Profinite Rigidity over Noetherian Domains
Julian Wykowski · 2025
Read Profinite Rigidity over Noetherian Domains by Julian Wykowski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-10278.txt.
Introduction
Julian Wykowski wrote a 2025 math paper that opens the study of profinite rigidity for modules. The question is how far a module over a Noetherian domain is fixed by its finite images alone. Group theory has classic results of this kind, and Wykowski builds the module parallel.
He sets out three profinite invariants for modules over any such domain. Free modules prove rigid when the domain meets a homology condition. Over a Dedekind domain he maps the full genus of each module, and over a principal ideal domain all finitely generated modules prove rigid. As a use, he proves a family of solvable Baumslag-Solitar groups is rigid in the absolute sense, a first for its kind.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Julian Wykowski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-10278
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Profinite Rigidity over Noetherian Domains Julian Wykowski Abstract . We initiate the study of profinite rigidity for modules over a Noetherian domain: to what extent are these objects determined by their finite images? We establish foundational statements in analogy to classical results in the category of groups. We describe three profinite invariants of modules over any Noetherian domain Λ \Lambda . Most notably, we show that being projective is a profinite invariant of Λ \Lambda -modules. We demonstrate absolute profinite rigidity for free modules assuming that Λ \Lambda satisfies a homological condition, and for all modules when Λ \Lambda is a PID. As an application, we prove that torsion-free lamplighter groups and solvable Baumslag–Solitar groups are profinitely rigid in the absolute sense. The latter class includes the first known examples of non-abelian one-relator groups and non-LERF groups which are profinitely rigid in the absolute sense. 1. Introduction Can the entirety of an infinite object be seen in its finite shadows? This question, known as profinite rigidity , is a major theme in the study of certain mathematical theories. Most prominently, group theory studies to what extent properties of a finitely generated group \Gamma may be detected in the collection of its finite quotients. This is equivalent to asking to what extent properties of \Gamma are encoded in its profinite completion \widehat{\Gamma} , the latter being a topological group constructed as the inverse limit of the finite quotients of \Gamma . The central problem of this enterprise is absolute profinite rigidity , that is, the question whether the isomorphism type of the profinite completion \widehat{\Gamma} determines the isomorphism type of \Gamma completely. Despite considerable research on the subject (see [ 27 ] or [ 7 ] for a survey), this question remains vastly unanswered, the difficulty lying in the necessity to consider all finitely generated groups \Delta as possible counterexamples. In fact, the problem of absolute profinite rigidity for free groups is a notorious open problem known as Remeslennikov’s question [ 21 ] . To the author’s knowledge, the only currently known examples of absolute profinite rigidity are: the classical examples of abelian and certain polycyclic groups [ 23 , 24 , 16 ] , lamplighter groups whose base has prime exponent [ 4 ] , and, thanks to a recent breakthrough, certain arithmetic lattices in \operatorname{PSL}(2,\mathbb{C}) and \operatorname{PSL}(2,\mathbb{R}) , see [ 9 , 10 , 8 ] . The latter class are the only known examples of full-sized groups which are profinitely rigid in the absolute sense. See also [ 7 ] for a survey of known counterexamples. Absolute profinite rigidity contrasts with the weaker question of relative profinite rigidity , where one attempts to distinguish isomorphism classes of groups in a certain class (usually of geometric significance) via their profinite completions only from other members of the given class. Notably, the geometric structure of 3-manifolds has allowed for some beautiful results on the distinction of such spaces from one another via the profinite completions of their fundamental groups [ 35 , 36 , 33 , 34 , 18 , 17 ] . However, little has been done to study profinite rigidity in different algebraic categories, such as categories of \Lambda -modules 1 1 1 The only mention known to the author is [ 25 ] , where modules with equal collections of finite epimorphic images were briefly considered for the construction of counterexamples to profinite rigidity in the class of finitely generated metabelian groups. We invite the reader to compare this result with the metabelian groups proven profinitely rigid in Theorem D below. over rings \Lambda other than \mathbb{Z} . The present article aims to initiate research of the latter. Given a ring \Lambda and a \Lambda -module M , the profinite completion M in the category of \Lambda -modules is the topological \Lambda -module \widehat{M} given by the inverse limit of the finite \Lambda -epimorphic images of M (see Section 2 for details). We shall restrict ourselves to the study of residually finite \Lambda -modules—that is, modules M such that the canonical map \iota\colon M\to\widehat{M} is an injection—for otherwise any profinite property of a module factors though its maximal residually finite quotient. We aim to investigate under what circumstances the following definition is satisfied. Definition 1.1 . Let \Lambda be a commutative ring. A finitely generated residually finite \Lambda -module M is \Lambda -profinitely rigid in the absolute sense if the equivalence \widehat{M}\cong\widehat{N}\Longleftrightarrow M\cong N holds for any finitely generated residually finite \Lambda -module N . Similarly, We shall say that a property, quantity or a functor \mathcal{P}(-) of \Lambda -modules is a \Lambda -profinite invariant if the implication \widehat{M}\cong\widehat{N}\Longrightarrow\mathcal{P}(M)=\mathcal{P}(N) holds whenever M,N are finitely generated residually finite \Lambda -modules. The main focus of the present article shall be the establishment of various \Lambda -profinite invariants and \Lambda -profinite rigidity for certain modules over a Noetherian domain \Lambda . We shall assume that \Lambda finitely generated as a \mathbb{Z} -algebra; in that setting, all finitely generated modules turn out to be residually finite (see Lemma 2.1 ), so we need not concern ourselves with the latter restriction. Nonetheless, the diversity in the possible structure of modules over Noetherian domains endows the question of profinite rigidity in these categories with great complexity and consequence. We dedicate Section 3 to the study of such \Lambda -profinite invariants in maximal generality, culminating in the following result. Theorem A . Let \Lambda be a finitely generated Noetherian domain and M,N be finitely generated \Lambda -modules with \widehat{M}\cong\widehat{N} . Then: (1) The annihilators of M and N in \Lambda agree: \operatorname{Ann}_{\Lambda}(M)=\operatorname{Ann}_{\Lambda}(N) . (2) For any maximal ideal \mathfrak{I} , the minimal number of generators of the localisations M_{\mathfrak{I}} and N_{\mathfrak{I}} as \Lambda_{\mathfrak{I}} -modules agree: \mu_{\mathfrak{I}}(M)=\mu_{\mathfrak{I}}(N) . (3) The \Lambda -module M is projective of rank \nu\in\mathbb{N} if and only if the \Lambda -module N is projective of rank \nu . We say that a commutative ring \Lambda is homologically taut if finitely generated projective modules are free. In that case, Theorem A yields the following corollary, the salient profinite rigidity result of the present article. Corollary B . Let \Lambda be a homologically taut finitely generated Noetherian domain. Finitely generated free \Lambda -modules are \Lambda -profinitely rigid in the absolute sense. In particular, the class of homologically taut domains contains the class of principal ideal domains (PIDs), where the notions of torsion-free, projective and free coincide for finitely generated modules. One then obtains a definitive structure theorem, the strength of which can be leveraged to demonstrate the absolute profinite rigidity for all finitely generated modules. This yields the following result, whose proof is independent of the above results and presented in Section 4 . Theorem C . Let \Lambda be a finitely generated principal ideal domain. Any finitely generated \Lambda -module is \Lambda -profinitely rigid in the absolute sense. Finally, we exhibit applications of the theory of profinite rigidity over Noetherian domains to the profinite rigidity of groups. The key observation is that finitely generated residually finite group \Gamma which admits an epimorphism \Gamma\twoheadrightarrow\mathbb{Z}^{n} with (possibly infinitely generated) abelian kernel M , we may equip the kernel M canonically with the structure of a module over the Noetherian domain \Lambda=\mathbb{Z}[x_{1}^{\pm},\ldots,x_{n}^{\pm}] . Under certain