Thermodynamics of multi-colored loop models in three dimensions
Soumya Kanti Ganguly, Sumanta Mukherjee, Chandan Dasgupta · 2025
Read Thermodynamics of multi-colored loop models in three dimensions by Soumya Kanti Ganguly, Sumanta Mukherjee, Chandan Dasgupta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09516.txt.
Introduction
Ganguly, Mukherjee, and Dasgupta study phase changes in 3D loop models painted with several colors. Monte Carlo simulations tracked order-disorder shifts in these models. The kind of shift turned out to hinge on the loops' symmetry.
Symmetric loops jumped in a sharp first-order change. Non-symmetric loops shifted smoothly, in a second-order change, and the team computed its critical exponents. Plain loop models in 3D mirror the XY model, but color interactions changed the heat exponent here. Strong links between colors can even flip a smooth change into a sharp one. The work ties loop shape to phase behavior.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Soumya Kanti Ganguly, Sumanta Mukherjee, Chandan Dasgupta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09516
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Thermodynamics of multi-colored loop models in three dimensions Soumya Kanti Ganguly, Sumanta Mukherjee, Chandan Dasgupta Abstract We study order-disorder transitions in three-dimensional multi-colored loop models using Monte Carlo simulations. We show that the nature of the transition is intimately related to the nature of the loops. The symmetric loops undergo a first order phase transition, while the non-symmetric loops show a second-order transition. The critical exponents for the non-symmetric loops are calculated. In three dimensions, the regular loop model with no interactions is dual to the XY model. We argue that, due to interactions among the colors, the specific heat exponent is found to be different from that of the regular loop model. The continuous nature of the transition is altered to a discontinuous one due to the strong inter-color interactions. I Introduction A perfect solid is a regular arrangement of atoms with a given periodicity. The solid-state is characterized by broken translational and rotational symmetry. However, in reality, perfect solids do not exist but contain irregularities in the form of vacancies or interstitials. This results in the formation of an extra plane of atoms or a deficiency of the same. This is a defect which is topological in nature. It means that no amount of smooth deformation of the solid will result in the complete removal of the defect. Topological defects that are responsible for the breakdown of the translational part of the symmetry are known as dislocations and the ones that break the rotational part are known as disclinations. A dislocation is a second-rank tensor quantity. One of its indices represents the direction of the dislocation line and the other represents the Burgers vector. If the two indices the are same, then it is a screw dislocation; otherwise, it is known as an edge dislocation. In general, a dislocated solid will have a combination of these two dislocations. For an edge dislocation, the dislocation line along a given direction i and the Burgers vector in the orthogonal direction j need not have a symmetric counterpart with the dislocation line along j and the Burgers vector along i . Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that a dislocation tensor is a second-rank non-symmetric tensor. The possibility of dislocations causing melting in solids was first suggested by C. Mott [ 1 ] . Experiments performed by Crawford [ 2 ] , Cotterill and Kristensen [ 3 ] suggest the nucleation of defects in the vicinity of the melting transition. This view has been later supported by Molecular dynamics as well as Monte Carlo (MC) simulations [ 4 , 5 ] . The first satisfactory theory of the melting transition due to dislocations was put forward by Mizushima [ 6 ] and Ookawa [ 7 ] , after which many other theories of dislocations and their role in melting were formulated [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . From the statistical physics point of view, dislocations may be treated as extended objects similar to polymers [ 11 ] or as closed loops [ 12 , 13 ] . As mentioned before, they are second-rank non-symmetric tensors, which obey a continuity condition (divergenceless) and have long-range interactions among themselves. These interactions not only depend upon their relative positions but also on their orientations [ 14 ] . Solids in two dimensions transit smoothly (continuous transition) from a less symmetric crystalline ordered state to a more symmetric liquid disordered state [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . The situation is quite the opposite in three dimensions, where the solid-to-liquid (melting) transition or vice-versa is discontinuous in nature. MC simulations performed by Janke and Kleinert [ 21 ] have confirmed this observation. Their model is essentially Gaussian in nature with a combination of elastic and defect degrees of freedom. An alternate viewpoint was suggested by Kleinert [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] , where he looked at the objects that are dual [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] to the dislocations with short-ranged interactions. These dual objects are divergenceless tensors, which are basically closed loops. These loops form the basis of our studies reported in this paper and in a companion paper (Ganguly et al. [ 29 ] , hereafter GMDb24). The aim of this present study is to further investigate the thermodynamic properties of these loop models using MC simulations. Since these loops are second-rank tensors ( \bar{\eta}_{ij} ), they can be symmetric ( \bar{\eta}_{ij}=\bar{\eta}_{ji} ) or non-symmetric ( \bar{\eta}_{ij}\neq\bar{\eta}_{ji} ) in nature. Henceforth, throughout this paper, the symmetric loops will be referred to as SY loops and the non-symmetric loops as NS loops. We have considered both the loop models to explore the order-disorder transitions in three-dimensional regular lattices. In GMDb24, we focus on analyzing the geometrical properties of these NS loops using certain thermodynamic quantities derived herein. In particular, the loop percolation properties of the NS loops have been studied using the finite-size scaling method. The loops obey the following divergenceless conditions \boldsymbol{\Delta}_{i}\bar{\eta}_{ij}(\mathbf{x})=0, (1) where the index j=1,2,3 , will be referred to as the color index (red, blue, green). In both cases, these loops interact via an on-site or contact interaction. In other words, these loops can annihilate or reinforce one another only when they share an edge. Our studies show that the SY loops undergo a first-order phase transition, whereas a second-order phase transition is seen in the NS loops (see Sec. III). Therefore, one can ask whether the nature of the transition is related to the nature of the loops or not. To answer this question, we study the finite temperature properties of these loop models using MC simulations. We find that for large negative values of the inter-color interaction parameter ( D ), the nature of the transition in NS loops is also altered from a continuous one to a discontinuous one. For different values of D ( 0.1,\pm 0.2 , etc.), our finite-size scaling studies show that the specific heat exponent ( \alpha ) for the NS loops is different from that of the XY model in three dimensions. We argue that this deviation from the second-order behaviour in NS loops is due to the presence of inter-color interactions. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we give a bird’s-eye view of Kleinert’s theory for dislocations, followed by a detailed description of our models. In Section III, we discuss the low and high-temperature properties of both loop models. We then discuss the first-order transition and metastability seen in SY loops. Subsequently, we perform the finite-size scaling study of the NS loop system, where we calculate its critical exponents. We then look at the relevance of the inter-color coupling in altering the nature of the phase transition in NS loops from a continuous transition to a discontinuous one. Finally, in Section IV, we end with some concluding remarks and some plausible future directions. The update rules for the SY loops are described in the Appendix. II Models In the present section, we briefly discuss Kleinert’s theory for dislocations, followed by a detailed description of the 3-color loop models, and finally, the methods used to study these loop models. II.1 A brief overview of Kleinert’s theory