PROTOCALC, A W-band polarized calibrator for CMB Telescopes: application to Simons Observatory and CLASS
Gabriele Coppi, Nadia Dachlythra, Federico Nati, Rolando Dünner-Planella, Alexandre E. Adler, Josquin Errard, Nicholas Galitzki, Yunyang Li, Matthew A. Petroff, Sara M. Simon, Ema Tsang King Sang, Amalia Villarrubia Aguilar, Edward J. Wollack, Mario Zannoni · 2025
Read PROTOCALC, A W-band polarized calibrator for CMB Telescopes: application to Simons Observatory and CLASS by Gabriele Coppi, Nadia Dachlythra, Federico Nati, Rolando Dünner-Planella, Alexandre E. Adler, Josquin Errard, Nicholas Galitzki, Yunyang Li, Matthew A. Petroff, Sara M. Simon, Ema Tsang King Sang, Amalia Villarrubia Aguilar, Edward J. Wollack, Mario Zannoni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-14473.txt.
Introduction
Gabriele Coppi and co-authors build a flying calibrator for telescopes that map the faint glow left from the early universe, in a 2025 paper. New maps of that glow are so sharp that the tools' own traits, above all their angle for polarized light, must be known to fine limits. Bright sky sources that could set the angle are scarce.
Their source, PROTOCALC, flies on a drone and beams a steady signal near 90 gigahertz, a common band for ground maps. Lab tests and computer models fed the Simons Observatory pipeline. Field runs in the Atacama desert pinned the source's roll angle to within a twentieth of a degree.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriele Coppi, Nadia Dachlythra, Federico Nati, Rolando Dünner-Planella, Alexandre E. Adler, Josquin Errard, Nicholas Galitzki, Yunyang Li, Matthew A. Petroff, Sara M. Simon, Ema Tsang King Sang, Amalia Villarrubia Aguilar, Edward J. Wollack, Mario Zannoni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-14473
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
PROTOCALC, A W-band polarized calibrator for CMB Telescopes: application to Simons Observatory and CLASS Gabriele Coppi, Nadia Dachlythra, Federico Nati, Rolando Dünner-Planella, Alexandre E. Adler, Josquin Errard, Nicholas Galitzki, Yunyang Li, Matthew A. Petroff, Sara M. Simon, Ema Tsang King Sang, Amalia Villarrubia Aguilar, Edward J. Wollack, Mario Zannoni Abstract Current- and next-generation Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) experiments will measure polarization anisotropies with unprecedented sensitivities. The need for high precision in these measurements underscores the importance of gaining a comprehensive understanding of instrument properties, with a particular emphasis on the study of the beam properties and, in particular, their polarization characteristics, and the measurement of the polarization angle. In this context, a major challenge lies in the scarcity of millimeter polarized astrophysical sources with sufficient brightness and calibration knowledge to meet the stringent accuracy requirements of future CMB missions. This led to the development of a drone-borne calibration source designed for frequency band centered on approximately 90 GHz 90\text{\,}\mathrm{GHz} band, matching a commonly used channel in ground based CMB measurements. The PROTOtype CALibrator for Cosmology, PROTOCALC, has undergone thorough in-lab testing, and its properties have been subsequently modeled through simulation software integrated into the standard Simons Observatory (SO) analysis pipeline. Moreover, the PROTOCALC system has been tested in the field, having been deployed twice on calibration campaigns with CMB telescopes in the Atacama desert. The data collected constrain the roll angle of the source with a statistical accuracy of 0.045 ° 0.045\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolDegree} . Journal: ApJs . I Introduction Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) observations have been foundational to our understanding of the evolution of the Universe and its energy content. Measurements of the small-scale CMB temperature and polarization fields allow us to constrain the cosmological parameters, measure the effective number of relativistic species, and set limits to primordial non-Gaussianity [ 47 , 49 ] . Furthermore, the large-scale CMB power spectrum retains an almost scale-invariant form and can thus be employed to study the early Universe and initial conditions [ 55 ] . A particularly interesting aspect which refers to the CMB polarization is that it can be decomposed into a strong, curl-free, and even-parity component, E-modes, and a fainter odd-parity and divergence-free component, B-modes [ 32 ] . A key difference between the two components is that, while E -modes can be produced both by scalar and tensor perturbations of the space-time metric, the primordial B -modes the CMB community is seeking can only be sourced by tensor perturbations. Although the CMB community has obtained precise measurements of the E -mode spectra [ 34 , 48 , 18 ] , a detection of primordial B -modes has not yet been achieved. Such detection would provide a significant probe of cosmic inflation [ 28 , 50 ] , the current leading theory for initial perturbations, according to which an initially small patch of the Universe underwent abrupt, exponential expansion at very early times. According to most inflationary models, an inevitable consequence in this scenario would be the creation of ripples in space-time that are expressed through tensor perturbations of the metric and can be thus probed via the CMB B -modes [ 29 ] . To quantify the inflationary gravitational wave signal we can detect from the CMB maps, we employ the so-called tensor-to-scalar ratio, r , i.e. the ratio between the amplitude of tensor and the scalar perturbations. The present upper-limit on the scalar-to-tensor ratio is, r<0.036 , at a 95\% confidence level (C.L.) and associated uncertainty of \sigma(r)=0.009 [ 6 ] . Current-generation experiments like the Simons Observatory (SO) Small Aperture Telescopes (SATs) aim at constraining the tensor-to-scalar ratio with a statistical uncertainty of \sigma(r)=0.003 or better [ 54 ] , while next-generation telescopes like LiteBIRD and CMB-S4 will attempt a r<0.003 detection with a statistical uncertainty of \sigma(r)<0.001 [ 24 , 1 ] . Measuring r to that level of precision demands exceptionally high accuracy in characterizing all potential systematic effects, achieved through a thorough understanding of the instrument’s performance. In particular, great caution must be taken when calibrating the spatial response of the optical system - commonly referred to as the instrument’s Point-Spread-Function (PSF) or beam - and the absolute orientation of each polarization-sensitive detector in the telescopes’ focal planes, commonly referred to as the absolute polarization angle. Beam systematics such as ellipticity, increased power at large angles away from the beam center (sidelobes), or cross-polar sensitivity may cause the strong temperature signal to leak into the fainter polarization data or lead to mixing between the two polarization components [ 25 , 39 , 52 , 15 , 36 ] . These are commonly modeled relying on planet observations. However, planets are not always sufficiently bright/available to reach the required calibration accuracies and, being effectively unpolarized, can not be used to calibrate the polarization angle. A miscalibrated polarization angle can assign part of the E -mode signal to the CMB B -mode component, affecting the r -tensor constraint and producing a spurious signal that could be mistaken for cosmic birefringence. Birefringence describes signature of parity-violating physics on the CMB and can serve as a probe of physical processes beyond the Standard Model of cosmology [ 9 , 8 , 41 ] . For CMB experiments, one can correct the polarization angle by assuming that any non-zero CMB EB spectra are the result of an angle calibration error [ 30 , 33 ] . This error can be either simply corrected in the analysis or further studied as the combination of a true instrumental miscalibration and a rotation due to cosmic birefringence [ 27 , 14 ] . However, in order to meaningfully separate these two contributions, the detectors’ polarization angles of the experiment in question must already be calibrated with exceptional precision [ 44 , 40 , 42 ] . For the reasons outlined above, it is clear that employing a strongly emitting, fully polarized millimeter-wave source is crucial for achieving the highest calibration accuracy in current and next-generation CMB instruments. In practice, the population of astrophysical sources with brightness well matched to the calibration needs of CMB experiments is limited and is further reduced upon considering polarization. Consideration of the subset sources that are also polarized further reduces the number of potential calibration candidates. Planets are the most common candidates for calibrating CMB experiments [ 58 , 23 , 53 , 36 , 12 ] , but they are often subject to availability issues when scanning from the ground and are very faintly polarized (maximum polarization fraction corresponds to Uranus and is less than 3.6\% according to [ 46 ] ). The most promising natural candidate for polarization is Tau A (the Crab Nebula) and allows for the determination of the average polarization angle with accuracy \Delta\psi\simeq 0.33$\SIUnitSymbolDegree$ [ 4 ] . This will not be sufficient for the \leq 0.2\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolDegree} polarization angle accuracy required at 90\text{\,} and 150\text{\,}\mathrm{GHz} by modern experiments like SO [ 2 ] , aiming to constraints the tensor-to-scalar ratio with biases smaller than \Delta r\simeq 10^{-3} . It is also reasonable to expect that this requirement will become even more stringent for upcoming ground-based missions such as CMB-S4 [ 1 ] . Instead, for cosmic birefringence measurements, the requirements are even