Principles and Policy Recommendations for Comprehensive Genetic Data Governance

Vivek Ramanan, Ria Vinod, Cole Williams, Sohini Ramachandran, Suresh Venkatasubramanian · 2025

Read Principles and Policy Recommendations for Comprehensive Genetic Data Governance by Vivek Ramanan, Ria Vinod, Cole Williams, Sohini Ramachandran, Suresh Venkatasubramanian (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09716.txt.

Introduction

Vivek Ramanan and four co-authors propose rules for genetic data in twenty twenty-five. Genetic data is now collected everywhere, revealing health, ancestry, and social traits. Unregulated use risks privacy loss and discrimination. AI systems that fuse genetic, clinical, behavioral, and environmental data sharpen those risks.

The authors organize uses of genetic data into four pillars. A risk assessment framework identifies the values any governance system must preserve. It draws on contextual integrity, data relationality, and the Belmont principles. Four real-world case studies test the framework. Gaps in current regulation and threats to personal liberty are identified. Readers get principles and policy recommendations aimed at governance that covers the whole data life cycle.

Catalog record

CREATORVivek Ramanan, Ria Vinod, Cole Williams, Sohini Ramachandran, Suresh Venkatasubramanian
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09716

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Principles and Policy Recommendations for Comprehensive Genetic Data Governance Vivek Ramanan, Ria Vinod, Cole Williams, Sohini Ramachandran, Suresh Venkatasubramanian Abstract Genetic data collection has become ubiquitous, producing genetic information about health, ancestry, and social traits. However, unregulated use—especially amid evolving scientific understanding—poses serious privacy and discrimination risks. These risks are intensified by advancing AI, particularly multi-modal systems integrating genetic, clinical, behavioral, and environmental data. In this work, we organize the uses of genetic data along four distinct ‘pillars’, and develop a risk assessment framework that identifies key values any governance system must preserve. In doing so, we draw on current privacy scholarship concerning contextual integrity, data relationality, and the Belmont principle. We apply the framework to four real-world case studies and identify critical gaps in existing regulatory frameworks and specific threats to privacy and personal liberties, particularly through genetic discrimination. Finally, we offer three policy recommendations for genetic data governance that safeguard individual rights in today’s under-regulated ecosystem of large-scale genetic data collection and usage. Introduction The scale of genetic data generation has increased at a staggering rate since 2001 ( Loos 2020 ; Bycroft et al. 2018 ) . A primary driver of this is decreased DNA sequencing costs ( Wetterstrand 2023 ) . For example, there are whole genome sequences combined with medical records from approximately 400,000 US residents in the National Institutes of Health (NIH) All of Us Research Study, with plans to increase sampling to include at least 1 million US residents ( National Institutes of Health 2024 ) . Direct-to-consumer (DTC) genetic testing companies have much more data: 23andMe has 14 million customer sequences ( 23andMe 2023a ) and Ancestry has 25 million ( Ancestry 2025 ) . The increase in genetic data and improvements in technologies has resulted in the following aspirational “bold prediction” for 2030 by the NIH: “a person’s complete genome sequence along with informative annotations can be securely and readily accessible on their smartphone” ( Gunter and Green 2023 ) . From a scientific perspective, the collection of genetic data and subsequent genetic information at this scale has been critically valuable to understanding health, ancestry, and driving public health initiatives. The unregulated collection of genetic data has created new avenues for surveillance, exploitation, and systemic harm. Since 2020, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has accelerated its collection of genetic data, growing the federal DNA database (CODIS) by more than 1.5 million people, the majority of whom are people of color ( Glaberson, Tse, and Tucker 2024 ) . 23andMe suffered a data breach after a hacker accessed customer profiles, primarily targeting individuals of Chinese and Ashkenazi Jewish descent ( Carballo, Schmall, and Tumin 2024 ) . Such pressing, real-world discrimination and privacy concerns are exacerbated by the sordid history of eugenics and forced sterilization in U.S. states in the 20th century (a model later adopted by Nazi Germany ( Spiegel 2019 ) ), and more recent practices of genetic determinism ( Epstein 2003 ) , racial pseudoscience ( Duello et al. 2021 ; Lala and Feldman 2024 ; Carlson et al. 2022 ; Panofsky, Dasgupta, and Iturriaga 2021 ) , race-motivated violence ( Carlson et al. 2022 ) , privacy and consent violations ( Jillson 2024 ; Sterling 2011 ; Strand 2016 ) , and broad scientific distrust ( Saulsberry and Terry 2013 ; Parkman et al. 2015 ; Kaye 2012 ) . These serious concerns must be addressed today given the number of recent proposals to use genetic data and information in public infrastructure—e.g., to assess intelligence proxies, like IQ ( Plomin and von Stumm 2018 ) ; insurance premiums ( Karlsson Linnér and Koellinger 2022 ) ; or educational outcomes ( Harden et al. 2020 ) . The only federal-level legislation in effect is the Genetic Information Non-Discrimination Act (GINA), which prohibits using genetic information in employment and health insurance decisions but not in long-term care, disability, or life insurance. Our Work. In this paper, we make three contributions to construct a robust genetic data governance system. First, we expand upon Wan et al.’s ( 2022 ) Four Pillars of genetic data collectors and argue that inconsistent and leaky regulation across these pillars introduces opportunity for genetic discrimination and privacy violations. Second, we present a risk assessment framework for modern genetic data governance, derived from theoretical analysis and existing U.S. policy. Third, we make policy recommendations to (1) define genetic data and genetic information as a distinct protected category of sensitive data, (2) extend the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) to include this category, and (3) establish a unified regulatory framework to govern all collection of genetic data and applications of genetic information. Background: How health and social information is derived from genetic data An individual’s genome is over 3 billion DNA bases long and derived equally from both genetic parents. Genetic variants—units of DNA that differ between individuals—are scattered throughout the genome and contain information about genetically influenced traits (from physical traits to behavioral traits). To predict traits or disease risk, geneticists analyze an individual’s unique set of genetic variants. However, this remains a challenging task: while diseases like cystic fibrosis or Huntington’s disease are determined by a single genetic variant, most traits are influenced by many variants across the genome as well as non-genetic factors (complex traits). In this section, we make the connection between genetic data—the raw genomic material—and genetic information, which refers to health, ancestry, and social traits inferred through statistical analysis of that genetic data. Genetic data is inherently relational The inheritance of DNA—where each parent passes down a random half of their genome to their offspring—results in relatives sharing portions of their DNA, with closer relatives sharing a larger proportion. Shared genetic material means that decisions made about any individual’s genome extend to their genetic relatives. At the population level, all individuals can be found in a latent web of interconnectedness. This means that a privacy breach in a small part of this web (that represents those in a genetic dataset, for example) may propagate to larger parts of the web and implicate individuals who were not in the original dataset. Thus, relationality applies to genetic data, where value is derived from shared connections among individuals ( Viljoen 2024 ; Hargreaves 2017 ) . This relationality complicates discussions of privacy in the context of genetic data ( Costello 2022 ) . A powerful example of the relationality of genetic data was highlighted in 2018, when law enforcement leveraged it to identify the Golden State Killer. Authorities used DNA left at a crime scene to identify distant relatives through DNA matching on a public website, GEDMatch. By combining these matches with publicly available genealogical records, they identified the suspect despite the closest identifiable relatives sharing only a great-great-great-great-grandfather ( Kaiser 2018 ; Zabel 2019 ) . An individual’s genome is shared with tens of thousands of other individuals, but at the same time is uniquely theirs: even the genomes of identical twins contain differences ( Jonsson et al. 2021 ) . While a single genome in isolation may not always be immediately identifiable, the relational nature of genetic data can enable re-identification. Researchers have argued that genomic data should be treated as “always

Read the complete text