, Hendrik Möller, Sophie Starck, Matan Atad, Philipp Braun, Jonathan Stelter, Annette Peters, Lilian Krist, Stefan N. Willich, Henry Völzke, Robin Bülow, Klaus Berger, Tobias Pischon, Thoralf Niendorf, Johannes Paetzold, Dimitrios Karampinos, Daniel Rueckert, Jan Kirschke · 2025

Read MAGO-SP: Detection and Correction of Water-Fat Swaps in Magnitude-Only VIBE MRI by Robert Graf, Hendrik Möller, Sophie Starck, Matan Atad, Philipp Braun, Jonathan Stelter, Annette Peters, Lilian Krist, Stefan N. Willich, Henry Völzke, Robin Bülow, Klaus Berger, Tobias Pischon, Thoralf Niendorf, Johannes Paetzold, Dimitrios Karampinos, Daniel Rueckert, Jan Kirschke (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-14659.txt.

Introduction

Robert Graf and co-authors build MAGO-SP, a pipeline that catches and fixes water-fat swaps in MRI scans. A breath-hold scan type splits tissue signal into water and fat images. Mix-ups during rebuilding can swap the two, wrecking fat fraction measures. Their three-step system first learns to label volumes as fat-like or water-like.

Fake swaps, made by blending volumes with cloud-like noise, train that sorter. A diffusion model then predicts a clean water image as a guide. A physics-based solver folds the guide in and recovers true signals. Swap detection error fell under one percent on the six-point scan. Swaps hit underweight and very obese patients most often.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert Graf, Hendrik Möller, Sophie Starck, Matan Atad, Philipp Braun, Jonathan Stelter, Annette Peters, Lilian Krist, Stefan N. Willich, Henry Völzke, Robin Bülow, Klaus Berger, Tobias Pischon, Thoralf Niendorf, Johannes Paetzold, Dimitrios Karampinos, Daniel Rueckert, Jan Kirschke
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-14659

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

MAGO-SP: Detection and Correction of Water-Fat Swaps in Magnitude-Only VIBE MRI Robert Graf, Hendrik Möller, Sophie Starck, Matan Atad, Philipp Braun, Jonathan Stelter, Annette Peters, Lilian Krist, Stefan N. Willich, Henry Völzke, Robin Bülow, Klaus Berger, Tobias Pischon, Thoralf Niendorf, Johannes Paetzold, Dimitrios Karampinos, Daniel Rueckert, Jan Kirschke Abstract Volume Interpolated Breath-Hold Examination (VIBE) MRI generates images suitable for water and fat signal composition estimation. While the two-point VIBE provides water-fat-separated images, the six-point VIBE allows estimation of the effective transversal relaxation rate R2* and the proton density fat fraction (PDFF), which are imaging markers for health and disease. Ambiguity during signal reconstruction can lead to water-fat swaps. This shortcoming challenges the application of VIBE-MRI for automated PDFF analyses of large-scale clinical data and of population studies. This study develops an automated pipeline to detect and correct water-fat swaps in non-contrast-enhanced VIBE images. Our three-step pipeline begins with training a segmentation network to classify volumes as “fat-like” or “water-like,” using synthetic water-fat swaps generated by merging fat and water volumes with Perlin noise. Next, a denoising diffusion image-to-image network predicts water volumes as signal priors for correction. Finally, we integrate this prior into a physics-constrained model to recover accurate water and fat signals. Our approach achieves a < 1% error rate in water-fat swap detection for a 6-point VIBE. Notably, swaps disproportionately affect individuals in the Underweight and Class 3 Obesity BMI categories. Our correction algorithm ensures accurate solution selection in chemical phase MRIs, enabling reliable PDFF estimation. This forms a solid technical foundation for automated large-scale population imaging analysis. 1 Introduction Figure 1: Example of two and six-point Dixon data where the reconstruction from MRI-device vendor failed. The wrong result is selected during the solution selection due to signal ambiguity. We highlighted the liver in the 6-point Dixon in purple. Estimating fat and water fractions in soft tissue is essential, as these serve as key markers for metabolic health, body composition, and disease risk, playing a crucial role in conditions such as obesity, diabetes, and hepatic steatosis [ 2 , 11 , 19 ] . The Dixon MRI technique utilizes multiple a series of MRIs acquired at different echo times (TE) to determine whether protons are bound to water or fat. Due to atomic bonding differences, fat-bound protons experience a shift in their Larmor frequency relative to water, causing them in phase and out of phase states between water and fat signals. By acquiring and reconstructing a series of MRI data as a function of the echo time TE, it is possible to estimate the effective transverse relaxation rate R_{2}^{*} and the proton densities of water ( \rho_{W} ) and fat ( \rho_{F} ) [ 16 ] . The general signal equation is given by: s[t_{i}]=\left(\rho_{W}+\rho_{F}\cdot\sum_{p=1}^{P}\alpha_{p}e^{j2\pi f_{p}t_{i}}\right)\cdot e^{j2\pi\psi t_{i}+\phi_{0}}\cdot e^{-R_{2}^{*}t_{i}}, where the complex echo signal at echo time t_{i} is denoted as s[t_{i}] . f_{p} and \alpha_{p} represent the frequencies and relative strengths of fat’s multiple spectral peaks, and \psi accounts for field inhomogeneity. Accurate reconstruction of this signal requires parameter estimation using a fat peak model measured in vivo [ 7 , 21 , 26 ] . Incorporating phase information helps resolve local minima and typically outperforms magnitude-only methods [ 9 , 20 ] . However, clinical MRI systems commonly store and export only magnitude data, leading to the loss of phase information and necessitating magnitude-only methods. When only magnitude signals |s[t_{i}]| are available, the model simplifies to: \left|s\left[t_{i}\right]\right|=\left|\rho_{W}+\rho_{F}\cdot\sum_{p=1}^{P}\alpha_{p}e^{j2\pi f_{p}t_{i}}\right|\cdot e^{-R^{*}_{2}t_{i}}. In the commonly used 2-point Dixon method, R_{2}^{*} effects are ignored, and a single fat peak is assumed. This further simplifies the equations to: S_{0}=\left|\tilde{\rho}_{W}-\tilde{\rho}_{F}\right|,\quad S_{1}=\left|\tilde{\rho}_{W}+\tilde{\rho}_{F}\right|, where \tilde{\rho}_{W} and \tilde{\rho}_{F} are estimates of the water and fat signals, respectively. Figure 2: Our proposed pipeline. We detect water-fat swaps by segmenting them into the water and fat volume. If a swap is detected, we generate a signal prior from the raw data and then use the physically constrained method to reconstruct the water and fat images. Our proposed steps are agnostic towards the number of gradient echos and the type of the applied physics model. Water-fat swaps occur when water and fat signals are incorrectly assigned due to the off-resonance effects caused by non-convex estimation of magnetic field inhomogeneities and potential additional phase errors (see Figure 1 ). In two-point VIBE, the estimated water ( \tilde{\rho}_{W} ) and fat ( \tilde{\rho}_{F} ) signals can be swapped due to inherent ambiguities in the limited data. In contrast, VIBE with more than two echoes is generally more robust against water-fat swaps. When working with complex signals, magnetic field inhomogeneities can be explicitly estimated, but phase wrapping may still introduce swaps if not properly handled [ 17 ] . Noise and modeling inaccuracies can cause localized phase-wrapping errors to propagate, affecting larger regions or even the entire volume. When only magnitude information is available, two-point VIBE provides insufficient data to reliably reconstruct water-fat images. The MAGO (MAGnitude-Only) method [ 25 ] addresses multi-echo Dixon ambiguities by selecting the global minimum with the smallest residual among two local minima. However, this approach can yield incorrect solutions for certain pixels. Smoothing the residual helps reduce single-pixel artifacts but does not fully correct larger areas or subtle structures. The MAGORINO (MAGnitude-Only with Rician noise modeling) method [ 1 ] extends MAGO by incorporating Rician noise estimation, improving accuracy in voxels with low fat signal. We further enhanced MAGO and MAGORINO by refining their multipoint search method and incorporating deep learning to predict an initial solution using a signal prior. Our signal prior can also be applied to two-point VIBE images, helping to disentangle fat and water by resolving ambiguities in the simplified physics model: \tilde{\rho}_{W},\tilde{\rho}_{F}=\left|S_{0}\pm S_{1}\right|. Our objective is to solve the automatic detection and correction of water-fat swap in a physics-aware manner [ 14 ] . We propose a processing pipeline that incorporates the following observations: Organs exhibit characteristic water or fat signals, allowing a definition of expected values to resolve ambiguities. A segmentation model can classify whether an observed region belongs to the fat or water solution for a region of interest [ 8 ] . With these insights, we introduce a robust framework (Figure 2 ) called "MAGnitude-Only with Signal Prior" (MAGO-SP): (1) Train a segmentation network to classify regions as fat-like or water-like using synthetic water-fat swaps as training data. (2) Predict the water image as a "signal prior" with denoising diffusion [ 10 , 23 ] image-to-image network. (3) Refine the reconstruction using a classical optimization approach based on magnitude-based fitting with a multi-peak fat model [ 7 , 21 ] . This pipeline addresses water-fat swaps by integrating segmentation, deep learning priors, and physics-based optimization. 2 Dataset Figure 3: In Vivo water reconstruction of 2-point Dixon VIBE. Our method retrospectively corrected the swaps. Swaps are marked with red arrows. Our experiments used 2-point- or 6-point 3D gradient echo VIBE data, with echo time t_{x}=1.23\cdot(x+1) ms. The MRI exam of the German National Cohort (NAKO) has 30,293 participants. This includes a 6-point VIBE MRI with the target region being the liver (axial slices, 1.64 mm in-plane, 4 mm slice thickness) and 2-point VIBE MRI with a field of view from above the knee to the neck (1.4 mm in-plane,

Read the complete text