On alleged solutions of the cubically nonlinear Schrödinger equation

Hans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov · 2025

Read On alleged solutions of the cubically nonlinear Schrödinger equation by Hans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-10234.txt.

Introduction

Schürmann and Serov showed in twenty twenty-five, with math and one worked case, that a wide-used guess form clashes with a known wave equation with a cube term. Such clash means the guess can-not be a true solve of that equation. The case gives a clear check for like claims in print.

Catalog record

CREATORHans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE11 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-10234

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On alleged solutions of the cubically nonlinear Schrödinger equation Hans Werner Schürmann, Valery Serov Abstract On the basis of analytical results, we present a numerical example that indicates inconsistency of a widely used ansatz with cubically nonlinear Schrödinger equation. I Introduction As is well-known, the cubically nonlinear Schrödinger equation (CNLSE) (see Eq.(1a) below) is an appropriate model to study a great variety of physical settings in, e.g., nonlinear optics AkhA , hydrodynamics Z , and plasma physics H . Due to this variety, the actual meaning of the independent variables x,t and of parameters p and q is different for different problems. As an integrable differential equation, the CNLSE possesses an infinite set of conservation laws and can be solved by general techniques (e.g., IST, Darboux transformation). In general, it is not easy to derive practical solutions for certain physically relevant problems using these general techniques. Thus, special ansatz (trial) solutions have been suggested. In the present article we consider one of them, originally presented in AEK and reconsidered in C . With reference to AEK , in a recent article, we have claimed inconsistency of this ansatz Se . Since a modification of AEK has been proposed in C , the cause of the present article is to check whether this modification is leading to a correction of our claim in Se . – We think that it is important to know whether this wide used ansatz Footnote is suitable as a solution of the CNLSE. After stating the problem in Section II, we transform, in Section III, the basic system \{(6a),(6b)\} (see below) to a dynamical system, that is suitable for the final consistency check in Section V. In Section IV we present solutions for d(t) and Q(x,t) (see Eq.(1b) below), necessary for use in Section V. We conclude with some comments in Section VI. II Statement of the problem We consider the basic system considered in C \displaystyle iA_{t}(x,t)+pA_{xx}(x,t)+qA(x,t)|A(x,t)|^{2}=0, (1a) \displaystyle A(x,t)=(Q(x,t)+id(t)e^{i\phi(t)}, (1b) where x,t,p,q,Q,d,\phi are real and d_{t}(t)\neq 0,Q_{x}(x,t)\neq 0 (generic case). The consistency of the basic system (1) represents the problem. Usually, the CNLSE (1a) is written in the form AEK iA_{t}(x,t)+A_{xx}(x,t)+2A(x,t)|A(x,t)|^{2}=0. (2) Obviously, with p=1,q=2 , Eq.(2) is a particular case of CNLSE (1a), hence results obtained w.r.t. C also refer to AEK . In the next Section, assuming validity of the basic system, we derive relations leading to a transformed system in terms of solutions d=\sqrt{z},Q that must hold necessarily for the basic system. – Finally, the validity assumption leads to a contradiction. III Transformation of the basic system to a dynamical system If the basic system is assumed to be consistent, the ansatz (1b) must satisfy the CNLSE (1a). Hence, if A(x,t) is substituted into (1a), we obtain (following the line indicated in AEK , C , Se ), separating imaginary and real parts (assuming p=1 ) \displaystyle Q_{t}(x,t)=d(t)\left(\phi_{t}(t)-q(d^{2}(t)+Q^{2}(x,t))\right) (3a) \displaystyle(Q_{x}(x,t))^{2}=-\frac{q}{2}Q^{4}(x,t)-(q^{2}d^{2}(t)-\phi_{t}(t))Q^{2}(x,t)-2d_{t}(t)Q(x,t)+b(t), (3b) where b(t) denotes the first x- integral of the real part of CNLSE from (1). In order to eliminate (unknown) b(t) and \phi_{t}(t),d_{t}(t) from this system it is useful to transform it (see AEK , C ) as follows. Evaluation of the integrability condition Q_{xt}=Q_{tx} leads to three ordinary differential equations (see Eq.(6) in C and Eqs.(7a)-(7c) in Se ) that can be integrated successively, hence \displaystyle\phi_{t}(t)=-2qd^{2}(t)+c_{1}, (4a) \displaystyle b(t)=\frac{1}{4}(2c_{2}-2c_{1}d^{2}(t)+3qd^{4}(t)), (4b) \displaystyle(d_{t}(t))^{2}=-4q^{2}d^{6}(t)+4qc_{1}d^{4}(t)-(c_{1}^{2}+2qc_{2})d^{2}(t)+c_{3}, (4c) where c_{1},c_{2} and c_{3} are integration constants. Setting d^{2}(t)=z(t) , Eq.(4c) can be rewritten as (z_{t}(t))^{2}=\alpha_{1}z^{4}(t)+4\beta_{1}z^{3}(t)+6\gamma_{1}z^{2}(t)+4\delta_{1}z(t)+\epsilon_{1}=:R_{1}(z), (5) where \alpha_{1}=-16q^{2},\quad\beta_{1}=4qc_{1},\quad\gamma_{1}=-\frac{2}{3}(c_{1}^{2}+4qc_{2}),\quad\delta_{1}=c_{3},\quad\epsilon_{1}=0. By using Eqs.(4a) and (4b), the dynamical system {(3a), (3b)} reads \displaystyle Q_{t}(x,t)=\sqrt{z(t)}(c_{1}-q(3z(t)+Q^{2}(x,t))), (6a) \displaystyle(Q_{x}(x,t))^{2}=-\frac{q}{2}Q^{4}(x,t)+(c_{1}-3qz(t))Q^{2}(x,t)+\frac{z_{t}(t)}{\sqrt{z(t)}}Q(x,t)+2c_{2}+\frac{3}{2}qz^{2}(t)-c_{1}z(t):=R_{2}(x,t). (6b) With solution z(t) of Eq.(5) this system is valid necessarily if the basic system is assumed to be consistent. We note that Eqs.(5), (6a), (6b) are equivalent with the corresponding equations in AEK and C , namely, with Eqs.(13), (5), (15) (due to (4a) in Se and c_{1}=W,c_{2}=\frac{H}{2},c_{3}=D ) in AEK , and with Eqs.(7), (4a), (5) in C ( c_{1}=-\omega_{0},c_{2}=\frac{k_{2}}{2},c_{3}=k_{1},p=1,q=2 ). IV solutions of Eq.(5) and Eq.(6 b ) Obviously Eqs.(5) and (6b) are of the same type. Solutions can be obtained by applying Weierstrass’ solution y(x) (Eq.(11) in Se ). In general, y(x) might be complex and unbounded. The solution of Eq.(5) reads (the prime denotes differentiation w.r.t. z ) z(t)=z_{0}+ +\frac{\frac{1}{2}R^{\prime}_{1}(z_{0})\left(\wp(t;g_{2z},g_{3z})-\frac{1}{24}R^{\prime\prime}_{1}(z_{0})\right)\pm\frac{d\wp(t;g_{2z},g_{3z})}{dt}\sqrt{R_{1}(z_{0})}+\frac{1}{24}R_{1}(z_{0})R_{1}^{\prime\prime\prime}(z_{0})}{2\left(\wp(t;g_{2z},g_{3z})-\frac{1}{24}R_{1}^{\prime\prime}(z_{0})\right)^{2}-\frac{1}{48}R_{1}(z_{0})R_{1}^{\prime\prime\prime\prime}(z_{0})}, (7) where z_{0}=z(0) and g_{2z}=\frac{4}{3}(c_{1}^{2}+4qc_{2})^{2}-16qc_{1}c_{3}, g_{3z}=\frac{8}{27}\left(54q^{2}c_{3}^{2}-18qc_{1}c_{3}(c_{1}^{2}+4qc_{2})+(c_{1}^{2}+4qc_{2})^{3}\right). Equation (6b) is solved by (here the prime denotes differentiation w.r.t. Q ) Q(x,t)=Q_{0}(t)+ +\frac{\frac{1}{2}R^{\prime}_{2}(Q_{0})\left(\wp(x;g_{2Q},g_{3Q})-\frac{1}{24}R_{2}^{\prime\prime}(Q_{0})\right)\pm\frac{d\wp(x;g_{2Q},g_{3Q})}{dx}\sqrt{R_{2}(Q_{0})}+\frac{1}{24}R_{2}(Q_{0})R_{2}^{\prime\prime\prime}(Q_{0})}{2\left(\wp(x;g_{2Q},g_{3Q})-\frac{1}{24}R_{2}^{\prime\prime}(Q_{0})\right)^{2}-\frac{1}{48}R_{2}(Q_{0})R_{2}^{\prime\prime\prime\prime}(Q_{0})}, (8) with g_{2Q}=\frac{c_{1}^{2}}{12}-qc_{2},\quad g_{3Q}=-\frac{(c_{1}-3qz(t))}{216}\left(c_{1}^{2}-24qc_{1}z(t)+36q^{2}z^{2}(t)+36qc_{2}\right)+\frac{qz^{2}_{t}(t)}{32z(t)}. V Inconsistency of the basic system By the foregoing transformation, system \{(6a),(6b)\} represents vanishing imaginary and real parts of Eq.(1a), respectively. With (necessarily) valid (7) (as the only solution of Eq.(5)) and (8) (as the only solution of Eq.(6b)) system \{(6a),(6b)\} must be considered. Solution (7) is valid for any real (see Eqs.(4a)-(4c)) parameters c_{j},q and any real (we consider real g_{2Q} , g_{3Q} ) z_{0} . Solution (8) is valid for any parameters c_{j},q and any z_{0},Q_{0} ; as the unique solution of (6b) in system \{(6a),(6b)\} , (8) is the only solution that must satisfy (6a), if the system is assumed to be consistent: P(x,t;c_{j},q,z_{0},Q_{0}):=Q_{t}(x,t)-\sqrt{z(t)}(c_{1}-q(3z(t)+Q^{2}(x,t)))=0. (9) Since (9) must hold for any real x,t,c_{j},q,z_{0} and any Q_{0} , we select at random x=1,t=1,q=-1,c_{1}=-2,c_{2}=0.4,c_{3}=0.13,z_{0}=1,Q_{0}=1 leading to P(1,1;c_{j},q,1,1)=0.113, contrary to (9): Since (9) is necessary for consistency of the basic system, this system is inconsistent. VI Concluding Comments Whereas ansatz (1b) is compatible with the CNLSE (1a) in the nongeneric cases (as outlined in Se , Section IV), above we have presented arguments that this is not the case in the generic case. – In view of the results in AEK and C , we might be mistaken in this claim. However, if we assume that it is correct, the question arises as to why the inconsistency was not uncovered in AEK and C (may be, the cause for C was a certain discomfort with AEK ) or in publications based on AEK (we did not find citations of C ). In this respect, we point out again that systems \{(5),(6)\} in AEK , \{(4a),(5)\} in C , and system \{(6a),(6b)\} are (only) necessary for validity of the basic system. As far as we can see, neither in AEK nor in C it has been checked whether the real part of Eq.(1a) is vanishing if the corresponding solution \{z(t),Q(x,t)\} is substituted (in AEK : z(t) and Q(x,t) according to (22) and (24), respectively, into Eq.(5); in C : z(t) and Q(x,t) , according to (9) and (13)-(15), respectively, into Eq.(4a)). – This might be a reason, why the error has not been detected. A further question arises as to whether a solution \tilde{Q}(x,t)\neq Q(x,t) is possible. As mentioned in Section I, a formally different (different from Q in (4) and different from Q according to (8)) solution \tilde{Q}(x,t) has been suggested in C . Instead of integrating Eq.(5) in C (Eq.(6) in AEK ), the author of C preferred to transform Eq.(4a) in C to a Riccati equation (13) leading to A(x,t) according to Eq.(16) in C . If \tilde{Q}(x,t) , according to (13)-(15) in C is assumed to be the correct solution of Eq.(4a) in C (equivalent to Eq.(6a)), it must satisfy Eq.(5), which is equivalent to Eq.(6b) due to the transformation of Section 3. However, Eq.(6b) has the unique solution (8)

Read the complete text