Uncertainty Propagation for Echocardiography Clinical Metric Estimation via Contour Sampling

Thierry Judge, Olivier Bernard, Nicolas Duchateau, Woo-Jin Cho Kim, Alberto Gomez, Arian Beqiri, Agisilaos Chartsias, and Pierre-Marc Jodoin · 2025

Read Uncertainty Propagation for Echocardiography Clinical Metric Estimation via Contour Sampling by Thierry Judge, Olivier Bernard, Nicolas Duchateau, Woo-Jin Cho Kim, Alberto Gomez, Arian Beqiri, Agisilaos Chartsias, and Pierre-Marc Jodoin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-12713.txt.

Introduction

Thierry Judge and seven co-authors bring honest uncertainty to heart ultrasound measures, in a 2025 paper. Echo scans yield key numbers such as the volume of the left ventricle and the share of blood it pumps out. Automated tools compute these from outlines of the heart walls. Pixel-level doubt, though, does not translate cleanly into doubt about the final number, which is what doctors actually use.

The method predicts uncertainty in the wall outline itself, then draws many sample outlines from that range. Each sample gives its own clinical number, and the spread across samples becomes the uncertainty estimate. Clinicians can then see not just a value but its error bars. That honesty matters when a borderline number decides treatment.

Catalog record

CREATORThierry Judge, Olivier Bernard, Nicolas Duchateau, Woo-Jin Cho Kim, Alberto Gomez, Arian Beqiri, Agisilaos Chartsias, and Pierre-Marc Jodoin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-12713

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Uncertainty Propagation for Echocardiography Clinical Metric Estimation via Contour Sampling Thierry Judge, Olivier Bernard, Nicolas Duchateau, Woo-Jin Cho Kim, Alberto Gomez, Arian Beqiri, Agisilaos Chartsias, and Pierre-Marc Jodoin Abstract Echocardiography plays a fundamental role in the extraction of clinical parameters (e.g. left ventricular volume and ejection fraction) required to determine the presence and severity of heart-related conditions. When deploying automated techniques for computing these parameters, uncertainty estimation is highly valuable for assessing their utility. Since clinical parameters are usually derived from segmentation maps, there is no clear path for converting pixel-wise uncertainty values into uncertainty estimates in the downstream clinical metric calculation. In this work, we propose a novel uncertainty estimation method based on contouring rather than segmentation. Our method explicitly predicts contour location uncertainty from which contour samples can be drawn. Finally, the sampled contours can be used to propagate uncertainty to clinical metrics. Our proposed method not only provides accurate uncertainty estimations for the task of contouring but also for the downstream clinical metrics on one public and two private cardiac ultrasound datasets containing a total of 1264 patients. 1 1 1 Code will be rendered public upon acceptance of this paper. I Introduction Ultrasound imaging is the predominant modality for the assessment of cardiac function [ 1 ] . One of the primary uses of echocardiography is the extraction of clinical metrics. For example, metrics such as left-ventricular volume and ejection fraction are widely used to diagnose heart disease [ 2 ] . These metrics are measured by delineating the endocardial contours of the left ventricle at end-systole and end-diastole. The time-consuming nature of this task has stimulated interest in automatic methods. Deep learning methods have proved excellent at automating the extraction of clinical metrics from echocardiographic images [ 3 ] . Such methods can be categorized in two classes: those where the metric values are regressed directly from the input image [ 4 , 5 ] ; and those that first delineate the left ventricle and myocardium, either with a segmentation map or by contouring the endo- and epi-cardium, before computing the clinical metrics using these segmentations [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . In both cases, uncertainty estimation is of great importance in clinical practice. However, both approaches have respective shortcomings. On the one hand, uncertainty estimation of clinical metrics using regression models has been explored in [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . However, clinicians are reluctant to use non-intelligible black-box models, hindering their adoption in practice. Moreover, these models can only estimate metrics they were explicitly trained to predict. On the other hand, many works have addressed uncertainty estimation of cardiac segmentation [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] . However, to our knowledge, no work has investigated the influence of this uncertainty on the derived clinical metrics. The main contribution of this paper is a generalized framework to propagate uncertainty from input images to segmentation and to the derived clinical metrics while, at the same time, exhibiting segmentation accuracies on par with SOTA methods. Unlike conventional methods yielding pixel-wise segmentation and uncertainty maps, our contour-based approach, particularly suited to clinical settings where user interactions remain critical, predicts aleatoric uncertainty directly for points defining the left ventricle. This method, combined with shape uncertainty estimates, enables sampling plausible and temporally consistent contours and gives rise to a robust end-to-end pipeline for automatic clinical metric estimation with intelligible uncertainty. Fig. 1 : Schematic of the CASUS framework illustrating the three core components: (1) prediction of contour point uncertainty, (2) a contour sampling mechanism, and (3) propagation of sampled contour uncertainties to compute clinical metrics. II Related Work II-A Echocardiographic Segmentation Deep neural networks trained on publicly available datasets such as CAMUS [ 8 ] and EchoNet-Dynamic [ 15 ] have reached a performance within inter-user variability, typically using architectures based on U-Net [ 16 ] . Since then, many different strategies such as echocardiography-specific data augmentation [ 17 ] and pyramid attention networks [ 18 ] have improved U-Net results. The recent publication of nnU-Net has significantly enhanced segmentation outcomes across various tasks [ 19 ] and, when applied to the CAMUS dataset, outperformed all prior methods [ 20 ] . Other work has addressed key-point localization [ 21 , 22 ] with dedicated approaches for cardiac [ 23 ] and lung [ 24 ] segmentation being proposed. This formulation reduces anatomical implausibilities and is more similar to clinical tools where keypoints are used to define contours in commercial software such as EchoPac by GE Healthcare 2 2 2 https://www.gehealthcare.com/products/ultrasound/vivid/echopac , which includes semi-automatic and manual delineation tools. Regardless of the segmentation technique, a key objective following segmentation is the derivation of clinical metrics. A standard metric in echocardiography is the left ventricular area. A more accurate evaluation of the ventricular cavity size involves determining the ventricular volume using Simpson’s biplane method [ 25 ] , utilizing the segmentation obtained from the apical 4-chamber (A4C) and apical 2-chamber (A2C) views. Additionally, temporal metrics are of significant interest. Examining the ratio of heart size between end-systole (ES) and end-diastole (ED) can provide indications of certain cardiac pathologies. The fractional area change (FAC) is defined as the difference between the end-diastolic area and the end-systolic area, divided by the end-diastolic area. Ejection fraction (EF) is calculated similarly, albeit with volume measurements. II-B Uncertainty Estimation Although numerous studies have proposed new models to enhance the segmentation accuracy, relatively few have addressed the predictive uncertainty of these models. Accounting for uncertainty is crucial, as although neural networks can achieve human-level performance, they can also make occasional critical errors. Uncertainty is usually classified into two categories: aleatoric and epistemic [ 26 ] . Aleatoric uncertainty is the uncertainty present within the data itself. In medical imaging, aleatoric uncertainty is caused by the inherent ambiguity of images, which for instance, can occur due to noisy images or labels. Epistemic uncertainty is the uncertainty associated with the model and is caused by the limited size of the training dataset. While epistemic uncertainty can be reduced by acquiring more data, aleatoric uncertainty is irreducible. One prominent approach for modeling epistemic uncertainty involves characterizing the distribution of model weights, \theta , conditioned on the data \mathcal{D} . This posterior distribution over weights, p(\theta|\mathcal{D}) , is generally intractable to compute analytically for neural networks. Variational inference offers a method to approximate the true posterior using a variational distribution, q_{w}(\theta) , in Bayesian neural networks [ 27 ] . However, this approach necessitates significant modifications to standard training procedures. Alternative methods, such as Monte-Carlo (MC) dropout, have demonstrated effectiveness as a practical approximation for Bayesian neural networks, allowing for uncertainty estimation without altering the training pipeline, and have achieved reliable results [ 28 , 29 ] . On the other hand, a frequentist approach with ensemble methods leverages the variability of independently trained networks—each trained on different data subsets or with distinct hyperparameters—to capture uncertainty [ 30 ] . While epistemic uncertainty methods usually do not require any data assumptions, this is not the case for aleatoric uncertainty methods. Most commonly, probabilistic approaches that model a parameterized distribution p_{\theta}(y|x) over the output y given the input x are employed in aleatoric uncertainty methods. For

Read the complete text