Linking Analytic Light Curve Models to Physical Properties of Kilonovae
Ayari Kitamura, Kyohei Kawaguchi, Masaomi Tanaka, Sho Fujibayashi · 2025
Read Linking Analytic Light Curve Models to Physical Properties of Kilonovae by Ayari Kitamura, Kyohei Kawaguchi, Masaomi Tanaka, Sho Fujibayashi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-10021.txt.
Introduction
Ayari Kitamura and co-authors warn that the red and blue pieces fitted to kilonova light may not map onto the real debris, in a 2025 paper. Kilonovae, the glow of merging neutron stars, are usually read as a red part from heavy-element-rich ejecta and a blue part from lighter ejecta. The team fit simple light-curve formulas to realistic simulated explosions instead.
The fits flipped the truth: the fitted red part came out heavier and slower than the actual fast, light dynamical debris, echoing the famous 2017 event. In reality the slow post-merger debris feeds both colors, its blue light partly swallowed and re-emitted as red by the outer shell. Total mass estimates stayed sound within a few-fold. The authors urge near-infrared watching at peak light for solid masses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ayari Kitamura, Kyohei Kawaguchi, Masaomi Tanaka, Sho Fujibayashi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-10021
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Linking Analytic Light Curve Models to Physical Properties of Kilonovae Ayari Kitamura, Kyohei Kawaguchi, Masaomi Tanaka, Sho Fujibayashi Abstract In binary neutron star mergers, lanthanide-rich dynamical ejecta and lanthanide-poor post-merger ejecta have been often linked to the red and blue kilonova emission, respectively. However, analytic light curve modeling of kilonova often results in the ejecta parameters that are at odds with such expectations. To investigate the physical meaning of the derived parameters, we perform analytic modeling of the kilonova light curves calculated with realistic multi-dimensional radiative transfer based on the numerical relativity simulations. Our fiducial simulations adopt a faster-moving, less massive dynamical ejecta and slower-moving, more massive post-merger ejecta. The results of analytic modeling, however, show that the inferred “red” component is more massive and slower, while the “blue” component is less massive and faster, as also inferred for GW170817/AT2017gfo. This suggests that the parameters derived from light curve modeling with an analytic model do not represent the true configuration of the kilonova ejecta. We demonstrate that the post-merger ejecta contributes to both blue and red emissions: the emission from the post-merger ejecta is absorbed and reprocessed to red emission by the dynamical ejecta with a higher lanthanide fraction. Our results caution against separately discussing the origins of red and blue components derived from the analytic models. Despite of the challenges in the parameter estimation, we show that the estimate of the total ejecta mass is rather robust within a factor of a few, reflecting the total luminosity output. To derive the reliable total ejecta mass, multi-epoch observations in near-infrared wavelengths near their light curve peaks are important. I Introduction Figure 1: Relationship between mass and velocity of the ejecta from neutron star mergers. The blue and red points represent the blue and red components from the analytic model fitting of GW170817/AT2017gfo [ 81 ] . Other symbols represent four different NR simulations: blue and red colors indicate the post-merger and dynamical ejecta, respectively [ 22 , 21 ] . The merger of neutron stars is considered as a prime candidate for the origin of r -process elements [ 41 , 15 , 9 ] . During the mergers, a small fraction of mass is ejected [ 61 , 25 ] , synthesizing various radioactive nuclei [ 20 ] . Then, decays of the newly synthesized nuclei power electromagnetic wave emissions especially in the optical and near-infrared (NIR) wavelengths, which is called kilonova ( Li & Paczyński 42 , Kulkarni 40 , Metzger et al. 48 , see Tanaka 67 , Fernández & Metzger 17 , Metzger 46 for reviews). Since the kilonova light curves are mainly characterized by ejecta mass ( M ), velocity ( v ), and opacity ( \kappa ) of the ejecta [ 42 , 28 , 30 , 5 , 71 , 72 ] , we can extract the properties of the ejected material from the analysis of the light curves. Early radiative transfer simulations suggest that the kilonova light curves can have broadly two components: “red” (mainly NIR) emission from the lanthanide-rich ejecta with a high opacity [ 68 , 28 ] , and “blue” (mainly optical) emission from ejecta, which contains lighter r -process elements with a low opacity [ 47 , 30 , 72 ] . These two components are also naturally predicted from numerical relativity (NR) simulations of the merger (see e.g., Shibata et al. 63 , Perego et al. 52 , Radice et al. 54 , Shibata & Hotokezaka 64 ): fast dynamical ejecta are typically neutron-rich including a low electron fraction material ( Y_{\rm{e}}\lesssim 0.25 , lanthanide-rich), while slower post-merger ejecta have a higher Y_{\rm e} material ( Y_{\rm{e}}\sim 0.25-0.5 , lanthanide-poor). The first joint observation of gravitational and electromagnetic emission from a neutron star merger was achieved for GW170817/AT2017gfo [ 1 ] . The optical and NIR light curves of AT2017gfo show a blue emission at the initial phase, followed by a prolonged red emission at later phases [ 3 , 4 , 8 , 10 , 12 , 14 , 16 , 32 , 44 , 53 , 62 , 66 , 75 , 76 , 77 , 79 ] . Since the presence of both blue and red components itself is consistent with theoretical expectations as described above, analytic modeling of AT2017gfo with a two-component (blue and red) model have been often performed (e.g., Cowperthwaite et al. 10 , Drout et al. 14 , Villar et al. 81 ). A similar two-component model has also been applied for kilonova candidates associated with gamma-ray bursts (e.g., O’Connor et al. 50 , Rastinejad et al. 56 , Rastinejad et al. 55 , Yang et al. 85 ). However, such two-component analytic modeling of the observed light curve yields the ejecta parameters that are at odds with theoretical prediction of NR simulations. Figure 1 shows the relationship between ejecta mass and velocity derived from NR simulations [ 22 , 21 ] and those estimated from analytic modeling [ 81 ] . There is a clear discrepancy between the NR simulations and estimates from the observations: the dynamical ejecta are often thought to correspond to the red component, but the inferred red component has a higher mass and lower velocity. Similarly, the inferred blue component has a higher velocity than that of the post-merger ejecta. Such a discrepancy has prompted some discussion involving the existence of a physically distinct fast blue component (or fast blue ejecta, e.g., Cowperthwaite et al. 10 , Kasen et al. 31 , Villar et al. 81 ). The discrepancy in the derived parameters may stem from the simplification made in the analytic light curve modeling. For example, in typical analytic models, the detailed elemental abundances are not considered and the effects of the abundances are represented by a choice of parameterized constant grey opacity [ 46 ] . In reality, however, the opacities depend on wavelength and time, reflecting the bound-bound transitions of heavy elements [ 28 , 69 , 70 ] . Furthermore, the photons in multiple ejecta components should experience complex radiative transfer processes, including absorption and reprocessing [ 36 , 37 , 35 ] . In fact, recent, more realistic end-to-end simulations covering the entire process from the merger to observational outputs [ 35 , 34 , 33 , 27 , 65 ] show that the light curves similar to those observed in GW170817/AT2017gfo can be realized by the ejecta configuration which NR simulations predict. Given these situations, some studies have attempted to estimate the ejecta parameters using a “surrogate model” [ 57 , 24 , e.g.,] . In this approach, detailed radiative transfer calculations are conducted across parameter grids and then interpolated to enable the fast parameter estimation. Some of these studies yield parameter estimates consistent with the NR simulations [ 2 , 51 ] . However, some cases result in the estimates similar to those from analytic models [ 7 , 58 ] , and the estimated parameters are sensitive to the assumptions in the radiative transfer simulations such as ejecta morphology [ 2 ] . Since realistic radiative transfer simulations based on numerical relativity simulations are still limited, the parameter space that can be used for the parameter estimation