The main jet axis of the W49B supernova remnant

Noam Soker, Dmitry Shishkin · 2025

Read The main jet axis of the W49B supernova remnant by Noam Soker, Dmitry Shishkin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09543.txt.

Introduction

Noam Soker and Dmitry Shishkin identify the main jet axis of a supernova remnant in a 2025 paper. The remnant, called W49B, holds two ear like bulges on opposite sides with rich heavy elements. The authors argue those bulges were inflated by a pair of jets when the star exploded.

A line through the clumps at the tips of the two ears marks the jet axis, they say. Three arcs around that axis look like parts of full rings that jets carve in other objects. Finding a jet axis rules out one explosion type and leaves two jet based options, the authors argue.

Catalog record

CREATORNoam Soker, Dmitry Shishkin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09543

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The main jet axis of the W49B supernova remnant Noam Soker, Dmitry Shishkin Abstract We identify an axis connecting two opposite ‘ears’ in the supernova remnant W49B and morphological signatures of three arcs around this axis that we claim are sections of full circum-jet rings. Based on recent identifications of morphological signatures of jets in core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe), including ejecta-rich axes, we re-examine images of W49B and identify a heavy element-rich protrusion (ear) as a jet-inflated structure. We identify the opposite ear and a clump at its tip as the signature of the opposite jets. The line connecting the two clumps at the tips of the two opposite ears forms the main jet axis of W49B. We compare the three arcs around the main jet axis in W49B to the circum-jet rings of the jets in the Cygnus A galaxy and deduce that these arcs are sections of full circum-jet rings in W49B. In W49B, the jets are long gone, as in some planetary nebulae with circum-jet rings. Identifying the main jet axis is incompatible with a type Ia supernova. It leaves two possibilities: that jets exploded W49B as a CCSN, i.e., the jittering jets explosion mechanism where the pair of jets we identify is one of many that exploded the star, or that the explosion was a common envelope jet supernova with a thermonuclear outburst, i.e., both the pair of jets and thermonuclear outburst exploded the core of a red supergiant star as a pre-existing neutron star tidally destroyed it. I Introduction The supernova remnant (SNR) W49B (G43.3–0.2; Westerhout 1958 ) is a puzzling SNR concerning, among others, its explosion process and symmetry axis. The dynamically estimated age of W49B is 4-6 kyr ( Hwang et al. 2000 ; Zhou & Vink 2018 ). Several studies presented its thermal and emission properties (e.g., Ozawa et al. 2009 ; Patnaude et al. 2015 ; H. E. S. S. Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Tanaka et al. 2018 ; Yamaguchi et al. 2018 ; Liu et al. 2019 ; Sano et al. 2021 ; Siegel et al. 2021 ; Suzuki et al. 2024 ), including images of W49B (e.g., Lacey et al. 2001 ; Lee et al. 2019 ; Lee et al. 2020 ; Castelletti et al. 2021 ), and its properties. Lopez et al. 2009 studied in detail the X-ray morphology, and found the iron to have a different distribution from sulphur and silicon. Zhou et al. 2011 simulated the interaction of W49B with its inhomogeneous circumstellar and interstellar medium and claim that mixing of relatively cold medium gas with the hot shocked ejecta and the rapid adiabatic expansion of the ejecta explains the presence of overionized plasma, which was later strengthened by X-ray observations (Chandra: Lopez et al. 2013a ; NuSTAR: Yamaguchi et al. 2018 ). On the other hand, Holland-Ashford et al. 2020 found the overionization to increase from east to west, like Lopez et al. 2013a found, and argued that cooling by thermal conduction can explain this overionization. Sun & Chen 2020 studied W49B and its overionized ejecta, and concluded that the ejecta’s metal abundance ratios are compatible with a CCSN of a star with an initial mass of <15M_{\odot} , except for a high Mn/Fe. Sano et al. 2021 found that CO clouds at low velocity show a good spatial correspondence to the X-ray and synchrotron structure of the SNR, and Zhou et al. 2022 found strong interaction with a cloud. Zhu et al. 2014 studied the molecular clouds in the W49B environment and suggested that the warm dust comes from the evaporation of clouds interacting with W49B. The complicated structure of W49B and its environment promoted suggestions of several scenarios for its formation. The three progenitors that the literature discusses are thermonuclear explosion as a type Ia supernova (SN Ia; e.g., Hwang et al. 2000 ; Zhou & Vink 2018 ; Siegel et al. 2020 ; Sato et al. 2024 ), core-collapse supernova (CCSN; e.g., Lopez et al. 2011 ; Lopez et al. 2013b ; Yamaguchi et al. 2014 ; Patnaude et al. 2015 ), and a common envelope jets supernova with thermonuclear outburst ( Grichener & Soker 2023 ) . Some studies find W49B to be a peculiar remnant that does not fit any scenario well (e.g., Patnaude et al. 2015 ; Siegel et al. 2020 ). Sawada et al. 2024 argue that the Fe-group ejecta mass ratios might result from either an SN Ia or a CCSN. Sato et al. 2024 claim that their determined titanium abundance excludes almost all hypernova/jet-driven supernova models. We note that they refer to an explosion driven by a fixed-axis jet that requires rapid pre-collapse core rotation (e.g., Khokhlov et al. 1999 ; Leung et al. 2023 ); they do not refer to nor exclude the jittering jet explosion mechanism (JJEM) of CCSNe (for recent simulations of the JJEM see Braudo et al. 2025 ). There is also a debate on the direction of the jet axis of W49B, with the two views orthogonal to each other. One group takes the jet axis to be the narrow high concentration of iron in the centre, in the general east-west direction (e.g., Miceli et al. 2008 ; Miceli et al. 2010 ; Lopez et al. 2011 ; Lopez et al. 2013b ; González-Casanova et al. 2014 ), as the axis of the barrel-shaped morphology that ( Keohane et al. 2007 ) suggest for W49B. The other view is that the general symmetry axis, the main jet axis, is more or less in the north-south direction, as Bear & Soker 2017 defined it and a few papers adopted ( Akashi et al. 2018 ; Siegel et al. 2020 ; Grichener & Soker 2023 ). In this study, we strengthen the latter view. Recent new identifications of jet axes in several CCSN remnants (CCSNRs; e.g., Soker & Shishkin 2024 ; for a review, see Soker 2024a ) and finding similarities with some jet-shaped morphologies in planetary nebulae (PNe; e.g., Soker 2024b ; Bear et al. 2024 ) and cooling flow clusters ( Soker 2024c ; Soker 2024b ), motivate us to re-examine images of SNR W49B and to search for the main jets axis; we do this in Section II . In section III , we compare the morphology of W49B with jet-shaped objects to strengthen our identification of the main jet axis. We summarize in Section V with a discussion on the possible origins of SNR W49B. II The main jet axis of W49B We start with radio images from Lacey et al. 2001 that we present in panels a and b in Figure 1 . The radio image shows a prominent ear in the southwest and a larger and less prominent one in the northeast, as we mark on panels a and b. Panel c is an X-ray image with two clumps at the tips of the ears, which we mark by NE and SW clumps. The four insets are images from Lopez et al. 2013b that present the morphology of four elements as indicated. The double-headed red arrow has the exact location in all panels. Figure 1: Panels a and b are radio images of SNR W49B from Lacey

Read the complete text