Dynamics of stellar systems with collisions: eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in nearly collisionless limit
Evgeny V. Polyachenko, Ilia G. Shukhman · 2025
Read Dynamics of stellar systems with collisions: eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in nearly collisionless limit by Evgeny V. Polyachenko, Ilia G. Shukhman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-13279.txt.
Introduction
Evgeny Polyachenko and Ilia Shukhman study stellar systems where rare collisions matter. Their 2025 arXiv paper looks at perturbations in a uniform self-gravitating model. The stars follow a Maxwellian distribution at the start. Without collisions, damping hides the true shape of the modes. Perturbations fade through Landau damping, a classic effect.
The density change fades fast, but the distribution itself grows wavy in velocity space. So the fading modes are not true eigenmodes of the system. The authors call them quasi-modes instead. Even rare collisions stop those steep velocity gradients from forming. Earlier work showed collisions erase such fine structure. The paper works out eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for the nearly collisionless case. It clarifies what damping really means here.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Evgeny V. Polyachenko, Ilia G. Shukhman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-13279
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dynamics of stellar systems with collisions: eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in nearly collisionless limit Evgeny V. Polyachenko, Ilia G. Shukhman Abstract We examine the decay of perturbations in an infinite homogeneous self-gravitating model with a Maxwellian distribution function (DF) when weak collisions are present. In collisionless systems within the stable parameter range, the eigenvalue spectrum consists of a continuous set of real frequencies associated with van Kampen modes, which are singular eigenfunctions of the stellar DF. An initial perturbation in the stellar density and gravitational potential decays exponentially through a superposition of these modes, a phenomenon known as Landau damping. However, the perturbation in the stellar DF does not decay self-similarly; it becomes increasingly oscillatory in velocity space over time, indicating the absence of eigenfunctions corresponding to the Landau damping eigenfrequencies. Consequently, we refer to perturbations undergoing Landau damping as quasi-modes rather than true eigenmodes. Even rare collisions suppress the formation of steep DF gradients in velocity space. Ng & Bhattacharjee (2021) demonstrated that introducing collisions eliminates van Kampen modes and transforms Landau quasi-modes into true eigenmodes forming a complete set. As the collision frequency approaches zero, their eigenfrequencies converge to those of the collisionless Landau quasi-modes. In this study, we investigate the behavior of the eigenfunction of the least-damped aperiodic mode as the collision frequency approaches zero. We derive analytic expressions for the eigenfunction in the resonance region and for the damping rate as a function of collision frequency. Additionally, we employ the standard matrix eigenvalue problem approach to numerically verify our analytical results. I Introduction Simplifying the Boltzmann kinetic equation equation by discarding the collision term yields the [ 27 ] equation. This simplification is often justified by comparing the collision time with the characteristic dynamical times of the system. When the collision time is significantly longer, the Vlasov equation provides a useful approximation. This simplified equation offers considerable advantages, especially in the analytical study of stellar systems – for instance, in investigating their stability or the evolution of perturbations arising from various external sources. It also clarifies conceptual aspects of stellar system dynamics, particularly their eigenmode spectrum. The question of mode spectra in collisionless electron plasmas, analogous to stellar systems, was initially addressed by Landau [13] . Though not explicitly framed as such, Landau’s work examined the evolution of small perturbations in electron density, or electric potential, and distribution function (DF). It demonstrated that density/potential perturbations, at large times, are a sum of decaying exponentials (Landau damping). However, the DF does not decay; it develops increasing corrugation in velocity space. Consequently, no DF eigenfunctions correspond to the Landau damping rates. Later, [ 26 ] and [ 5 ] clarified how Landau damping, discovered in an initial value setting, relates to the eigenmode spectrum. They showed that Landau damping follows from the decay of an initial perturbation expressed as a continuous superposition of van Kampen (vK) eigenmodes over real frequencies \omega . The DF f_{\omega}(v) of the vK modes is singular at v=c and corresponds to the real eigenvalues \omega , or the phase velocity c=\omega/k , where the DF and potential perturbations are \propto\exp[-{\mathrm{i}}(kx-\omega t)] . Thus, Landau’s exponentially decaying solutions are not true modes, i.e., not self-similar perturbations, but quasi-modes. The relationship between true and Landau quasi-modes in a gravitating system was analyzed in detail in [ 23 ] . Completely neglecting collisions is an idealization that can sometimes lead to contradictions or flawed conclusions. A parallel arises in the hydrodynamics of shear flows: reducing the fourth-order viscous Orr-Sommerfeld equation to the second-order inviscid Rayleigh equation [ 24 , see, e.g.,] can lead to impasses when examining perturbations near the stability boundary. To resolve this, one must revert to a viscous approach, at least formally, because viscosity, though absent from the final formulas, is implicit in their derivation. As detailed in [ 16 ] , this situation prompted the Landau-Lin bypass rule for studies of perturbations in collisionless or inviscid systems. The question of eigenmodes in collisionless systems, such as electron plasmas or stellar systems, exemplifies situations where neglecting collisions leads to paradoxes. Specifically, the lack of DF eigenfunctions corresponding to Landau quasi-modes, and the emergence of vK modes with their singular structure, are puzzling. Although [ 26 ] , [ 5 ] , and subsequent studies on collisionless plasma and inviscid fluids [ 1 , 22 , see, e.g.,] clarified the interpretation of these singular modes, their presence in physical settings remains unsettling. Accounting for any finite, even arbitrarily small collision frequency \nu helps resolve this issue. At first glance, continuity arguments suggest that the eigenmode spectrum in a collisional medium should, as \nu\to 0 , revert to the real, singular vK spectrum. However, this expectation proves incorrect: a series of works by Ng and co-authors [ 18 , 19 , 17 , see] show that including collisions in the kinetic equation, even at \nu\to 0 , eliminates the vK modes and yields a spectrum of damped modes whose eigenfrequencies align with the Landau quasi-modes at \nu=0 . This article examines, numerically and analytically, the nature of eigenfunctions in the regime of infrequent collisions, a topic not fully explored in prior works. We aim to clarify the origin of the DF, specifically how the corrugated structure of the DF, observed in the initial collisionless problem, relates to the collision frequency when collisions are considered. We also investigate how the localization and extent of this corrugation depend on the damping rate. Following the approach of Ng and co-authors, our calculations employ a model of a homogeneous, infinite medium using the Jeans swindle. Our numerical calculations are not limited in accuracy, allowing us to approach the collisionless limit \nu=0 by reducing the collision frequency to very small values, significantly smaller than those in previous studies. Section 2 analytically calculates the eigenvalues c using perturbation theory and examines the eigenfunction structure in the limit of infrequent collisions, focusing on the physically relevant least-damped mode. Section 3 validates these results through high-accuracy numerical calculations using a matrix eigenvalue problem solution. Section 4 discusses the findings. II Analytical Expressions For very rare collisions, one can derive a correction to the collisionless (Landau) eigenvalues c=c_{\rm L} using perturbation theory with respect to the small parameter \mu , the dimensionless collision frequency. We begin, as in [ 17 ] , with a linearized system consisting of the one-dimensional Boltzmann equation, incorporating a collision term of the [ 14 ] form, \frac{\partial\,\delta f}{\partial t}+v\,\frac{\partial\,\delta f}{\partial x}-\frac{\partial\,\delta\Phi}{\partial x}\,\frac{\partial f_{0}}{\partial v}=\nu\,\frac{\partial}{\partial v}\,\Bigl(v\,\delta f+\sigma^{2}\frac{\partial\,\delta f}{\partial v}\Bigr)\,, (1) where \delta f(t,x,v) and \delta\Phi(t,x) represent perturbations of the distribution function (DF) and gravitational potential, respectively. These perturbations are related through the Poisson equation: \frac{\partial^{\,2}\delta\Phi}{\partial x^{2}}=4\pi G\int\hskip-2.0pt{\mathrm{d}}v\,\delta f\,, (2) Here, G is the gravitational constant, \nu is the collision frequency, and the unperturbed DF is assumed to be Maxwellian: f_{0}(v)=\frac{\rho_{0}}{(2\pi\sigma^{2})^{1/2}}\,\exp\Bigl(-\frac{v^{2}}{2\sigma^{2}}\Bigr)\,. (3) Considering disturbances of the form \delta f=f(v)\,{\mathrm{e}}^{{\mathrm{i}}(kx-\omega t)},\quad\delta\Phi=\phi\,{\mathrm{e}}^{{\mathrm{i}}(kx-\omega t)} (4) switching to dimensionless variables, and also using the relation -k^{2}\phi=4\pi G\int f\,{\mathrm{d}}v , we obtain: \hskip-4.0pt(u-c)\,g(u)-\eta(u)\hskip-4.0pt\int\limits_{-\infty}^{\infty}\hskip-4.0pt{\mathrm{d}}u^{\prime}g(u^{\prime})\\ =\frac{\mu}{2{\mathrm{i}}}\frac{{\mathrm{d}}}{{\mathrm{d}}u}\hskip-2.0pt\left[2ug(u)+\frac{{\mathrm{d}}g(u)}{{\mathrm{d}}u}\right]. (5) The dimensionless variables are defined as follows. The dimensionless velocity ( u ), phase velocity ( c ), and collision frequency ( \mu ) are given by: u\equiv\frac{v}{\sqrt{2}\,\sigma}\,,\quad c\equiv\frac{\omega}{\sqrt{2}k\sigma}\,,\quad\mu\equiv\frac{\nu}{\sqrt{2}k\sigma}\,. (6) The dimensionless unperturbed distribution function g_{0}(u) and its perturbation g(u) are: