Human-Artificial Interaction in the Age of Agentic AI: A System-Theoretical Approach

Uwe M. Borghoff, Paolo Bottoni, Remo Pareschi · 2025

Read Human-Artificial Interaction in the Age of Agentic AI: A System-Theoretical Approach by Uwe M. Borghoff, Paolo Bottoni, Remo Pareschi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-14000.txt.

Introduction

Uwe Borghoff, Paolo Bottoni, and Remo Pareschi present in 2025 a systems view of how people and artificial agents interact as AI agents grow more capable. Older views focus on the interface between one person and one machine. Their view stresses coordination and talk among mixed agents with different skills, roles, and goals inside a network.

They contrast two patterns of teamwork. In one, agents stay separate and cooperate through set protocols. In the other, human and AI skills merge into a single decision making unit. A layered frame for communication spaces joins the two, with formal nets used to model each. Uses range from autonomous robots to decision support and cognitive systems.

Catalog record

CREATORUwe M. Borghoff, Paolo Bottoni, Remo Pareschi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-14000

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Human-Artificial Interaction in the Age of Agentic AI: A System-Theoretical Approach Uwe M. Borghoff, Paolo Bottoni, Remo Pareschi Abstract This paper presents a novel perspective on human-computer interaction (HCI), framing it as a dynamic interplay between human and computational agents within a networked system. Going beyond traditional interface-based approaches, we emphasize the importance of coordination and communication among heterogeneous agents with different capabilities, roles, and goals. A key distinction is made between multi-agent systems (MAS) and Centaurian systems, which represent two different paradigms of human-AI collaboration. MAS maintain agent autonomy, with structured protocols enabling cooperation, while Centaurian systems deeply integrate human and AI capabilities, creating unified decision-making entities. To formalize these interactions, we introduce a framework for communication spaces, structured into surface, observation, and computation layers, ensuring seamless integration between MAS and Centaurian architectures, where colored Petri nets effectively represent structured Centaurian systems and high-level reconfigurable networks address the dynamic nature of MAS. Our research has practical applications in autonomous robotics, human-in-the-loop decision making, and AI-driven cognitive architectures, and provides a foundation for next-generation hybrid intelligence systems that balance structured coordination with emergent behavior. 1 Introduction Agentic AI systems—capable of iterative planning, autonomous task decomposition, and continuous learning—are rapidly reshaping the landscape of human–computer interaction (HCI). Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) and advanced conversational agents have revitalized the field of multi-agent systems, whose roots in Artificial Intelligence predate the current rise of generative AI. Historically, multi-agent systems relied on agents with relatively constrained capabilities; however, the emergence of powerful, conversationally adept LLMs significantly broadens the scope of possible multi-agent interactions. In this new paradigm, humans themselves can participate as fully capable agents, thanks to their innate conversational and decision-making faculties. The result is a complex, interconnected ecosystem [ 27 ] . Simultaneously, novel and more direct forms of human–AI integration are emerging [ 46 , 49 ] , in which advanced AI cognition is harnessed to create “Centaurian” intelligence—a seamless fusion of human and machine-driven capabilities. These developments push beyond traditional HCI in two distinct directions that mirror fundamental patterns found in biological systems [ 6 , 7 , 39 ] . Multi-agent systems, like biological ecosystems, emphasize how collections of autonomous entities can coordinate effectively while preserving distinct boundaries and roles. In contrast, “Centaurian” systems pursue deeper integration—analogous to symbiotic relationships in nature—fusing human and artificial competencies in tightly knit partnerships that often blur the lines between human decision-making and AI-driven processes. Living systems theory [ 38 ] helps us understand how both approaches must address a core challenge: maintaining system identity through regulated boundaries and feedback loops [ 53 ] , whether in loosely coupled collectives or tightly integrated hybrid intelligences. Herbert Simon’s influential work on cognitive architectures [ 52 ] provides additional insight into how such human-AI integration might be structured. His tripartite model—comprising an external interface, a coding mechanism, and an internal processing system—was originally conceived to explain human problem-solving but extends naturally to hybrid systems. When human abilities merge with artificial intelligence, the resulting configuration can evolve from traditional tool use ( Homo Faber ) to a more profound integration ( Centaurus Faber ) where each component may be instantiated by either human cognition or AI subsystems [ 46 ] . This perspective suggests how system boundaries might be organized to support both autonomous operation and deep integration. To address these architectural challenges, we introduce a formal framework based on Petri nets that can model both multi-agent and Centaurian paradigms while supporting the key requirements suggested by living systems theory and Simon’s architecture: clear boundaries, regulated interactions, and adaptive feedback loops. Our approach, grounded in rigorous process modeling, provides a unified way to specify how heterogeneous agents—human and artificial—can coordinate their activities while either maintaining autonomy or achieving deeper integration as needed. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 analyzes two fundamental paradigms in human–machine collaboration—the multi-agent approach and the Centaurian one—in light of the recent resurgence of agentic AI. Section 3 provides foundational background on Petri nets and their extensions. Section 4 introduces the concept of communication spaces as a unifying framework for these paradigms, grounded in formal architectures and coordination mechanisms. Sections 5 and 6 illustrate these ideas with two use cases, demonstrating how communication spaces can be applied in practical HCI scenarios. Section 7 discusses related work, and Section 8 concludes with implications and future directions. 2 Paradigms in Human-AI Integration The emergence of agentic AI systems has given new life to two distinct approaches for human-AI collaboration: multi-agent architectures and Centaurian integration. This section examines these paradigms in detail, highlighting the distinct challenges each presents for system design and coordination. Indeed, although both paradigms involve interactions between intelligent entities, they represent fundamentally different approaches to human-artificial collaboration [ 46 ] . Multi-agent systems maintain distinct boundaries between components while enabling complex interactions, much like natural ecosystems. In contrast, Centaurian systems mirror the tight integration seen in biological organisms, where components merge functionally to create new capabilities [ 49 ] . 2.1 Architectural Differences The primary architectural distinction lies in how these systems organize and maintain their identity [ 46 ] . Multi-agent systems (MAS) emphasize functional independence, where agents —human or artificial—operate as distinct entities with decision-making capabilities and dynamic collaboration. This design has allowed MAS implementations to thrive even with relatively simple AI agents, focusing on coordination rather than deep integration. Centaurian systems, by contrast, create unified composite entities where human and artificial components become functionally interdependent. Theoretical foundations for such systems trace back to [ 37 ] and [ 23 ] , but their practical feasibility has emerged only recently with generative AI systems capable of complementing human cognitive functions. A key concept in both systems is that of communication spaces —regions of interaction where information exchange and coordination occur. In biological systems, these are signaling pathways or neural networks; in human-machine systems, they manifest as protocols, interfaces, and shared representational spaces [ 14 ] . These spaces enable “joint activity”, characterized by inter-predictability, common ground, and directability. 2.2 Integration Paradigms, Operational Dynamics, and Convergence Points Each paradigm embodies different principles from living systems theory: In MAS , collaboration occurs through well-defined protocols between autonomous agents, resembling distinct organisms in an ecosystem. Effectiveness emerges from collective behavior while maintaining individual identities. In Centaurian systems , integration blurs the boundaries between human and artificial components, forming functionally unified entities similar to biological organisms. The ecosystem versus organism analogy extends to operational dynamics: • Identity Maintenance : MAS preserve distinct agent identities while allowing interaction while, Centaurian systems create new composite identities through integration. • Adaptation Mechanisms : MAS adapt via reconfiguration of agent relationships, while Centaurian systems evolve through internal transformation of integrated components. • System Boundaries : MAS maintain clear boundaries with well-defined interfaces, while Centaurian systems develop permeable boundaries for deep functional integration. Despite these distinctions, some scenarios blur the boundaries between paradigms, especially in adaptive complex systems. Consider large action models (LAMs), where human operators provide training feedback to artificial systems. Depending on the context, these interactions can manifest as multi-agent collaboration or Centaurian integration. Such convergence points suggest that while the paradigms are conceptually distinct, they can complement each other

Read the complete text