Gravitational lensing and accretion disk imaging of a Buchdahl dense core
Takahisa Igata , Motoki Omamiuda, Yohsuke Takamori · 2025
Read Gravitational lensing and accretion disk imaging of a Buchdahl dense core by Takahisa Igata , Motoki Omamiuda, Yohsuke Takamori (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-11755.txt.
Introduction
Three physicists in Japan study how light bends around a dense core that is almost, but not quite, a black hole, in a 2025 paper. The core follows a model named for Buchdahl, with no central singularity. The team maps the range in which such a core can copy a black hole's pull while still acting in its own way. They trace how light paths curve near the core.
The authors also build the picture an observer would see of a thin glowing disk around the core. For looser cores, only a few disk images form, and the extra images often show as double loops. Past a set level of tightness, an endless stack of loops appears, tied to a shell where light can orbit. These odd image shapes could let future sharp telescopes tell a dense core from a true black hole.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Takahisa Igata , Motoki Omamiuda, Yohsuke Takamori |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-11755
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational lensing and accretion disk imaging of a Buchdahl dense core Takahisa Igata , Motoki Omamiuda, Yohsuke Takamori Abstract In this paper, we investigate the gravitational lensing and accretion disk imaging characteristics of a dense core modeled by the Buchdahl spacetime. By imposing the appropriate energy conditions and ensuring the absence of curvature singularities, we delineate the parameter space in which the dense core mimics key gravitational features of black holes while exhibiting unique deviations. We derive the photon orbital equation and calculate deflection angles, clearly distinguishing between weak- and strong-deflection regimes. Furthermore, we construct a mapping from the illuminated, geometrically thin accretion disk onto the observer’s screen—focusing on the isoradial curves corresponding to a representative source ring. For compactness values below a critical threshold, only a finite number of disk images are formed. In this range, their secondary and higher-order images typically display double-loop structures, with each loop individually capturing the entire source ring. Notably, the highest-order image sometimes appears as a single, crescent-shaped loop that does not enclose the screen’s center, implying the existence of a cutoff angle that restricts the imaged portion of the source ring. In contrast, for compactness values above the critical threshold, an infinite sequence of double-loop structures appears—a behavior closely linked to the presence of a photon sphere. These findings suggest that the lensing signatures of dense cores can distinguish them from black holes, offering new insights for high-resolution observations. I Introduction Over the past decade, remarkable advances in observational astronomy have significantly deepened our understanding of the compact objects at the centers of galaxies, providing new insights into their gravitational effects. Among these objects are M87* and Sagittarius A*, which are widely regarded as supermassive black hole candidates and have attracted considerable attention from theoretical and observational perspectives. The groundbreaking imaging of these objects by the Event Horizon Telescope EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp provided compelling evidence in support of the existence of a black hole, or at least an object with black-hole-like properties. The sharp boundaries of the observed shadows likely arise from both the strong bending of light near the photon sphere and the potential absorption near the Schwarzschild radius, each of which is indicative of an intense gravitational field consistent with black hole predictions. Nevertheless, confirming the existence of a black hole and its event horizon is essentially impossible, as the event horizon represents a boundary from which neither light nor matter can escape Hawking:1973uf , rendering direct observational verification unattainable Abramowicz:2002vt ; Nakao:2018knn . Thus, while the observed shadows align well with black hole models, they neither conclusively prove the presence of a horizon nor rule out the possibility of alternative objects. This fundamental limitation—the inability to definitively confirm the existence of an event horizon—has motivated extensive research into horizonless compact objects Cardoso:2017cqb , including naked singularities, wormholes, boson stars, gravastars, and dense cores. These objects exhibit strong gravitational fields comparable to those of black holes, but could, in principle, allow the direct observation of their interiors or surfaces. Observationally, one promising approach is to look for small yet significant deviations by comparing the photon ring and shadow features predicted by standard black hole models with those observed in data. If such discrepancies are found, they would substantially strengthen the possibility that the central object is an alternative to a black hole, thereby broadening our understanding of supermassive objects at galactic centers. Theoretically, it is critical to develop and refine alternative models that quantitatively predict such observational signatures. Systematic comparisons between these predictions and high-precision data could determine whether alternative objects mimic all black hole observables or reveal detectable differences. Even if no observational test can definitively rule out the standard black hole model, continued efforts in model building and data analysis promise invaluable insights into the nature of compact objects at galactic centers. Consequently, determining whether a genuinely alternative configuration can replicate every black hole signature—or reveal measurable deviations—remains an open and compelling question. In this context, upcoming developments in very-long-baseline interferometry (e.g., Ref. Lupsasca:2024xhq ) will further refine angular resolution, offering new opportunities to test such scenarios and explore possible deviations from the Kerr metric Cardoso:2019rvt . Given these considerations, imaging of accretion disks plays a central role in understanding the gravitational environments surrounding compact objects and serves as a powerful tool for distinguishing between competing theoretical models. Early studies Cunningham:1973 ; Luminet:1979 ; Fukue:1988 ; Takahashi:2004xh demonstrated how the gravitational field of a black hole strongly bends light emitted by an accretion flow, producing observable features such as distorted disk images and photon rings. More recent studies have explored thin accretion disk images around black holes in various contexts Tsupko:2022kwi ; Liu:2021lvk ; Guo:2023zwy ; Gyulchev:2021dvt ; Zhu:2024vxw . Meanwhile, researchers have investigated the optical appearance of a thin accretion disk surrounding a black hole alternative, including naked singularities Gyulchev:2019tvk ; Gyulchev:2020cvo ; Guerrero:2022msp , wormholes Paul:2019trt ; Rahaman:2021kge , boson stars Rosa:2023qcv , and gravastars Rosa:2024bqv , revealing how the underlying geometry can imprint distinctive observational signatures. Collectively, these studies underscore the power of disk imaging to uncover subtle yet critical differences between standard black holes and potential alternatives. Among the many alternatives proposed, dense cores have garnered particular attention because they can remain extremely compact—reproducing the key gravitational effects of black holes—while maintaining a smooth and physically consistent matter distribution. Recent studies on the core-halo distribution of dark matter suggest that dense cores may account for the environments in galactic centers Ruffini:2014zfa ; Arguelles:2016ihf , and relativistic effects such as periapsis shifts in dense core models have been analyzed Rubilar:2001 ; Igata:2022nkt . Moreover, distinct features in photon ring structures or luminosity profiles arising from a dense core’s internal mass distribution could distinguish it from a black hole. For instance, some numerical analyses of dark matter cores illuminated by accretion disks report central brightness depressions without clear photon rings, highlighting key distinctions from black hole scenarios Pelle:2024eyt . Despite this growing interest, systematic studies of optically thin accretion disks around dense cores, employing analytically tractable models, remain limited. Dense core solutions vary widely in their matter distributions and underlying assumptions, and purely numerical models may obscure important physical insights. Building on prior developments, this paper aims to provide new perspectives on the gravitational lensing and observational signatures of dense cores by adopting a simpler perfect-fluid solution. This approach clarifies how the compactness and mass distribution of a dense core shape its associated lensing effects and disk images, thereby highlighting potential observational signals that could differentiate dense cores from black holes. Such signals may be investigated in future high-resolution observations, offering deeper insights into the nature of these compact objects. In particular, this study focuses on dense cores modeled by the Buchdahl solution, a static and spherically symmetric perfect-fluid configuration Buchdahl:1964 . The Buchdahl solution serves as a relativistic extension of the Newtonian Plummer model, providing a useful bridge between Newtonian gravity and strong gravity regimes. Unlike naked singularities, this solution describes a regular spacetime that is both highly compact and free of singularities. Furthermore, whereas many alternative black hole models invoke exotic matter fields, the Buchdahl solution relies on a classical perfect fluid that satisfies standard energy conditions. This combination of regularity and physical