On the dynamical evolution of randomness Part A: Random experiments as dynamical systems
Allen Lobo & Saravanan Arumugam · 2025
Read On the dynamical evolution of randomness Part A: Random experiments as dynamical systems by Allen Lobo & Saravanan Arumugam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-13978.txt.
Introduction
Allen Lobo and Saravanan Arumugam treated random trials as dynamic systems in this paper from twenty twenty-five. They grow out of Bernoulli's law of large numbers, the classic rule on how rates settle with many trials. The pair ask how the felt randomness of a trial shifts as trials pile up. A coin toss and a dice roll serve as their worked cases.
By hand and by number runs, they show that the randomness of each outcome can rise by chance. That rise hangs on how fast the felt rates grow. Trial runs and sims check the math. Readers in probability get a flow view of how chance itself seems to move as a trial repeats.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Allen Lobo & Saravanan Arumugam |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-13978
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the dynamical evolution of randomness Part A: Random experiments as dynamical systems Allen Lobo & Saravanan Arumugam Abstract In this work, Bernoulli’s Law of Large Numbers, also known as the Golden theorem, has been extended to study the relations between empirical probability and empirical randomness of an otherwise random experiment. Using the example of a coin toss and a dice role, some interesting results are drawn. Analytically and using numerical computations, empirical randomness of each outcome has been shown to increase by chance , which itself depends on the growth rate of empirical probabilities. The analyses presented in this work, apart form depicting the nature of flow of random experiments in repetitions, also present dynamical behaviours of the random experiment, and experimental and simulation-based verifications of the mathematical analyses. It also presents an appreciation of the beauty of Bernoulli’s Golden theorem and its applications by extension. Keywords: Probability Theory of random experiments; Bernoulli’s Law of Large Numbers; Empirical vs. Theoretical Probability 1 Introduction Historically, in as early as the 16^{th} century, Gerolamo Cardano (in his book Liber de ludo aleae ) [ 1 ] observed a growth of the accuracy of his observations when the number of repetitions were increased. This was followed in the 18^{th} century when Bernoulli presented a mathematics behind it (in his work, Ars Conjectandi ) [ 2 ] as the Law of Large Numbers [ 3 ] . Since then, the Law of Large Numbers has presented an intriguing aspect of the classical probability theory. The Law of Large Numbers (LLN), or Bernoulli’s Golden theorem (as termed by Bernoulli) presents a relation between theoretically defined probability of outcomes of an experiment and the statistics of the outcomes. It states that when the experiment is repeated for a large number of times, the empirically observed statistics of the outcomes match the theoretically predicted probabilities. Since its mathematical formulation by Bernoulli, the LLN has since been presented and modified by many authors [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] , such as the Strong Law of Large Numbers presented by Kolmogorov and the weak law presented by Khinchin. However, the Golden theorem can be analyzed further in order to assess some more aspects of the probabilistic nature of random experiments. One such aspect is the idea of the degree of ”randomness” of an experiment. Randomness, in itself, is a condition of unpredictability of the outcomes of an experiment. Although this necessarily dictates that each outcome of an experiment is equally unbiased, the influence of chance can significantly deviate the empirical probability from the theoretical one. This occurs when, upon successive trials, one output seems to be more biased than others. The LLN dictates that as the number of trials tend towards infinity, this bias reduces to zero, and the empirical probability of each outcome gradually converges to the theoretical predictions. This convergence to the theoretical values is thought to depend on chance, since over repeated experiments, each outcome occurs for a sufficient number of times as the number or repetitions tend towards infinity. Suppose a and b are the outcomes of a random experiment, with equal probabilities P of occurrence, such that P_{a}=P_{b}. (1) As the number of trials N approaches infinity, the number of outcomes of both a (=f_{a}) and b (=f_{b}) must increase. \displaystyle f_{a}+f_{b}=N. (2) \displaystyle\because N\rightarrow\infty,\quad\therefore f_{a}+f_{b}\rightarrow\infty. (3) This implies that one of the following three cases must be satisfied: \displaystyle f_{a}+f_{b}\rightarrow\infty\Leftrightarrow\begin{cases}\text{Only }f_{a}\rightarrow\infty,\text{ or,}\\ \text{Only }f_{b}\rightarrow\infty\text{ or,}\\ \text{Both }f_{a}\text{ and }f_{b}\rightarrow\infty.\end{cases} (4) Both the first and second conditions imply a bias in the outcomes and are against the idea of random outcomes. It therefore makes mathematical sense to state that in a random experiment, for large repetitions, the empirical probabilities P^{\epsilon} of each outcome, which are ratios of individual number of outcomes to total number of trials, become equal. Let P^{\epsilon}_{a} and P^{\epsilon}_{b} be the empirical probabilities of the outcomes a and b , such that \displaystyle P^{\epsilon}_{a}=\frac{f_{a}}{N},\quad P^{\epsilon}_{b}=\frac{f_{b}}{N}. (5) When N\rightarrow\infty , both P^{\epsilon}_{a} and P^{\epsilon}_{b} approach irrational forms of {\infty}/{\infty} . However, the condition P^{\epsilon}_{a}+P^{\epsilon}_{b}=\frac{f_{a}+f_{b}}{N}\equiv 1 (6) must be satisfied. For the same, a limit can be introduced as \lim_{N\to\infty}\quad f_{b}\rightarrow f_{a}. (7) This directly points towards the solution that: P^{\epsilon}_{a}=P^{\epsilon}_{b}, (8) which agrees with the theoretical case. Hence, theoretical probability can be safely regarded as a simple measurement of the possibilities of outcomes in an ideal scenario, which in no way dictates the occurrence of those outcomes. This idea about theoretical probability, although well-understood, is almost counter-intuitive to the reader who, in the case of a random experiment, expects outcomes to occur in the (theoretically) predicted fashion. This therefore presents the following questions: 1. If, upon repetitions, one outcome occurs more frequently than the other(s), is the experiment truly random? In other words, how empirically random is the random experiment ? 2. If each outcome bears an equal probability of occurrence in an ideal random experiment, what dictates the outcomes in each repetition? In other words, what is the mathematics behind chance ? The brief work presented in this communication aims to present arguments and mathematics which aim at answering the enumerated questions above. In order to test the presented mathematical analyses, numerical simulations and quantum experiments have been conducted using computational set-ups. Specifically for the quantum experiment, we have used the IBM-quantum computational facility. We then explore the dynamics of the random experiments and present an explanation for the occurrence of the Law of Large Numbers, based on the observations. 2 Mathematical Analyses We consider a random experiment with m outcomes, each having a random theoretical probability P_{i} (which is ideally equal to 1/m to represent a purely unbiased set-up), where i\in[1,m] . We repeat the experiment n number of times, and measure the frequency of each outcome as f_{i} . The empirical probability P_{i}^{\epsilon} is then calculated as the ratio of the outcome frequency to total number of repetitions, P_{i}^{\epsilon}=\frac{f_{i}}{n}. (9) In this communication, a new measure of the ”randomness” of a system has been presented. Since, classically, randomness is measured using the entropy (\sigma) of the system, we define our measurement of randomness as the \Lambda- entropy (\Lambda_{\sigma}) . We define \Lambda- entropy as the joint empirical probability of all outcomes, \Lambda_{\sigma}=\prod_{i=1}^{m}P^{\epsilon}_{i}=\prod_{i=1}^{m}\frac{f_{i}}{n}=\frac{1}{n^{m}}\prod_{i=1}^{m}f_{i}. (10) The golden theorem dictates that the empirical probabilities must converge to the theoretical probabilities as n\rightarrow\infty . Hence, the \Lambda- entropy must also converge to a point \Lambda_{\sigma}^{0} , where, \Lambda_{\sigma}^{0}=\prod_{i=1}^{m}P_{i}. (11) Hence, at-least two approximations can be presented here in regard to the \Lambda- entropy as per Bernoulli’s LLN, which states that as the number of trials (repetitions) of the random experiment increase towards infinity, according to the Law of Large Numbers, the \Lambda- entropy saturates to \Lambda_{\sigma}^{0} , i.e., \displaystyle\lim_{n\to\infty}\Lambda_{\sigma}=\Lambda_{\sigma}^{0}, (12) \displaystyle\lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{d}{dn}\Lambda_{\sigma}=0. (13) It can be readily realised that for an ideal random experiment, that is to say, for an experiment with no bias in its outcomes, the \Lambda- entropy should be equal to \Lambda_{\sigma}^{0} . Hence, as the experiment starts and proceeds with repetitions such that n\geq m , \Lambda_{\sigma} may deviate away from \Lambda_{\sigma}^{0} . This will occur not due to bias in the outcomes (since the