SoK: State of the time: On Trustworthiness of Digital Clocks

Adeel Nasrullah, Fatima M. Anwar · 2025

Read SoK: State of the time: On Trustworthiness of Digital Clocks by Adeel Nasrullah, Fatima M. Anwar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09837.txt.

Introduction

Digital clocks underpin vital services, yet their trustworthiness is fragile, Adeel Nasrullah and Fatima Anwar argue in a 2025 systematization paper. Timing supports public key infrastructure, smart grids, navigation, and high-frequency trading. Modern timing stacks stay vulnerable to attack for several reasons, including weak security, a unique sensitivity to delays, and implementation flaws.

The authors analyze the security flaws of the whole timing stack in a systematic way. They uncover attack surfaces that prior work often overlooked, such as physical timing parts and on-device timekeeping, since most research studies synchronization protocols alone. They also show that emerging trusted timing designs are flawed and could harm wider system security. An alternative design based on hardware-software co-design is proposed.

Catalog record

CREATORAdeel Nasrullah, Fatima M. Anwar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09837

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

SoK: State of the time: On Trustworthiness of Digital Clocks Adeel Nasrullah, Fatima M. Anwar Abstract Despite the critical role of timing infrastructure in enabling essential services—from public key infrastructure and smart grids to autonomous navigation and high-frequency trading—modern timing stacks remain highly vulnerable to malicious attacks. These threats emerge due to several reasons, including inadequate security mechanisms, the timing architecture’s unique vulnerability to delays, and implementation issues. In this paper, we aim to obtain a holistic understanding of the issues that make the timing stacks vulnerable to adversarial manipulations, what the challenges are in securing them, and what solutions can be borrowed from the research community to address them. To this end, we perform a systematic analysis of the security vulnerabilities of the timing stack. In doing so, we discover new attack surfaces, i.e., physical timing components and on-device timekeeping , which are often overlooked by existing research that predominantly studies the security of time synchronization protocols. We also show that the emerging trusted timing architectures are flawed & risk compromising wider system security, and propose an alternative design using hardware-software co-design . 1 Introduction An accurate perception of time is indispensable in modern digital ecosystems. Critical applications such as Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) [ 2 ] , streaming authentication protocols such as TESLA [ 81 ] , smart grid operations [ 101 , 11 ] , autonomous vehicle perception systems [ 56 ] , and high-frequency trading [ 14 ] depend on precise timing for their proper functionality. Further, the absence of accurate time synchronization endangers Time Difference of Arrival (TDoA)-based applications, which are vital for electronic warfare [ 83 ] , vehicular triangulation [ 108 ] , sonar operations in marine environments [ 105 ] , environmental conservation [ 111 ] , and indoor localization [ 113 ] . Disrupting these cyber-physical systems (CPS), by exploiting their timing stacks, poses a serious threat to society. Despite the pivotal role of timing infrastructure, it remains susceptible to adversarial manipulations. NTP [ 25 ] , the predominant time-sync protocol on the internet, could face continental-scale disruptions due to a few malicious servers within its pool [ 50 ] . PTP [ 80 ] , essential for high-precision synchronization, is vulnerable to frequency manipulations by compromised nodes despite using dual authentication [ 44 ] . GPS, integral to critical infrastructure, can be easily spoofed [ 104 ] . Furthermore, recently developed high-precision time-sync protocols, e.g., Huygens [ 33 ] and Sundial [ 61 ] , as well as the IoT framework Matter ’s timing stack [ 21 ] , do not adequately address their security. The prevalence of security vulnerabilities in existing and emerging time stacks warrants a systematic examination of their issues. In this paper, we present the first systematization of knowledge for time security in a typical CPS. While existing research on this topic has made important contributions, it has been limited to examining single protocols (e.g., NTP [ 66 , 50 , 98 ] , PTP [ 3 , 97 , 44 ] , and GPS [ 104 , 1 , 71 , 53 ] etc.) or specific types of attacks (e.g., delay attacks [ 3 , 70 ] ). In contrast, we propose the idea of a timing framework and provide a holistic view of time stack security; we analyze the vulnerabilities of physical timing components (e.g., quartz crystals), software-based clocks , and the time-sync protocols . Utilizing this timing framework, we highlight existing and emerging attack surfaces, gain insights into the extent and scope of proposed countermeasures, and identify open research problems. Leveraging our framework, we discover previously uncharted attack surfaces threatening the timing stack of CPS, and present case studies that underscore the gravity of these threats. Through our study, we demonstrate that these attacks surfaces, constituting side-channel attacks on physical timing components , and risks posed by privileged software to the integrity of system time , are insufficiently addressed by the current body of timing security research. This oversight often results in conflating timing stack security with mere time synchronization issues, predominantly attributing threats to network-based attackers (e.g., DNS cache poisoning on NTP [ 50 ] , delay attacks on PTP [ 3 ] , and GPS spoofing [ 27 ] ). While some recent research has focused on securing time within Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs) to guard against privileged software adversary, our analysis reveals that this area is fraught with unresolved challenges. Our work fills this gap through a comprehensive systematization of security vulnerabilities across the timing stack’s hardware, software, and network dimensions. We also show that research methodologies used for building secure timing services can be classified into two categories: system-based approach, which utilizes design mechanisms like NTP’s message authentication [ 25 ] to deter attacks, and theoretical approach, applying mathematical tools (e.g., theorem proving, model checking, game theory) for the security analysis of timing protocols. Despite their significant contributions to timing stack security, very few works successfully utilize both strategies together. Their limited interaction is exemplified by the formal analysis of NTS 1 1 1 NTS is a secure version of NTP. by Tiechel et al. [ 103 ] , which falls short of analyzing full specifications due to the analysis tool’s inability to model time and clocks. Nevertheless, we evaluate the two approaches to determine their coverage of the timing stack’s security issues and contrast their contributions. Moreover, we identify a significant risk to CPS security posed by state-of-the-art trusted timing services like Timeseal [ 5 ] and T3E [ 36 ] . These solutions provide TEE 2 2 2 Trusted Execution Environment. -confined trusted timestamps to user applications, requiring them to execute inside the TEE. Given that such applications may come from untrusted sources, they pose a threat to sensitive code and data inside the TEE. As a result, these solutions inadvertently increase system-wide security risks. Drawing from our timing stack security analysis, we provide recommendations for an alternative design that aligns with the goal of overall system security. Additionally, we highlight future research directions to advance this domain. In summary, we make the following contributions: (1) We conduct the first systematic study of timing stack security in light of the proposed timing framework. (2) We identify previously overlooked attack surfaces through case studies. (3) We propose an intuitive taxonomy for categorizing timing stack vulnerabilities and analyze relevant literature. (4) We categorize timing stack solutions into system-based and theoretical, highlighting their unique contributions and limitations. (5) Finally, we identify open research challenges related to the timing stack’s security. 2 Background In this section, we provide a brief introduction to the timing stacks in contemporary digital systems. Additionally, we describe the types of timing attacks and present case studies demonstrating attacks on the timing stack. 2.1 Timing Stack Basics Measuring Time. The foundation of any timing stack is its timing source, which emits a recurring signal at fixed intervals. This clock signal is essential for digital systems to measure time accurately. Figure 1 illustrates a typical Cyber-Physical System (CPS) timing stack, where the time source is integrated into the physical hardware, accompanied by time measurement components such as counters and timer registers. The time source, often a quartz crystal,

Read the complete text