The XMAGNET exascale MHD simulations of SMBH feedback in galaxy groups and clusters: Overview and preliminary cluster results
Philipp Grete, Brian W. O’Shea, Forrest W. Glines, Deovrat Prasad, Benjamin D. Wibking, Martin Fournier, Marcus Brüggen, Mark Voit · 2025
Read The XMAGNET exascale MHD simulations of SMBH feedback in galaxy groups and clusters: Overview and preliminary cluster results by Philipp Grete, Brian W. O’Shea, Forrest W. Glines, Deovrat Prasad, Benjamin D. Wibking, Martin Fournier, Marcus Brüggen, Mark Voit (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-13213.txt.
Introduction
Philipp Grete and co-authors report early results from some of the largest ever simulations of galaxy clusters with magnetic fields, in a 2025 paper. The runs model how jets from a central black hole push back against hot gas that would otherwise cool and collapse. They were computed on an exascale supercomputer with a code built for such machines.
For a cluster modeled on the real Perseus cluster, the simulated core held a steady state for billions of years, with jet power in a realistic range and no on-off cycle. Strong magnetic fields helped cold gas form and spread it in filaments far from the center. The jets also stirred turbulence tied to their activity. The project will extend the campaign across groups and clusters of many sizes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Philipp Grete, Brian W. O’Shea, Forrest W. Glines, Deovrat Prasad, Benjamin D. Wibking, Martin Fournier, Marcus Brüggen, Mark Voit |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-13213
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The XMAGNET exascale MHD simulations of SMBH feedback in galaxy groups and clusters: Overview and preliminary cluster results Philipp Grete, Brian W. O’Shea, Forrest W. Glines, Deovrat Prasad, Benjamin D. Wibking, Martin Fournier, Marcus Brüggen, Mark Voit Abstract We present initial results from extremely well-resolved 3D magnetohydrodynamical simulations of idealized galaxy clusters, conducted using the AthenaPK code on the Frontier exascale supercomputer. These simulations explore the self-regulation of galaxy groups and cool-core clusters by cold gas-triggered active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback incorporating magnetized kinetic jets. Our simulation campaign includes simulations of galaxy groups and clusters with a range of masses and intragroup and intracluster medium properties. In this paper we present results that focus on a Perseus-like cluster. We find that the simulated clusters are self-regulating, with the cluster cores staying at a roughly constant thermodynamic state and AGN jet power staying at physically reasonable values ( ≃ 10 44 − 10 45 \simeq 10^{44}-10^{45} erg/s) for billions of years without a discernible duty cycle. These simulations also produce significant amounts of cold gas, with calculations having strong magnetic fields generally both promoting cold gas formation and allowing cold gas out to much larger clustercentric radii ( ≃ 100 \simeq 100 kpc) than simulations with weak or no fields ( ≃ 10 \simeq 10 kpc), and also having more filamentary cold gas morphology. We find that AGN feedback significantly increases the strength of magnetic fields at the center of the cluster. We also find that the magnetized turbulence generated by the AGN results in turbulence where the velocity power spectra are tied to AGN activity whereas the magnetic energy spectra are much less impacted after reaching a stationary state. I Introduction The intracluster medium (ICM) – the hot, diffuse, magnetized plasma that comprises the bulk of the baryons in galaxy clusters – radiates copiously in X-ray radiation, with X-ray luminosities of massive clusters typically being in the range of \sim 10^{43.5}-10^{45.5} erg/s [ 19 ] . “Cool core” galaxy clusters, having dense and (relatively) cool cores, are particularly X-ray luminous, with central cooling times of tens to hundreds of millions of years – far shorter than the age of the universe and the lifetime of these structures [ 39 , 8 ] . In cool-core clusters, local thermal stability of the intracluster medium becomes a critical physical phenomenon that governs their evolution [ 22 ] . Cold gas is expected to precipitate out of the thermally unstable ICM [ 109 , 51 , 91 ] and to be available to star formation and accretion onto the central SMBH [ 94 , 64 , 35 ] . An apparent consequence is that the rapidly cooling gas would result in many hundreds to thousands of solar masses per year of cold, dense gas being available for star formation. This would result in brightest cluster galaxies having a very high star formation rate ( \sim several 100s M ⊙ yr -1 ), and thus it was predicted that the brightest central galaxies in clusters should see similarly high star formation rates. The observed star formation rate in these galaxies is lower, however – typically only a handful of solar masses per year [ 20 , 17 , 68 , 62 ] . This observation implies that there is a heating source in the center of every cool-core galaxy cluster that offsets this cooling, and does so in a tightly-coupled way that inhibits significant amounts of gas from forming [ 70 ] . Although several mechanisms have been proposed, including thermal conduction [ 107 , 83 ] , supernova feedback [ 108 ] , sound waves [ 82 ] , infalling galaxies and sub-halos [ 15 ] , and cluster mergers, the only mechanism that robustly fits the necessary criteria of (1) appropriate level of energy production, (2) location that would tend to deposit heat in the areas of greatest X-ray emission/cooling, and (3) ability to couple to the central cluster plasma on short time scales, is AGN feedback [ 12 , 5 , 78 , 77 , 8 , 10 , 98 ] . This idea has been supported by observational evidence from radio surveys showing that radio-loud AGN at the centers of massive cool-core galaxies are always active and, separately, analysis of cavities created by AGN jets interacting with the ICM demonstrates that the work done by those “bubbles” over time is roughly what is needed to offset cooling in clusters [ 5 , 66 , 75 , e.g.,] . These observations are supported by theory and simulations that have shown AGN feedback is crucial to the self-regulation of clusters [ 29 , 47 , 72 , 117 , 54 , 11 , 61 , 18 , e.g.,] . Idealized simulations of AGN feedback in galaxy clusters have demonstrated that cold gas-triggered AGN hosted by the central cluster galaxy are effective mechanisms for offsetting radiative losses in the intracluster medium, and (depending on the exact prescription for AGN triggering and feedback) result in clusters with thermodynamic states that are comparable to observed cool-core clusters [ 46 , 76 , 3 , 112 , 18 , 25 , e.g.,] . Furthermore, theory has shown that AGN feedback is important in environments less extreme than galaxy clusters. Cosmological simulations of galaxy formation show that AGN feedback is necessary to correctly reproduce the low star formation rates in massive galaxies [ 58 , 114 , 16 , 69 , e.g.,] as well as the budget of cold-phase gas [ 63 , e.g.,] . It is challenging to make detailed inferences from these simulations, however, because implementations of AGN feedback operate at the resolution limit of these calculations (i.e., on \sim kpc scales) and thus cannot accurately capture the interaction between the jet and the cooling, multi-phase gas. In addition, these simulations do not reproduce the morphology of the radio jets that dominate the radio sky [ 92 , e.g.,] . It is clear that there is need for a detailed examination of the impact of AGN feedback in self-regulating cool-core clusters. Multi-wavelength observations of these systems have recently shed light on the multiphase nature of the intracluster medium, showing significant complexity at relatively small spatial scales [ 86 , 53 , 101 , 63 , 106 , 30 , e.g.,] . Filament-like structures of magnetically-supported warm ionized and cold molecular gas are expected to populate the inner tens of kpc of potentially all cool–core clusters [ 81 , 63 ] , with cold molecular gas also sometimes observed in much smaller, disk-like structures [ 36 , see, e.g.,] . The measured velocity structure functions and X-ray surface brightness fluctuations also imply that the ICM is turbulent, although this turbulence is subsonic [ 48 , 27 , 13 ] . While subsonic (and thus subdominant in terms of the system’s overall pressure support), this turbulence may be quite important for promoting thermal instability and energy transfer. Highly idealized simulations using Cartesian, turbulent boxes have shown that the formation of cold structures and the coupling between gas phases is tightly coupled to turbulence driving, magnetic fields, and potentially other physical processes [ 51 , 28 , 42 , 56 , 57 , 116 ] . While these