Beyond Homes scaling: disorder, the Planckian bound and a new universality
D. M. Broun, Vivek Mishra, J. S. Dodge, P. J. Hirschfeld · 2025
Read Beyond Homes scaling: disorder, the Planckian bound and a new universality by D. M. Broun, Vivek Mishra, J. S. Dodge, P. J. Hirschfeld (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-13351.txt.
Introduction
Broun and co-authors revisit a famous scaling law for superconductors, in this 2025 paper. The law, named for Homes, links how much superfluid a material holds to its normal conductivity and its transition temperature. For one symmetry class of superconductors, plain scattering explains the law well. The team ran the same math for the other class, the d-wave materials that include the cuprates.
There, dirty samples break the law in a squared pattern. Adding inelastic scattering restores it. With both axes rescaled by a plasma weight, a new shared pattern appears, ending at a bound on how fast scattering can run. The authors offer the plot as a sorting tool for new materials.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | D. M. Broun, Vivek Mishra, J. S. Dodge, P. J. Hirschfeld |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-13351
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond Homes scaling: disorder, the Planckian bound and a new universality D. M. Broun, Vivek Mishra, J. S. Dodge, P. J. Hirschfeld Abstract Beginning with high- T c T_{c} cuprate materials, it has been observed that many superconductors exhibit so-called “Homes scaling”, in which the zero-temperature superfluid density, ρ s 0 \rho_{s0} , is proportional to the product of the normal-state dc conductivity and the superconducting transition temperature, σ dc T c \sigma_{\mathrm{dc}}T_{c} . For conventional, s s -wave superconductors, such scaling has been shown to be a natural consequence of elastic-scattering disorder, not only in the extreme dirty limit but across a broad range of scattering parameters. Here we show that when an analogous calculation is carried out for elastic scattering in d d -wave superconductors, a stark contrast emerges, with ρ s 0 ∝ ( σ dc T c ) 2 \rho_{s0}\propto\left(\sigma_{\mathrm{dc}}T_{c}\right)^{2} in the dirty limit, in apparent violation of Homes scaling. Within a simple approximate Migdal–Eliashberg treatment of inelastic scattering, we show how Homes scaling is recovered. The normal-state behavior of near optimally doped cuprates is dominated by inelastic scattering, but significant deviations from Homes scaling occur for disorder-dominated cuprate systems, such as underdoped YBa 2 Cu 3 O 6.333 and overdoped La 2-x Sr x CuO 4 , and in very clean materials with little inelastic scattering, such as Sr 2 RuO 4 . We present a revised analysis where both axes of the original Homes scaling plot are normalized by the Drude plasma weight, ω p , D 2 \omega_{p,D}^{2} , and show that new universal scaling emerges, in which the superfluid fractions of dirty s s -wave and dirty d d -wave superconductors coalesce to a single point at which normal-state scattering is occurring at the Planckian bound. The combined result is a new tool for classifying superconductors in terms of order parameter symmetry, as well as scattering strength and character. Although our model starts from a Fermi-liquid assumption it describes underdoped cuprates surprisingly well. I Introduction Since condensed matter physics deals with a huge variety of materials, universal relations highlighting commonalities among disparate systems are often extremely valuable to deduce fundamental laws of nature. Well-known examples are given by the universal ratios that occur in the BCS theory of superconductivity [ 1 ] , relating properties of paired Fermi systems with interactions and degeneracy temperatures varying over many orders of magnitude, or scaling relations that reflect the irrelevance of details of a system near its critical point [ 2 ] . One scaling relation that appears extremely important but whose origin has proved elusive is so-called “Homes scaling”, proposed initially by Dordevic et al. [ 3 ] and Homes et al. [ 4 ] as a way to highlight common behavior of several families of cuprate superconductors. “Homes’ Law” states that the zero-temperature superfluid density \rho_{s0}\equiv\rho_{s}(T\!=\!0)\propto\sigma_{\mathrm{dc}}T_{c} , where \sigma_{\mathrm{dc}} is the dc conductivity and T_{c} is the critical temperature. While several theoretical proposals [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] have invoked exotic aspects of cuprate physics such as non-Fermi liquid behavior to explain Homes scaling, others have derived similar scaling based on models of granularity [ 9 ] or pointlike disorder in dirty s -wave superconductors [ 10 , 11 ] . The inadequacy of any single one of these explanations was underlined by the extension of Homes scaling to conventional electron–phonon and organic superconductors [ 12 ] , i.e., including systems with both s - and d -wave pairing, with significantly different degrees of inhomogeneity and disorder. We believe that the role of disorder in Homes scaling deserves further attention, since at first glance impurities should cause very different effects in s - and d -wave superconductors: nonmagnetic disorder has virtually no effect on T_{c} in s -wave systems whereas even weak disorder breaks d -wave pairs. We therefore begin a re-examination of Homes scaling by calculating the superfluid density, T_{c} and conductivity for a simple d -wave model in the presence of disorder, and show that it produces a fundamentally different scaling in the dirty limit. This raises the question of why cuprates obey Homes scaling at all. To address this question, we consider the effects of inelastic scattering via a simple Migdal–Eliashberg model with s -wave or d -wave pairing [ 13 ] , employing a strong-scattering boson spectrum that has been used to roughly characterize optimally doped cuprates [ 14 ] . When the characteristic boson frequency, \Omega_{\mathrm{B}} , is several times T_{c} , one obtains a normal state scattering rate \hbar\Gamma\sim k_{B}T_{c} — i.e., a scattering rate at the Planckian limit. We then show that when both axes of the original Homes scaling plot are rescaled by the Drude plasma weight, \omega_{p,D}^{2} , a new universal scaling emerges, in which the superfluid fractions of dirty s -wave and dirty d -wave superconductors coalesce to a single point at which normal-state scattering is occurring at the Planckian bound. This restores Homes scaling for d -wave superconductors dominated by strong inelastic scattering (e.g., optimally doped cuprates and the heavy fermion superconductor CeCoIn 5 ), but retains the stark dichotomy between s -wave and d -wave superconductors in cases where the normal-state inelastic scattering is weak (e.g., heavily underdoped YBa 2 Cu 3 O 6.333 and strongly overdoped La 2-x Sr x CuO 4 ). The revised scaling plot is well supported by data on a wide range of conventional and unconventional superconductors, and suggests that the prevalence of Planckian-limit scattering in many different materials [ 15 ] underlies the ubiquity of the original Homes scaling. Figure 1: Homes scaling (gray line) shown alongside theory curves for pointlike elastic scattering disorder, revealing different dirty-limit power-laws for s -wave and d -wave superconductors. Elastic scattering curves have been plotted for two choices of Drude plasma frequency: \omega_{p,D}=10^{4} cm -1 (solid lines) characteristic of typical cuprates; and \omega_{p,D}=7\times 10^{4} cm -1 (dashed lines) characteristic of an elemental metal such as Nb. In the d -wave case, results depend on the scattering phase shift of the impurities and are bounded by the Born and unitarity limits. Also plotted is a selection of data for various superconductors, used throughout the paper and summarized in Table 1 . Here we present our main results by way of summarizing the logical flow of the paper. Details of derivations and discussion of data are postponed until later sections. First, in Sec. II , we review expected Homes scaling in systems with elastic scattering only. The result in the case of isotropic s -wave superconductors [ 10 , 11 ] , that \rho_{s0}\propto\sigma_{\mathrm{dc}}T_{c} in the dirty limit, is recovered. However, a similar calculation for the d -wave case, which seems not to have been presented heretofore, yields a different scaling relation, \rho_{s0}\propto(\sigma_{\mathrm{dc}}T_{c})^{2} . This very different behavior in the dirty limit arises of course from the fact that potential scatterers break pairs in d -wave superconductors, but may also be related more intuitively to the conductivity spectral weight lost in the low- T superconducting state, as will be discussed later. These very different scaling behaviors are shown superposed on a familiar Homes scaling plot in Fig. 1 , including experimental data for