Hadron Identification Prospects With Granular Calorimeters

Andrea De Vita, Abhishek, Max Aehle \orcidI, Muhammad Awais, Alessandro Breccia \orcidP, Riccardo Carroccio \orcidG, Long Chen \orcidT, Tommaso Dorigo, Nicolas R. Gauger \orcidJ, Ralf Keidel \orcidQ, Jan Kieseler \orcidL, Enrico Lupi, Federico Nardi \orcidN, Xuan Tung Nguyen \orcidH, Fredrik Sandin, · 2025

Read Hadron Identification Prospects With Granular Calorimeters by Andrea De Vita, Abhishek, Max Aehle \orcidI, Muhammad Awais, Alessandro Breccia \orcidP, Riccardo Carroccio \orcidG, Long Chen \orcidT, Tommaso Dorigo, Nicolas R. Gauger \orcidJ, Ralf Keidel \orcidQ, Jan Kieseler \orcidL, Enrico Lupi, Federico Nardi \orcidN, Xuan Tung Nguyen \orcidH, Fredrik Sandin, (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-10817.txt.

Introduction

A team of particle physicists studied how well a granular calorimeter can tell hadrons apart in this 2025 paper. A calorimeter measures the energy of particles that crash into dense matter. The pattern of that energy, plus the timing of each hit, carries clues to which particle made it.

The team simulated a lead tungstate calorimeter with fine slicing across and along the beam, using the GEANT4 toolkit. They asked how well it could separate protons, positive pions, and positive kaons at 100 GeV of energy. Detector cells were merged step by step to test how much detail matters. Two machine learning methods, XGBoost and deep neural networks, did the sorting. The work guides the design of future detectors where fine grain may pay off in particle naming.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrea De Vita, Abhishek, Max Aehle \orcidI, Muhammad Awais, Alessandro Breccia \orcidP, Riccardo Carroccio \orcidG, Long Chen \orcidT, Tommaso Dorigo, Nicolas R. Gauger \orcidJ, Ralf Keidel \orcidQ, Jan Kieseler \orcidL, Enrico Lupi, Federico Nardi \orcidN, Xuan Tung Nguyen \orcidH, Fredrik Sandin,
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-10817

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hadron Identification Prospects With Granular Calorimeters Andrea De Vita, Abhishek, Max Aehle \orcidI, Muhammad Awais, Alessandro Breccia \orcidP, Riccardo Carroccio \orcidG, Long Chen \orcidT, Tommaso Dorigo, Nicolas R. Gauger \orcidJ, Ralf Keidel \orcidQ, Jan Kieseler \orcidL, Enrico Lupi, Federico Nardi \orcidN, Xuan Tung Nguyen \orcidH, Fredrik Sandin, Kylian Schmidt \orcidM, Pietro Vischia \orcidK, Joseph Willmore \orcidO Abstract In this work we consider the problem of determining the identity of hadrons at high energies based on the topology of their energy depositions in dense matter, along with the time of the interactions. Using GEANT4 simulations of a homogeneous lead tungstate calorimeter with high transverse and longitudinal segmentation, we investigated the discrimination of protons, positive pions, and positive kaons at 100 GeV. The analysis focuses on the impact of calorimeter granularity by progressively merging detector cells and extracting features like energy deposition patterns and timing information. Two machine learning approaches, XGBoost and fully connected deep neural networks, were employed to assess the classification performance across particle pairs. The results indicate that fine segmentation improves particle discrimination, with higher granularity yielding more detailed characterization of energy showers. Additionally, the results highlight the importance of shower radius, energy fractions, and timing variables in distinguishing particle types. The XGBoost model demonstrated computational efficiency and interpretability advantages over deep learning for tabular data structures, while achieving similar classification performance. This motivates further work required to combine high- and low-level feature analysis, e.g. , using convolutional and graph-based neural networks, and extending the study to a broader range of particle energies and types. keywords particle detectors, calorimetry, particle identification, physics, machine learning † † firstpage: 1 † † volume: 1 † † issue: 1 † † articlenumber: 0 † † year: 2024 † † copyright-year: 2024 † † hreflink: https://doi.org/ † † titlecitation: Hadron Identification Prospects With Granular Calorimeters † † authornames: Andrea de Vita, Abhishek, Muhammad Awais, Alessandro Breccia, Riccardo Carroccio, Long Chen, Tommaso Dorigo, Nicolas R. Gauger, Ralf Keidel, Jan Kieseler, Enrico Lupi, Federico Nardi, Xuan Tung Nguyen, Fredrik Sandin, Kylian Schmidt, Pietro Vischia, and Joseph Willmore † † authorcitation: De Vita, A.; Abhishek; Aehle, M; Awais, M.; Breccia, A.; Carroccio, R.; Chen, L; Dorigo, T.; Gauger, N.R.; Keidel, R.; Kieseler, J.; Lupi, E.; Nardi, F.; Nguyen, X.T.; Sandin, F.; Schmidt, K.; Vischia, P.; Willmore, J. † † address: 1 INFN, sezione di Padova - Via F. Marzolo 8, 35131 Padova, Italy 2 Università di Padova, dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Via F. Marzolo 8, 35131 Padova, Italy 3 National Institute of Science Education and Research, Jatni, 752050, India 4 Luleå University of Technology, 971 87 Luleå, Sweden 5 Universal Scientific Education and Research Network, Italy 6 University of Kaiserslautern-Landau (RPTU), Gottlieb-Daimler-Straße, 67663 Kaiserslautern, Germany 7 Universidad de Oviedo and ICTEA, Spain 8 Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany 9 Laboratoire de Physique Clermont Auvergne, 63170 Aubière, France 10 MODE Collaboration, https://mode-collaboration.github.io ∗ Corresponding author: [email protected] † † reftitle: References 1 Introduction For thirty or more years until the end of the last century, the purpose of hadron calorimeters instrumenting detectors for particle colliders has been invariably the one of determining with the highest possible precision the collective energy of hadronic jets. Although already in the late 1980s a few studies had shown promising results in the improvement of jet energy measurement through the analysis of the interactions of individual particles within the jet cone and the use of momentum information for charged particles provided by tracker measurements Wing (2000) , a fine segmentation of the calorimeter did not appear sufficiently motivated to be worth the added cost and data volume overhead. Then, after the turn of the century, two separate advancements in data analysis dramatically changed that paradigm: the demonstration of boosted jet tagging on one side Qu and Gouskos (2020) ; Dreyer and Qu (2020) ; The ATLAS Collaboration (2023) ; Kasieczka (2018) , and the success of particle flow techniques on the other The CMS Collaboration (2017) ; Thomson (2009) . The contrast could not be starker. The estimate of the total energy deposited by a stream of hadrons does not require a calorimeter to be built with high longitudinal or transverse segmentation: other attributes, such as passive material, total depth in interaction lengths, hermeticity, and detection materials and sensors are the main drivers of performance. Instead, the identification of sub-jet components produced within fat jets by the decay of high-mass boosted particles such as W , Z , and H bosons and top quarks, as well as the detailed accounting of energy deposited by charged and neutral particles within a jet performed by particle flow algorithms, both require high granularity of detection elements within the calorimeter volume. If we consider broadly the problem of optimally designing a calorimeter for a future collider application, the two recent motivations of high segmentation mentioned above should be considered with care, as the cost of construction and independent readout of a large number of cells can be very high. However, a third element in this equation may then need to be considered, because a high longitudinal and transverse segmentation, coupled with accurate timing of the harvested signals and with precise tracking of charged particles entering the detector, may enable the identification of the particle species producing the energy deposits in localized portions of the detector, through the use of machine learning techniques. The discrimination of protons, charged pions, and charged kaons through the topology and timing of their energy depositions in a hadron calorimeter is very difficult, and there is a dearth of studies of this topic in the literature; we only know the CALICE attempt in 2015 Bilki et al. (2015) . However, the general push toward high granularity of today’s and tomorrow’s hadron calorimeters requires a careful assessment of the ultimate particle identification performance of these instruments. Kaon tagging, for example, may enable the identification of leading kaons in strange quark jets, opening the way to studies of Higgs channels such as H\to s\bar{s} decays; separation of the three dominant charged hadrons also improves the particle flow performance. In this work we consider the above problem from a rather abstract standpoint: our goal is to try and assess what may be the ultimate discrimination power of a hadron calorimeter for protons, pions, and kaons, if the detector is built with arbitrarily high segmentation; in addition, we aim to assess how that information gets lost if the cell size is progressively increased. This way signal features that are particularly relevant to consider in order to balance the discrimination power versus data readout rate and computational demands can also be investigated (see, e.g. , feature sampling in Ref. Verhelst and Bahai (2015) ). A quantitative answer to these questions may be very important in informing the design of instruments for future collider applications. This article is organized as follows: in Sec. 2 we describe the Monte Carlo simulations we produced as a basis of our studies. In Sec. 3 we describe the construction of useful high-level features extracted from energy and time determinations in calorimeter cells. In Sec. 4 we describe the metrics used to evaluate the performance and the models we used to assess what discrimination is possible with the use of those

Read the complete text