When Adiabaticity Is Not Enough to Study Topological Phases in Solid-State Physics: Comparing the Berry and Aharonov-Anandan Phases in 2D Materials
Abdiel de Jesús Espinosa-Champo a,c , Alejandro Kunold b and Gerardo G. Naumis d · 2025
Read When Adiabaticity Is Not Enough to Study Topological Phases in Solid-State Physics: Comparing the Berry and Aharonov-Anandan Phases in 2D Materials by Abdiel de Jesús Espinosa-Champo a,c , Alejandro Kunold b and Gerardo G. Naumis d (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-11875.txt.
Introduction
Three physicists in Mexico compared two geometric phases for studying topological states in flat materials in a 2025 paper. The classic Berry phase assumes change so slow that a system stays in its band. In gapless materials like graphene that assumption often fails outright, yet the phase is still computed as if it held.
The team turned to a phase that needs no slow-change assumption. They proved it links directly to electric current, with light-driven band jumps producing current vortices. Graphene under radiation, worked through a time-driven formalism, showed the two phases giving matching yet distinct insights. Topology, band jumps, and currents can be read together. The authors urge care when the slow limit is quietly assumed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abdiel de Jesús Espinosa-Champo a,c , Alejandro Kunold b and Gerardo G. Naumis d |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-11875
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When Adiabaticity Is Not Enough to Study Topological Phases in Solid-State Physics: Comparing the Berry and Aharonov-Anandan Phases in 2D Materials Abdiel de Jesús Espinosa-Champo a,c , Alejandro Kunold b and Gerardo G. Naumis d Abstract Topological phases emerge as the parameters of a quantum system vary with time. Under the adiabatic approximation, the time dependence can be eliminated, allowing the Berry topological phase to be obtained from a closed trajectory in parameter space. In solid-state physics, this approach is commonly applied by taking a reciprocal space wavevector as the parameter, which is assumed to be varied by electromagnetic fields. The Berry curvature is then obtained by computing the derivatives of Bloch wavefunctions in reciprocal space. However, in many systems—especially gapless ones—the adiabatic approximation is never satisfied. This is particularly true in Dirac and Weyl materials, where the Berry curvature is often calculated without considering the breakdown of the adiabatic condition. In this work, we demonstrate how other time-dependent topological quantities, specifically the Aharonov-Anandan phase, can be used to extract information not only about topology but also about band transitions in 2D materials. In particular, a relationship between the current and the Aharonov-Anandan phase is proved, showing that photon-induced transitions produce current vortices. To illustrate this, we analyze graphene under electromagnetic radiation from a time-driven perspective, showing how the Aharonov-Anandan and Berry phases provide complementary insights into topology, interband transitions, and currents. This is achieved by using the Dirac-Bloch formalism and by solving the time-dependent equations within Floquet theory. I Introduction Beyond electronic properties, the study of quantum geometry and topology in solid-state physics—especially in two-dimensional (2D) materials—has emerged as a pivotal area of research [ 1 ] . Quantum geometry, characterized by parameters such as the Berry curvature and quantum metric, plays a crucial role in understanding various physical phenomena, including the anomalous Hall effect and topological insulators [ 2 ] . Topology, on the other hand, concerns the global properties of the material’s electronic wavefunctions, leading to robust edge states and exotic phases of matter [ 3 ] . In solid-state physics, topology is usually studied considering the reciprocal space properties of the Hamiltonian and its corresponding wave functions [ 4 ] . However, it is often forgotten that this procedure is valid whenever the parameters of the Hamiltonian are varied adiabatically in time in such a way that there are no transitions to other states. This requires driving the system with a frequency smaller than the gap size measured in frequency units. It turns out that in many cases the adiabatic condition does not hold as we will discuss here [ 5 ] . In fact, many 2D materials fall into this category. Among these, graphene and borophene stand out. Graphene has been widely celebrated for its exceptional conductivity and mechanical strength [ 6 ] , and borophene for its remarkable flexibility and electronic characteristics [ 7 ] . Although numerous studies explore the topological properties of these 2D materials, it is often overlooked that many lack a band gap, and thus, the adiabaticity condition is never truly met. Some researchers gap the system’s spectrum by breaking a symmetry, yet this does not answer what the required size of the gap should be or whether this process changes the nature of the topology. Since the adiabaticity condition does not hold, the alternative is to focus on the time-dependent origin of topological phases, as done in Thouless’s pioneering work on topology [ 8 ] . Fortunately, in other areas of physics, different dynamic approaches have been developed to identify topological properties [ 9 , 10 ] . The aim of the present work is to compare the information provided by the Aharonov-Anandan phase with the Berry phase in the context of solid-state band topology. The advantage is that the Aharonov-Anandan phase does not require adiabaticity [ 10 ] . As we shall see, in many instances, the Aharonov-Anandan and Berry phases are radically different and encode distinct physical aspects of the electronic properties of 2D materials. Until recently, the consensus was that the Berry and Aharonov-Anandan phases coincide in the adiabatic limit [ 11 , 12 ] . However, it was recently discovered that degeneracy can cause them to differ [ 10 ] . Our work aligns with this perspective. In solid-state physics, degeneracy and gapless systems are common, necessitating a careful examination of the equivalence between topological phases. The understanding of such time-dependent aspects opens new avenues in material science and condensed matter, as it allows us to manipulate the properties of these materials through external stimuli [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] . One such method is time-driving, which consists in the temporal modulation of a material’s properties using external fields. This technique not only facilitates the exploration of new phases of matter but also offers a platform for the dynamic control of electronic and topological features [ 16 , 17 ] . The application of electromagnetic fields to 2D materials offers a powerful means to alter their quantum geometry and topology. By tuning the frequency, amplitude, and polarization of the applied fields, researchers can induce significant modifications in the band structure and topological properties of the material [ 7 ] . For instance, it is possible to induce topological phase transitions, where the material’s topological invariants change, leading to new states of matter with distinct edge modes and transport properties [ 18 ] . These field-induced modifications not only enhance the fundamental understanding of 2D materials but also pave the way for novel applications in electronic and optoelectronic devices [ 3 ] . The ability to dynamically control the properties of 2D materials through time-driving and electromagnetic fields has far-reaching implications for technology [ 19 ] . Potential applications include the development of high-speed, low-power electronic devices and advanced sensors [ 19 , 20 ] . The tunability provided by these techniques allows the design of materials with tailored properties, optimized for specific applications [ 2 ] . For example, the induction of topological states can lead to devices with robust edge conduction, immune to scattering and defects, which is highly desirable for reliable electronic and spintronics applications [ 21 ] . Time-driving in 2D materials typically involves the application of periodic external fields, such as electromagnetic or acoustical waves, which induce a time-dependent perturbation in the system [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . The response of these materials to this driving can be effectively studied using the Floquet theory [ 18 , 22 , 26 ] . Floquet theory extends the concept of Bloch’s theorem to time-periodic systems, allowing the analysis of the system’s behavior in terms of quasi-energy states known as Floquet states. These states provide a comprehensive understanding of the material’s dynamic response, enabling the identification of novel phenomena such as Floquet-Bloch bands and time-crystalline states [ 21 , 27 ] . In summary, in this article we provide an alternative path, based on Floquet theory, to obtain topological phases for solid-state systems that are gapless. As a result, we relate non-adiabatic topological phases with electronic transitions and currents induced by the applied electromagnetic field. To do so, we will compare and explore the Berry and Aharonov-Anandan