A purely analytic derivation of Bonnet surfaces

Robert Conte, Alfred Michel Grundland · 2025

Read A purely analytic derivation of Bonnet surfaces by Robert Conte, Alfred Michel Grundland (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-11815.txt.

Introduction

Robert Conte and Michel Grundland spell out Bonnet surfaces by purely analytic settings in a two thousand twenty-five math paper. Bonnet at first spelled out these surfaces through a geometric setting on their curvature.

The new account swaps geometry for two needs on the mean curvature. First, the mean curvature of a surface in three-dimensional space should reduce to an usual differential equation. Second, that equation should possess the Painlevé property, meaning its solutions have no movable key singular points. Together the settings single out exactly the Bonnet surfaces. The paper offers analysts a differential-equations route into a classic topic of surface theory.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert Conte, Alfred Michel Grundland
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE13 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-11815

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A purely analytic derivation of Bonnet surfaces Robert Conte, Alfred Michel Grundland Abstract Bonnet has characterized his surfaces by a geometric condition. What is done here is a characterization of the same surfaces by two analytic conditions: (i) the mean curvature H H of a surface in ℝ 3 \mathbb{R}^{3} should admit a reduction to an ordinary differential equation; (ii) this latter equation should possess the Painlevé property. Journal: Journal of geometry and physics PACS 02.30.Hq, 02.30.Jr, 02.30.+g MSC 33E17, 34Mxx, 35A20, 35Q99 TO ELSEVIER. An error in the style file elsarticle.cls prevents your macro affiliation to accept accented characters in words like Université, Mathématiques, Québec …PLEASE CORRECT. In order to overcome this error, these words have been erroneously written without their accents. See our macros \Universite etc. 1 Introduction Surfaces immersed in the three-dimensional simply connected manifold \mathbb{M}^{3}(c) with constant sectional curvature \kappa c^{2} , where \mathbb{M}^{3}(c) is the sphere \mathbb{S}^{3}(c^{2}) when \kappa=1 , the Euclidean space \mathbb{R}^{3} when \kappa=0 and the hyperbolic space \mathbb{H}^{3}(c^{2}) when \kappa=-1 , are described by a set of partial differential equations (PDE) known as the Gauss-Codazzi equations 1 1 1 The additional parameter c arises when one replaces the Euclidean space \mathbb{R}^{3} by the three-dimensional manifold \mathbb{M}^{3}(c) described in the text. \displaystyle\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\displaystyle{\upsilon_{z{\bar{z}}}+\frac{1}{2}(H^{2}-c^{2})e^{\upsilon}-2|Q|^{2}e^{-\upsilon}=0\hbox{ (Gauss)},}\\ \displaystyle{Q_{\bar{z}}-\frac{1}{2}H_{z}e^{\upsilon}=0,\overline{Q}_{z}-\frac{1}{2}H_{\bar{z}}e^{\upsilon}=0\hbox{ (Codazzi)},}\end{array}\right. in which z,{\bar{z}} are conformal coordinates, e^{\upsilon}\hbox{d}z\hbox{d}{\bar{z}} the induced metric on the surface, H the mean curvature ( \upsilon and H being both real), and Q the complex coefficient of the Hopf differential. By determining all surfaces in \mathbb{R}^{3} applicable on a given surface while conserving the two principal radii of curvature, the geometer Pierre-Ossian Bonnet [ 3 ] isolated a remarkable class of analytic surfaces, now called Bonnet surfaces, characterized by the third order ordinary differential equation (ODE) [ 3 , Eq. (52) p. 84] [ 6 , Eq. (B16)] \displaystyle{\hskip-45.5244pt}(\log h^{\prime})^{\prime\prime}+2h^{\prime}-2\left(\frac{4a}{\sinh 4a(\xi-\xi_{0})}\right)^{2}\left(\frac{h^{\prime}+h^{2}-c^{2}}{h^{\prime}}\right)=0,\ ^{\prime}=\frac{\hbox{d}}{\hbox{d}\xi}, (4) in which the mean curvature H is a function of one variable only, denoted \xi , H(z,{\bar{z}})=h(\xi) , with \xi=\Re(z) , and a^{2} is an arbitrary real constant. Their metric \upsilon and the coefficient Q are given by (see details in [ 5 , 6 ] ) \displaystyle{\hskip-73.97716pt}\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\displaystyle{Q=2a\coth 2a(z-z_{0})-2a\coth 4a\Re(z-z_{0})=\frac{\sinh 2a({\bar{z}}-{\bar{z}}_{0})}{\sinh 2a(z-z_{0})}\frac{2a}{\sinh 4a\Re(z-z_{0})},\ }\\ \displaystyle{\overline{Q}=2a\coth 2a({\bar{z}}-{\bar{z}}_{0})-2a\coth 4a\Re(z-z_{0})=\frac{\sinh 2a(z-z_{0})}{\sinh 2a({\bar{z}}-{\bar{z}}_{0})}\frac{2a}{\sinh 4a\Re(z-z_{0})},}\\ \displaystyle{|Q|^{2}=\left(\frac{2a}{\sinh 4a\Re(z-z_{0})}\right)^{2},}\\ \displaystyle{e^{\upsilon}=4|Q|^{2}\frac{\hbox{d}\Re(z)}{\hbox{d}H}.}\end{array}\right. The general solution [ 1 ] of the ODE ( 4 ), which admits the first integral ( [ 9 , p. 48] for c=0 , [ 2 ] for arbitrary c ) \displaystyle{\hskip-42.67912pt}K=\left(\frac{h^{\prime\prime}}{h^{\prime}}+8a\coth 4a(\xi-\xi_{0})\right)^{2} \displaystyle{\hskip-42.67912pt}\phantom{1234}+8\left[\left(\frac{4a}{\sinh 4a(\xi-\xi_{0})}\right)^{2}\frac{h^{2}-c^{2}}{h^{\prime}}+h^{\prime}+8a\coth 4a(\xi-\xi_{0})h\right], (10) is the logarithmic derivative of the tau-function of either (when a\not=0 ) a sixth Painlevé equation {\rm P_{\rm VI}} of codimension two, or (when a\to 0 ) a fifth Painlevé equation {\rm P_{\rm V}} of codimension three. {\rm P_{\rm VI}} was only to be discovered in 1905 [ 8 ] from purely mathematical considerations, but in fact it already occured in a natural problem of geometry thirty-eight years earlier, this is why Bonnet surfaces are so important. What we perform here a straightforward derivation of the third order ODE ( 4 ), which is based purely on analysis, and not on geometry like that of Bonnet. 2 The method The mean curvature is an important geometric quantity for a surface in a three-dimensional manifold, therefore let us make the first assumption that this mean curvature H depends on one variable denoted \xi=\varphi(z,{\bar{z}}) instead of two ( z and {\bar{z}} ), \displaystyle H(z,{\bar{z}})=h(\xi),\qquad\xi=\varphi(z,{\bar{z}}), (11) and let us then determine the function \varphi(z,{\bar{z}}) and the ODE for h(\xi) . Let us eliminate \upsilon and H between the three equations ( 1 ) 1 , ( 1 ) 2 , ( 11 ) in order to obtain an equation for h(\xi) whose coefficients depend only on Q,\overline{Q},\varphi and their derivatives. The field \upsilon is first determined from the first Codazzi equation ( 1 ) 2 , then substituted in the two remaining Gauss-Codazzi equations ( 1 ). After replacement of the field H defined by ( 11 ), the second Codazzi equation becomes \displaystyle Q_{z}\varphi_{z}-Q_{\bar{z}}\varphi_{\bar{z}}=0, (12) and the Gauss equation is now \displaystyle{\hskip-17.07164pt}\left\{\begin{array}[]{ll}\displaystyle{(\log h^{\prime})^{\prime\prime}+F_{1}h^{\prime}+F_{2}\frac{h^{\prime\prime}}{h^{\prime}}+F_{3}\frac{h^{2}-c^{2}}{h^{\prime}}+F_{4}=0,}\\ \displaystyle{F_{1}=\frac{Q\overline{Q}}{Q_{\bar{z}}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}\raise 2.0pt\hbox{,}\ F_{2}=\frac{\varphi_{z{\bar{z}}}}{\varphi_{z}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}\raise 2.0pt\hbox{,}\ F_{3}=\frac{Q_{\bar{z}}}{\varphi_{z}^{2}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}\raise 2.0pt\hbox{,}\ }\\ \\ \displaystyle{F_{4}=\frac{Q_{{\bar{z}}}Q_{{\bar{z}}{\bar{z}}}Q_{z{\bar{z}}}}{\varphi_{z}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}-\frac{Q_{z{\bar{z}}{\bar{z}}}}{Q_{\bar{z}}\varphi_{z}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}-\frac{\varphi_{z{\bar{z}}}\varphi_{zz}}{\varphi_{z}^{3}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}+\frac{\varphi_{zz{\bar{z}}}}{\varphi_{z}^{2}\varphi_{\bar{z}}}\cdot}\end{array}\right. According to our assumption ( 11 ), equation ( 2 ) 1 should be an ODE for h(\xi) , i.e. its coefficients should only depend on \xi . Let us now make a second assumption, namely that this ODE should possess the Painlevé property [ 7 ] , i.e. its general solution should have no movable critical singularities. This double requirement will determine all coefficients F_{j} (except F_{1} , which will remain arbitrary) in terms of \xi . Once the F_{j}(\xi) ’s are known, the last four equations in ( 2 ) will determine the functions Q(z,{\bar{z}}),\overline{Q}(z,{\bar{z}}),\varphi(z,{\bar{z}}) . 2.1 Painlevé test For the technical vocabulary, we refer the reader to Ref. [ 4 , p. 160] [ 7 , Chap. 2] . A necessary condition for the absence of movable critical singularities is that ( 2 ) pass the Painlevé test. Since h^{(3)}(\xi) in ( 2 ) is singular at h^{\prime}=0 , the Painlevé test mainly consists in checking the existence of all Laurent series of both h(\xi) and 1/h^{\prime}(\xi) able to locally represent the general solution. Near a movable singularity \chi(\xi)=0 , since Q is nonzero, the field h has only one family of movable simple poles, \displaystyle h\sim\frac{2}{F_{1}}\chi^{-1},\chi\to 0,\chi^{\prime}=1, (18) and the Fuchs indices of this family are -1,1,2 . The existence of a Laurent series of h near this singularity requires that two conditions must be obeyed at the positive Fuchs indices, \displaystyle Q_{1}\equiv F_{1}F_{2}+F_{1}^{\prime}=0,\qquad Q_{2}\equiv F_{1}F_{2}^{2}+2F_{3}-F_{1}F_{4}+F_{1}F_{2}^{\prime}=0. (19) They determine F_{2} and F_{3} and restrict the ODE ( 2 ) 1 to \displaystyle\begin{array}[]{ll}\displaystyle{(\log h^{\prime})^{\prime\prime}+F_{1}h^{\prime}+\frac{F_{4}h^{\prime}+(F_{1}/2)^{3}G_{4}(h^{2}-c^{2})-(\log F_{1})^{\prime}h^{\prime\prime}}{h^{\prime}}=0,}\end{array} with the notation \displaystyle G_{4}=(2/F_{1})^{2}\left[F_{4}+(\log F_{1})^{\prime\prime}-{(\log F_{1})^{\prime}}^{2}\right]. (22) Next, let us build the ODE for 1/h^{\prime}=g(\xi) . After the substitution h^{\prime}=1/g(\xi) in ( 2.1 ) and its derivative, the elimination of h(\xi) generates a third order ODE for g(\xi) , whose degree in the third derivative is two. Its Gauss decomposition then reads, \displaystyle(gS^{\prime})^{2}-4S=0,S=\frac{8}{F_{1}^{3}G_{4}}\left[\frac{(\log g)^{\prime\prime}}{g}-\frac{F_{1}^{\prime}g^{\prime}}{g^{3}}-\frac{F_{4}}{g}-\frac{F_{1}}{g^{2}}\right]+c^{2}=h^{2}. (23) It has one family of movable double poles with an arbitrary leading coefficient, \displaystyle g\sim g_{0}(\xi)\chi^{-2},\chi\to 0,\chi^{\prime}=1. (24) Its Fuchs indices are -1,0,2 , and the index 2 generates a necessary condition on G_{4},F_{1} for the Laurent series to exist, \displaystyle Q_{2}\equiv\left[\left(\frac{2G_{4}^{\prime}}{F_{1}G_{4}}\right)^{2}+2G_{4}\right]^{\prime}=0, (25) thus defining the value of G_{4} \displaystyle G_{4}=2(4a)^{2}\left[1-\coth^{2}\left(4a\int(F_{1}(\xi)/2)\hbox{d}\xi\right)\right],a\hbox{ arbitrary constant}. (26) After substitution of this value ( 26 ) in ( 2.1 ), the change of independent variable \xi\to\int(F_{1}(\xi)/2)\hbox{d}\xi performs the identification of the ODE ( 2.1 ) to the ODE ( 10 ) for the mean curvature of the Bonnet surfaces. Therefore, the unique ODE resulting from the two above mentioned assumptions is the ODE characterizing the Bonnet surfaces. 2.2 Determination of the variables \varphi,Q,\overline{Q},\upsilon Given the values F_{j}(\xi) obtained in section 2.1 , let us now determine the reduced variable \xi=\varphi(z,{\bar{z}}) , the Hopf coefficients Q(z,{\bar{z}}),\overline{Q}(z,{\bar{z}}) and the metric function \upsilon(z,{\bar{z}}) by integrating the last four equations in ( 2 ) and the remaining Gauss-Codazzi equations ( 1 ). Of course, by the results of Bonnet, one knows that the expressions ( 1 ) together with \varphi=(z+{\bar{z}})/2 are indeed a solution of ( 2 ) 2:5 , therefore the question is to prove the unicity of this solution. Without loss of

Read the complete text