The origin and scarcity of breathing pyrochlore lattices in spinel oxides

Valentina Mazzotti, Solveig S. Aamlid, Abraham A. Mancilla, Janna Machts, Megan Rutherford, Jörg Rottler, Kenji M. Kojima, Alannah M. Hallas · 2025

Read The origin and scarcity of breathing pyrochlore lattices in spinel oxides by Valentina Mazzotti, Solveig S. Aamlid, Abraham A. Mancilla, Janna Machts, Megan Rutherford, Jörg Rottler, Kenji M. Kojima, Alannah M. Hallas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-14089.txt.

Introduction

Valentina Mazzotti and co-authors present a 2025 physics paper on why a beautiful crystal pattern is so rare in nature. Breathing pyrochlores arrange magnetic atoms on corner-sharing tetrahedra that alternate big and small, like a lattice inhaling. Only a couple of spinel oxides, both chromium based, are known to do it.

The team tried swapping chromium for other magnetic metals and watched the pattern collapse. Computer calculations on the two known materials traced the protection to one preference: chromium ions strongly favor octahedral sites. That stubbornness locks the host lattice in place so the breathing distortion can survive. Exchange forces between the chromium spins were weighed as well. The recipe for new breathing materials, it seems, must respect that site loyalty.

Catalog record

CREATORValentina Mazzotti, Solveig S. Aamlid, Abraham A. Mancilla, Janna Machts, Megan Rutherford, Jörg Rottler, Kenji M. Kojima, Alannah M. Hallas
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-14089

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The origin and scarcity of breathing pyrochlore lattices in spinel oxides Valentina Mazzotti, Solveig S. Aamlid, Abraham A. Mancilla, Janna Machts, Megan Rutherford, Jörg Rottler, Kenji M. Kojima, Alannah M. Hallas Abstract Breathing pyrochlores are a unique class of materials characterized by a three-dimensional lattice of corner-sharing tetrahedra. However, unlike conventional pyrochlores where all tetrahedra are identical in size, the breathing pyrochlore lattice is composed of alternating large and small tetrahedra. Experimental realizations of the breathing pyrochlore lattice are rare but they do occur in A A -site ordered spinels, as in the prototype materials LiGaCr 4 O 8 and LiInCr 4 O 8 . In this work, we demonstrate that Cr cannot be straightforwardly substituted with other magnetic transition metals while retaining the breathing pyrochlore structure. To explain this observation, we perform density functional theory (DFT) calculations to investigate the formation and stability of LiGaCr 4 O 8 and LiInCr 4 O 8 , focusing on the energy scales associated with A A and B B -site orderings as well as the magnetic exchange interactions of Cr ions. We identify the strong octahedral site preference of Cr 3+ \text{Cr}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}^{\text{3+}} as a key factor in protecting the structural integrity of the pyrochlore sublattice, which in turn enables the breathing distortion to proceed. We also demonstrate that the charge order between the A A (Li) and A ′ A^{\prime} sites (Ga or In) is maintained at all temperatures up to decomposition. Furthermore, while the magnetic exchange interactions constitute a relatively small energy scale and therefore do not play a fundamental role in the structural stability of LiGaCr 4 O 8 and LiInCr 4 O 8 , magnetism may play a critical role in setting the magnitude of the tetrahedral distortion. Ultimately, we conclude that the scarcity of breathing pyrochlores is a consequence of the stringent requirement on site ordering for their formation. Introduction Complex oxides display remarkable functionalities that are intricately linked with their cation orderings. Isomorphic complex oxides often form solid solutions where some cations share a single sublattice, depending on considerations related to charge, ionic radii, and polarizability [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . In the opposing limit, complex oxides sometimes form superstructures in which the cations order on distinct sublattices, as observed in double perovskites [ 4 , 5 ] and rocksalt-type lithium transition metal oxides [ 6 ] . Consequently, the tendency for oxides to tolerate disorder and their propensity to realize more complex ordered structures are key factors in optimizing their functionalities. Figure 1: The relationship between the cation disordered spinel and the distorted breathing pyrochlore lattice. (a) The parent phase for the breathing pyrochlores, LiGaCr 4 O 8 and LiInCr 4 O 8 , is a cubic spinel (space group Fd\overline{3}m with chemical formula AB_{2} O 4 in which the cations sharing the A -site are randomly distributed and the B -site cation forms an undistorted corner-sharing tetrahedral (pyrochlore) lattice. (b) We show that cation ordering of the A -site energetically precedes the distortion of the pyrochlore sublattice, as represented by this hypothetical intermediate structure, which can be interpreted as a site-ordered but undistorted spinel . (c) The experimentally observed breathing pyrochlore structure for LiGaCr 4 O 8 and LiInCr 4 O 8 , in the cubic F\overline{4}3m space group with chemical formula AA^{\prime}B_{4} O 8 . This structure exhibits both A -site cation ordering and a distorted breathing pyrochlore B -site sublattice characterized by alternating small and large tetrahedra, which have been exaggerated here for visual clarity. In this context, one particularly interesting family of materials is the spinel oxides, with the chemical formula AB_{2} O 4 , shown in Fig 1 (a). The spinel structure is made up of tetrahedrally oxygen-coordinated cations at the A site and octahedrally oxygen-coordinated cations at the B site, which form diamond and pyrochlore lattices, respectively. Spinels are known for their chemical versatility, their ability to form solid solutions [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , and their structural instabilities that involve charge, spin, and orbital degrees of freedom [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . One well understood structural phenomenon in the spinels is their tendency towards cation inversion [ 14 , 15 ] . In structures termed normal spinels, the A site is exclusively occupied by a divalent cation, and the B site is occupied by trivalent cations. In partially or fully inverse spinels, the A site is partially or completely occupied by a trivalent cation. The degree of inversion is often dictated by crystal field effects and can, in some cases, be experimentally controlled through synthesis conditions [ 16 , 17 ] . In the fully inverted limit, or in cases where two or more distinct cations share the octahedral site, spinels will often undergo cation ordering on the B -sublattice , leading to more complex structural motifs [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . By comparison, cation order on the A sublattice is rare, with the notable exception of the “breathing pyrochlore” distortion, which is the focus of this work. Spinels with a breathing pyrochlore distortion crystallize in the space group F\overline{4}3m , which is a subgroup of the conventional spinel Fd\overline{3}m [ 21 , 22 ] . Charge ordering of two cations that share the A -site leads to compounds with the formula unit AA^{\prime}B_{4} O 8 , which can be understood as a doubling of the standard spinel formula unit AB_{2} O 4 [ 23 ] . The monovalent A and trivalent A\textquoteright cations occupy alternating tetrahedral sites producing a relative contraction and expansion of their local environments. This ordering of the A site cation in turn disrupts the B cation sublattice, which in conventional spinels forms a uniform pyrochlore lattice. The resulting breathing pyrochlore sublattice of the B site cations is characterized by a corner-sharing array of alternating small and large tetrahedra [ 24 ] , as can be seen in Fig. 1 (c). The degree of the tetrahedral distortion can be quantified by the ratio of the bond distances, d/d^{\prime} , where d and d^{\prime} are the cation-cation bond distances within the small and large tetrahedra, respectively. Alternatively, in cases where the breathing pyrochlore lattice is occupied by a magnetic cation, the breathing factor can be quantified by the ratio of the magnetic exchange couplings, B_{f}=J^{\prime}/J where J and J^{\prime} are the coupling parameters in the small and large tetrahedra, respectively. Breathing pyrochlore lattices have attracted a lot of interest in the context of their complex magnetism and geometric frustration [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ] . However, a limiting factor has been the scarcity of materials realizations. There are only five known A -site ordered spinels and of these, two are nonmagnetic (LiGaRh 4 O 8 and LiInRh 4 O 8 [ 21 ] ) and a third has a secondary magnetic element off the breathing pyrochlore sublattice complicating its description (LiFeCr 4 O 8 [ 32 ] ). The two remaining magnetically unambiguous examples are LiGaCr 4 O 8 and LiInCr 4 O 8 , which both have Cr 3+ S=\nicefrac{{3}}{{2}} occupying the breathing pyrochlore B sublattice [ 21 , 25 ]

Read the complete text