Robust Pricing of Equity-Indexed Annuities under Uncertain Volatility and Stochastic Interest Rate

Ludovic Goudenege, Andrea Molent, Antonino Zanette · 2025

Read Robust Pricing of Equity-Indexed Annuities under Uncertain Volatility and Stochastic Interest Rate by Ludovic Goudenege, Andrea Molent, Antonino Zanette (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-10300.txt.

Introduction

Ludovic Goudenège, Andrea Molent, and Antonino Zanette priced a tricky insurance product in two thousand twenty-five: equity-indexed annuities with step-up payoffs and early exit risk. Their market model lets volatility stay uncertain, while interest rates follow a standard random model. That mix makes exact pricing formulas out of reach.

They built a tree-based computing method that tracks both the rate and the index, with local volatility tuning. Tests show it works well, matching a machine learning rival. The tool also maps where holders should exit early for the best value. Insurers can use it to price such contracts with more confidence.

Catalog record

CREATORLudovic Goudenege, Andrea Molent, Antonino Zanette
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE104 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-10300

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Robust Pricing of Equity-Indexed Annuities under Uncertain Volatility and Stochastic Interest Rate Ludovic Goudenege, Andrea Molent, Antonino Zanette Abstract Abstract In this paper, we propose a novel methodology for pricing equity-indexed annuities featuring cliquet-style payoff structures and early surrender risk, using advanced financial modeling techniques. Specifically, the market is modeled by an equity index that follows an uncertain volatility framework, while the dynamics of the interest rate are captured by the Hull-White model. Due to the inherent complexity of the market dynamics under consideration, we develop a numerical algorithm that employs a tree-based framework to discretize both the interest rate and the underlying equity index, enhanced with local volatility optimization. The proposed algorithm is compared with a machine learning-based algorithm. Extensive numerical experiments demonstrate its high effectiveness. Furthermore, the numerical framework is employed to analyze key features of the insurance contract, including the delineation of the optimal exercise region when early surrender risk is incorporated. Keywords : Equity-indexed Annuities; Uncertain Volatility Model; Stochastic interest Rate; Tree Method; Machine Learning. 1 Introduction Equity-linked annuities (ELAs) are significant contracts in the insurance market, offering interest credits and benefit payouts linked to the performance of one or more equity indices, such as the S&P 500. Among these, equity-indexed annuities (EIAs) stand out for their unique combination of features: they guarantee a minimum rate of return while also allowing policyholders to benefit from additional earnings tied to the performance of the associated indices. These instruments provide a compelling blend of market-linked growth potential and downside protection. The guaranteed minimum interest rate ensures that policyholders retain a baseline value for their investment, even in unfavorable market conditions. This combination of security and growth potential has driven the popularity of EIAs, particularly among individuals focused on retirement planning, who seek a prudent balance between risk and reward. The payoffs of the most common EIA contracts follow a cliquet-style structure, meaning they are determined through a series of periodic resets, with gains secured at each reset point. Such a feature is also known as ratchet, symbolizing the mechanism by which the accrued value can only move upward or remain fixed, never decreasing. In the early studies on this topic, EIAs were priced under the assumption that the underlying equity index follows a geometric Brownian motion with a constant interest rate, in line with standard financial modeling approaches, as discussed by Gerber and Shiu [ 8 ] and Hardy [ 12 ] . However, given the typically long maturities of EIAs, it is more appropriate to price these contracts under a stochastic interest rate model rather than relying on a constant rate. The Vasicek model has been one of the first stochastic interest rate framework applied to EIA pricing. Specifically, Sheldon and Tan [ 23 ] use Monte Carlo simulations to derive prices for various types of EIAs within the Vasicek framework. Building on this, Kijima and Wong [ 19 ] develop a closed-form pricing formula for ratchet EIAs with geometric index averaging under the extended Vasicek model. They also introduce an efficient Monte Carlo simulation algorithm for pricing EIAs with arithmetic index averaging. Furthermore, as highlighted by Kijima and Wong [ 19 ] , the EIA pricing literature has largely overlooked early surrender risk. Moreover, they identified addressing this oversight as a compelling and open problem in the field. To this aim, Wei et al. [ 27 ] focus on improving the pricing of EIAs, particularly those with ratchet features, minimum contract values and early surrender options. Later, some authors have focused on describing the dynamics of the underlying by considering stochastic volatility models and jump-diffusion models. In this regard, Windcliff et al. [ 11 ] examine several numerical methods and volatility models for valuing cliquet options, and they focus on the impacts of different volatility assumptions, such as local volatility surfaces, jump-diffusion models, and uncertain volatility models. More recently, Hieber [ 15 ] introduces a regime-switching Lévy model to value equity-linked life insurance contracts with annual cliquet-style return guarantees and incorporates macroeconomic regime changes via a Markov chain. Cui et al. [ 6 ] develop an efficient method for pricing ELAs with cliquet-style guarantees using advanced models such as regime-switching Lévy processes and stochastic volatility models with jumps. Hess [ 14 ] addresses the pricing of cliquet options within a jump-diffusion Lévy framework. In this model, the underlying stock price process incorporates both Brownian motion and compound Poisson jumps, capturing rare market events such as crashes or sudden upward movements. It is widely recognized that cliquet options exhibit significant sensitivity to unpredictable future changes in the volatility skew, as discussed by Windcliff et al. [ 11 ] , among others. Relying on constant or local volatility models, such as Dupire’s framework, can result in substantial mispricing, necessitating more sophisticated approaches to volatility modeling. Stochastic volatility models like Heston or Hull-White, as well as hybrid jump-diffusion models, typically involve a challenging and sometimes unreliable calibration process. Furthermore, the effectiveness of delta hedging strategies within these models is often unclear, as noted by Hess [ 14 ] . Unlike many other exotic derivatives, the valuation of a cliquet option is particularly dependent on the choice of model used to calibrate against vanilla option prices and a careful modeling for volatility is particularly important for these products because of the non convex nature of their payoff function. Given these complexities, several experts in applied mathematical finance, such as Wilmott [ 28 ] , Windcliff et al. [ 11 ] , Hénaff and Martini [ 13 ] , have advocated for the use of the Uncertain Volatility Model (UVM), which provides a robust framework for both pricing and evaluating the volatility risk associated with structured products containing embedded cliquet options. Specifically, the UVM, introduced by Avellaneda et al. [ 1 ] , bounds the volatility of the underlying within predefined limits. Such a model ensures robust pricing even under significant market uncertainty, making it highly applicable for exotic options and derivatives that are sensitive to volatility fluctuations. Recently, researchers have increasingly explored the integration of the UVM with stochastic interest rate frameworks in the valuation of financial derivative instruments. The combination of these two models allows for a robust management of market uncertainties by addressing the dual complexities of random volatility and the fluctuating dynamics of interest rates. This synergy is particularly effective when traditional stochastic processes struggle to fully capture the variability in market conditions. The UVM, by keeping volatility within specified bounds, enables robust pricing strategies even in the presence of considerable market uncertainty. This makes it particularly effective for exotic options and derivatives with high sensitivity to volatility dynamics. Meanwhile, stochastic interest rate models, such as those based on Hull-White or CIR (Cox-Ingersoll-Ross) processes, provide a realistic representation of interest rate movements, which are crucial for accurate pricing in fixed-income markets or derivatives tied to rate-sensitive assets. For instance, the integration of these models has been particularly useful in pricing cliquet options and equity-linked products, where path dependency and market conditions introduce additional layers of complexity. In this regard, Hölzermann [ 16 , 17 ] examines the classical Hull-White model for interest rate term structures while incorporating volatility uncertainty, and proposes a new approach to pricing zero-coupon

Read the complete text