Comparison of Offset and Ratio Weighted Regressions in Tweedie Models with Application to Mid-Term Cancellations
Jean-Philippe Boucher & Raïssa Coulibaly · 2025
Read Comparison of Offset and Ratio Weighted Regressions in Tweedie Models with Application to Mid-Term Cancellations by Jean-Philippe Boucher & Raïssa Coulibaly (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-11788.txt.
Introduction
Jean-Philippe Boucher and Raïssa Coulibaly compare two ways to fit insurance models in twenty twenty-five. In car insurance, risk is usually taken to grow in proportion to how long cover lasts. That idea leads to two standard tricks. The ratio approach divides the response by exposure. The offset approach adds a fixed term based on exposure into the model's mean.
Both rest on the same assumption, but they diverge for Tweedie models, a common frame in insurance work. The authors show each approach can be run on its own. Both give a consistent estimate of the true mean. They then show the offset approach is more efficient in the long run. The test case is mid-term policy cancellations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jean-Philippe Boucher & Raïssa Coulibaly |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 95 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-11788
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparison of Offset and Ratio Weighted Regressions in Tweedie Models with Application to Mid-Term Cancellations Jean-Philippe Boucher & Raïssa Coulibaly Abstract In property and casualty insurance, particularly in automobile insurance, risk exposure is commonly assumed to be proportional to the duration of coverage. This assumption leads to two standard estimation strategies: the ratio approach, which normalizes the response variable (e.g., claim cost or premium) by the exposure, and the offset approach, which incorporates a transformation of the exposure—typically its logarithm—as a fixed regressor in the mean structure of the model. Although both approaches rely on the same proportionality assumption, they are not equivalent when the response variable follows a Tweedie distribution, a framework widely used in insurance analytics. In this paper, we show that each approach can be implemented independently and yields a consistent estimator of the true mean parameter vector. We then show that the offset approach is asymptotically more efficient than the ratio approach, a result established both theoretically and through simulation studies. However, when evaluated from the perspective of portfolio-level financial balance, the ratio approach exhibits superior performance, particularly in the presence of heterogeneous or truncated exposures arising from mid-term policy cancellations. These theoretical results are illustrated through an empirical analysis of an automobile insurance portfolio with a high cancellation rate, highlighting the practical implications of model choice for premium estimation under variable exposure conditions. A Preprint August 24, 2026 K eywords Tweedie distribution, weighted regression, offset variable, policy cancellation, positive definite matrix 1 Introduction In insurance, particularly within the property and casualty sector like automobile insurance, risk exposure has traditionally been associated with the duration of coverage (see Denuit et al. (2007) ). Risk exposure refers to the extent to which an insured entity is subject to potential claims or losses over the policy period. For example, under a linear interpretation of exposure, a one-year policy would be considered twice as risky as a six-month policy, assuming identical characteristics for the insured. This concept is central to many actuarial research projects and practical applications. Given its importance, it becomes essential to develop a comprehensive framework for incorporating various dimensions of risk exposure into the modelling of random variables used for ratemaking. Such models ensure that the premiums charged accurately reflect the underlying risks. More formally, we are interested in modelling the random variable Y_{i} , representing either the total number of claims or the total claims amount (also referred to as the loss cost) for contracts i=1,\dots,n , where n denotes the total number of contracts in the portfolio. Assuming that the expected value corresponds to the premium (as discussed in Denuit et al. (2007) and Frees et al. (2014) ), the premium can be expressed as: \mathrm{E}\!\left[Y_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}}\right]=g^{-1}\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}\right), (1.1) where \bm{\beta} is a parameter vector to be estimated, and \mathbf{X_{i}}=(x_{i,0},\dots,x_{i,q})^{\top} represents the vector of risk characteristics associated with contract i (with q being a positive integer). These risk characteristics—such as age, sex, and the value of the insured goods—are used as covariates in the regression model, allowing the premium to vary based on these factors. The function g(\cdot) serves as a link function that connects the score \mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta} to the expected value, similar to the approach in Generalized Linear Models (GLMs) (see Nelder and Wedderburn (1972) ). An analysis of historical motor insurance data reveals significant variability in exposure periods among insured individuals. This variation often occurs when coverage is cancelled before the contract ends due to reasons such as the sale or replacement of a vehicle, theft, or a total loss resulting from an accident. For modelling purposes, insurers typically treat the exposure period as a fraction of the total number of days in a year. This fraction, referred to as risk exposure and denoted by t , is a positive value between 0 and 1, reflecting the proportion of the year that the contract was active. Formally, we consider a portfolio of n insured contracts, indexed by i , some of which have a risk exposure, denoted by t_{i} , that is less than 1. To account for this variation in exposure when calculating premiums and estimating model parameters, it is necessary to generalize Equation ( 1.1 ). This paper examines two approaches within the maximum likelihood estimation framework to address this generalization: 1. The first approach assumes that the exposure t_{i} is proportional to the mean of the conditional distribution Y_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}} , where f_{Y_{i}}(\cdot) represents the density or probability mass function of Y_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}} , and y_{i} denotes the observed loss cost for contract i . Under this assumption, the log-likelihood function for estimating the parameter vector \bm{\beta} is expressed as: \ell(\bm{\beta}|y_{1},\ldots,y_{n})=\sum_{i=1}^{n}\log\left(f_{Y_{i}}(y_{i})\right), where the mean of Y_{i} being linearly proportional to t_{i} , such that: \mathrm{E}\!\left[Y_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}}\right]=g^{-1}\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}\right)\times t_{i}. In this framework, g(\cdot) is typically chosen as a logarithmic link function, resulting in: \exp\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}\right)t_{i}=\exp\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}+\log(t_{i})\right), where \log(t_{i}) acts as an offset variable. This method is thus referred to as the offset approach . 2. The second approach, referred to as ratio approach , focuses on annualizing the random variable Y_{i} to facilitate direct comparisons of policyholders’ claims on an annual basis. In this method, a new random variable Z_{i}=\frac{Y_{i}}{t_{i}} is defined for each contract i=1,\dots,n , resulting a normalized set of claim amounts z_{1},\dots,z_{n} . To distinguish it from the offset approach, the mean of Z_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}} is assumed to no longer depend on t_{i} , and the density or probability mass function of Z_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}} incorporates the risk exposure through this weighting. The log-likelihood function for estimating \bm{\beta} is expressed as: \ell(\bm{\beta}|z_{1},\ldots,z_{n})=\sum_{i=1}^{n}t_{i}\log\left(f_{Z_{i}}(z_{i})\right), where f_{Z_{i}}(\cdot) is the density or probability mass function of Z_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}} , and the mean is given by: \mathrm{E}\!\left[Z_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}}\right]=g^{-1}\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}\right), where g(\cdot) a logarithmic link, the expected loss cost for an insured i exposed to risk over a period of t_{i} years is then expressed: \mathrm{E}\!\left[Y_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}}\right]=\mathrm{E}\!\left[t_{i}Z_{i}|\mathbf{X_{i}}\right]=\exp\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}\right)\times t_{i}=\exp\left(\mathbf{X}_{i}^{\top}\bm{\beta}+\log(t_{i})\right), which has the same form as the expected loss cost from the offset approach. It is important to emphasize that in the offset approach, the random variable Z_{i} can be used to estimate the parameter vector \bm{\beta} , but this method should not be confused with the ratio approach. Similarly, in the ratio approach, the random variable Y_{i} can also be used, but this method should not ne mistaken for the offset approach. We refer to the offset approach when risk exposure is only incorporated into premium modelling as an offset variable. Conversely, we refer to the ratio approach when risk exposure is only included as a weight in the premium modelling process. These two approaches represent distinct methods for integrating risk exposure, ensuring that premiums are appropriately aligned with the insured’s actual level of risk. 1.1 Examples for claim counts To clarify the issue, we can illustrate the situation with a preliminary comparison of the two approaches, assuming that Y_{i} represents the number of claims for insured i . Example 1 . Under the ratio approach, we assume that Z_{i},i=1,\ldots,n follows a Poisson distribution with mean \zeta_{i}=\exp(\mathbf{X}^{\top}_{i}\bm{\beta}) . In this framework, it can be shown that the ratio approach corresponds to a Poisson weighted regression and yields the same inference results of the parameter vector \bm{\beta} as in the offset approach, where Y_{i},i=1,\ldots,n is Poisson distributed with mean \mu_{i}=t_{i}\exp(\mathbf{X}^{\top}_{i}\bm{\beta})=\exp(\mathbf{X}^{\top}_{i}\bm{\beta}+\log(t_{i})) . Proof. The log-likelihood function of the offset and ratio