FIP Bias Evolution in an Emerging Active Region as observed in SPICE Synoptic Observations
T. Varesano, D. M. Hassler, N. Zambrana Prado, J. M. Laming, J. Plowman, D. J. Knipp, M. Molnar, K. Barczynski, The SPICE consortium · 2025
Read FIP Bias Evolution in an Emerging Active Region as observed in SPICE Synoptic Observations by T. Varesano, D. M. Hassler, N. Zambrana Prado, J. M. Laming, J. Plowman, D. J. Knipp, M. Molnar, K. Barczynski, The SPICE consortium (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-12045.txt.
Introduction
Varesano and co-authors, working with the SPICE consortium, watch the chemistry of a young active region on the Sun change over two days. Their 2025 paper studies the first ionization potential effect, a sorting that enriches some elements in the corona over others. The team used a spectrograph aboard Solar Orbiter that reads light from the upper chromosphere up to the low corona.
From those spectra they built maps of relative abundances for elements of low, middle, and high ionization potential, structure by structure. A model driven by a ponderomotive force, the push of waves on plasma, matched the maps well, pointing to Alfvén waves as the sorting agent. Fan loops, loop footpoints, and the region's edges showed coronal-style makeup, while the core stayed closer to the surface mix. One ratio climbed slowly and steadily, rising about half again over two days.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | T. Varesano, D. M. Hassler, N. Zambrana Prado, J. M. Laming, J. Plowman, D. J. Knipp, M. Molnar, K. Barczynski, The SPICE consortium |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-12045
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
FIP Bias Evolution in an Emerging Active Region as observed in SPICE Synoptic Observations T. Varesano, D. M. Hassler, N. Zambrana Prado, J. M. Laming, J. Plowman, D. J. Knipp, M. Molnar, K. Barczynski, The SPICE consortium Abstract Aims. We investigate the time evolution of relative elemental abundances in the context of the first ionization potential effect focusing on an active region. Our aim is to characterize this evolution in different types of solar active region structures as well as in different atmospheric layers. We wish to assess how the measured changes relate to different magnetic topologies by computing abundance enhancement in different conditions using the ponderomotive force model. Methods. Leveraging SPICE (Spectral Imaging of the Coronal Environment) spectroscopic observations of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lines from ions formed across a broad temperature range—from the upper chromosphere to the low corona—, we perform relative abundance ratios following differential emission measure analysis. This methodology yields abundance maps from low, intermediate, and high first ionization potential elements. Results. We obtain the temporal evolution of a number of abundance ratios for different structures on the Sun. We compare these results with the outcomes of the ponderomotive force model. We find good correlation between the model and our results, suggesting an Alfvén-wave driven fractionation of the plasma. Fan loops, loop footpoints and AR boundaries exhibit coronal abundances, while the AR core shows more photospheric-like composition. A slow and steady increase in the Mg/Ne FIP bias values is observed, starting around 1.5 and increasing by about 50% after two days. The S/O evolution coupled with the model brings evidence of resonant waves fractionating the plasma in transition region structures. 1 Introduction The growing number of Solar science missions in the last two decades has enabled solar physicists to address a great number of unresolved questions regarding plasma dynamics and mechanisms in the solar atmosphere. Solar Orbiter (SolO), the joint ESA and NASA solar and heliospheric mission, was launched in February 2020 ( Müller et al., 2020 ) . Using the onboard SPICE (Spectral Imaging of the Coronal Environment) instrument, we focus on the first ionization potential (FIP) as one of the discriminating factors when it comes to elemental abundance variations. One way to characterize these compositional variations is through the “FIP effect” ( Meyer, 1985 ; Meyer, 1991 ) , whereby elements with a low first ionization potential (FIP) are enhanced in abundance within certain coronal structures relative to high-FIP elements. This "FIP effect" is characterized as the ratio between an element’s coronal and photospheric abundances (for element X , noted Ab_{X}^{\text{coronal}} and Ab_{X}^{\text{photospheric}} ): \centering FIP_{bias}=\frac{Ab_{X}^{\text{coronal}}}{Ab_{X}^{\text{photospheric}}}\@add@centering (1) Because it is challenging to determine the absolute abundance of elements relative to hydrogen in the upper solar atmosphere, we instead rely on relative abundances. We compare the ratios of radiances between spectral lines from different elements to study their composition. Several studies have investigated the dependency on this ratio, the ‘FIP bias’, on the type of solar region, magnetic flux, and solar cycle, and increasing interest has been given to its temporal evolution (see Section 1.2). However, few studies have examined how the FIP bias evolves over time specifically within the transition region or across multiple atmospheric layers — a focus that distinguishes the present work ( Widing & Feldman, 2001 ; Baker et al., 2015 ) . Sheeley (1995) , Widing (1997) , Young & Mason (1997) , and Widing & Feldman (2001) found photospheric plasma composition in newly emerged loops, indicating that flux emergence provides a potential reservoir of low-FIP bias plasma to mix with the high-FIP bias plasma contained within AR coronal loops. Understanding the mechanisms by which this material enters coronal loops of the AR and the timescales over which plasma mixing occurs, therefore the evolution of the FIP bias, is crucial to investigate the link between the underlying magnetic field and the coronal plasma ( Baker et al., 2015 ) . Earlier investigations of the FIP effect have mainly focused on the corona ( Baker et al., 2018 ; Mihailescu et al., 2022 ; Baker et al., 2022 ; Mihailescu et al., 2023 ) . In contrast, studies treating the Sun as an unresolved source found little to no evidence of FIP fractionation at transition region temperatures ( Laming et al., 1995 ) , and spatially resolved measurements at those temperatures revealed FIP-related signatures only in select structures ( Sheeley, 1995 ; Widing & Feldman, 2001 ) . With Solar Orbiter’s improved spatial resolution and its closer approach to the Sun, exploring FIP fractionation in the transition region now becomes especially compelling. As mentioned in Baker et al. (2015) and references therein, the current thinking suggests that emerging closed loops start with a photospheric composition, which then transitions to a coronal one in the following days. However, the time scales and exact mechanisms for this transformation are not fully understood. Widing & Feldman (2001) used the Skylab spectroheliograph to investigate the Mg VI/Ne VI ratio. Their work concluded that the FIP bias increased shortly after AR emergence ( \Delta t<1 day) to reach coronal values after a few days ( \Delta t>2/3 days), and a correlation between the sunspot growth and increasing in FIP bias has also been established. It is thought that emerging loops of photospheric composition reconnect with older structures (i.e. preexisting loops, formed before the flux emergence and exhibiting higher FIP bias), lead to fractionated plasma being brought up to the corona, most likely through interchange reconnection.The time scale and mechanisms of this mixing is thought to be in the order of days ( Baker et al., 2015 ; Widing & Feldman, 2001 ) . The aim of this project is to investigate the variability of FIP bias during the emergence phase of an active region, leveraging the unique opportunity provided by the SPROUTS (Synoptic PRogram of Out of RemoTe Sensing observations) to continuously monitor the Sun. The focus will be on the FIP bias evolution over time, across different structural features, and through various layers of the solar atmosphere specifically within the temperature range of \log_{10}\frac{T}{1\,\text{K}} =4.8 to 6.0. These changes in elemental abundances are then compared with predictions made by the ponderomotive force model. 1.1 Fractionation mechanisms The ponderomotive force (see Laming (2015) ; Laming et al. (2019) ) provides the most widely adopted explanation of the FIP effect and also the inverse FIP effect (an enhancement in the abundance of high FIP elements). It posits that Alfvén waves generated either in the corona or coming up from the photosphere travel to chromospheric heights where they encounter strong density gradients and thus are refracted and reflected. That change in direction leads to the "ponderomotive force". This force separates the ions from the neutrals – the ions traveling towards areas of high wave electric energy density, leading to the observed FIP effect. The newly fractionated plasma is then brought upwards by thermal and diffusion processes. For closed loops, the best match with observations comes with waves that are resonant. Alfvén waves propagate along magnetic field lines and can undergo resonance in the chromosphere, where their frequencies match natural oscillation modes of magnetic flux tubes. At resonance, the wave energy is efficiently converted into localized ponderomotive forces acting on