The Effect of Rotation on Triggering S Doradus Instabilities in Luminous Blue Variables

Emily M. Levesque, Henny J. G. L. M. Lamers, Alex de Koter · 2025

Read The Effect of Rotation on Triggering S Doradus Instabilities in Luminous Blue Variables by Emily M. Levesque, Henny J. G. L. M. Lamers, Alex de Koter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2502-09504.txt.

Introduction

Emily Levesque, Henny Lamers, and Alex de Koter examine how rotation triggers outbursts in luminous blue variables, in a two thousand twenty-five astronomy paper. These massive stars lose huge amounts of mass and vary strongly. Their slow eruptions, called S Dor variations, change their temperatures over years to decades.

Observations show the variations start when a star reaches a strip where radiation pressure nearly cancels gravity. The team adopts an instability criterion based on that balance. They then run numerical models at solar and lower metallicities to add rotation. Rotation worsens the instability, they find. Most modeled stars prove unstable at both equator and poles, and some lose extra mass at the poles.

Catalog record

CREATOREmily M. Levesque, Henny J. G. L. M. Lamers, Alex de Koter
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2502-09504

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Effect of Rotation on Triggering S Doradus Instabilities in Luminous Blue Variables Emily M. Levesque, Henny J. G. L. M. Lamers, Alex de Koter Abstract Luminous blue variables are an intermediate stage in the evolution of high-mass stars characterized by extreme mass loss and substantial variability. The stars show large irregular episodic variations on timescales of years to decades in these stars’ effective temperatures (called “S Dor variations”). Observations show that these variations are triggered when the stars are in a well-defined strip in the HRD that corresponds to the Modified Eddington Limit, where the atmospheric radiation pressure almost balances gravity. In this work we consider the role that rotation plays in the instability that leads to the triggering of S Dor variations in luminous post-main sequence LBVs. We adopt the existing instability criterion that the effective surface gravity is reduced to 10% of the Newtonian gravity due to radiation pressure in the atmosphere of non-rotating stars. We then specifically describe how rotation impacts this instability. By carrying out numerical simulations of model LBVs at both solar and sub-solar metallicities, we confirm that most LBVs should be unstable at both the equator and the poles, and that rotation exacerbates this effect; some models also produce enhanced mass loss at the pole or equator. Our numerical models also predict dense equatorial disks or rings and high-velocity bipolar outflows, in agreement with existing observations of LBV circumstellar nebulae. I Introduction Luminous blue variables (LBVs) are an intermediate stage in the evolution of high mass ( \gtrsim 30M_{\odot} ) stars. They represent a crucial evolutionary stage for these stars, characterized by extreme mass loss and substantial variability. Despite their importance there are a number of open questions regarding LBVs. Telltale physical signatures of LBVs include their extremely high luminosities (log( L / L_{\odot} ) \gtrsim 5.4) and large irregular episodic variations in their temperatures on timescales of years to decades. The latter are referred to as “S Dor variations”. During S Dor variations LBVs vary between a “hot” state and a “cool” state (hitting a fairly narrow minimum T_{\rm eff} range of 7500-9000 K; Figure 1) while maintaining a nearly constant luminosity. During the “hot state” LBVs occupy a narrow well-defined strip in the HRD, sometimes referred to as the S Dor instability strip, that runs from about (\log(L/\mbox{$L_{\odot}$}),\log(\mbox{$T_{\rm eff}$}))\simeq(6.2,4.5) to (5.4, 4.1) (e.g. Wolf 1989 , Humphreys & Davidson 1994 , de Koter et al. 1996 Smith et al. 2004 , Weis & Bomans 2020 , Davidson 2020 , and Figure 1). The transition between the two states manifests observationally as long-term photometric variability due to the star’s changing bolometric correction as a function of T_{\rm eff} . Davidson 2020 has pointed out the potential difference in evolutionary phase between the more luminous LBVs (log L>5.7 ) and the lower luminosity LBVs (log L<5.7 ) (see also Wolf 1989 ). While both experience similar S Dor variations, some of the more luminous LBVs have also experienced giant eruptions such as those associated with \eta Car and P Cyg. The explanation of these giant eruptions has been the topic of several recent theoretical studies. (e.g. Owocki et al. 2017 , Owocki et al. 2019 , Owocki & Shaviv 2016 , and Davidson 2020 . Jiang et al. 2018 also studied the structure and stability of LBVs by means of 3D hydrodynamic simulations and suggested an explanation for fast low luminosity variations on a timescale of days. In this paper we concentrate on the S Dor variations that occur on timescales of years. The large variations in T_{\rm eff} at almost constant luminosity during S Dor variations indicate drastic variations in the effective radius of the stars, on timescales of years to decades. These variations can be as large as a factor of \sim 2 (R110, \mbox{$T_{\rm eff}$}= 7600-10300 K) to \sim 10 (AG Car, \mbox{$T_{\rm eff}$}= 9000-30000 K) with the more luminous LBVs showing the largest variations. These changes are not primarily due to variations in the mass-loss rate and the associated changes in the effective radius in the wind, because the observed changes in the mass-loss rate are not large enough ( de Koter et al. 1996 ; Vink & de Koter 2002 ; Smith et al. 2004 ) . They must therefore be due to large radius variations in the subphotospheric layers. Several mechanisms have been suggested to explain these episodic S Dor variations (see reviews by Vink 2012 and Davidson 2020 ). They are all based on dynamical instabilities of the sub-photospheric layers and a violent reaction of the atmosphere which is at the limit of stability against radiation pressure. The luminosity of LBVs is below the classical Eddington limit for radiation pressure by electron scattering, but the sub-photospheric envelope opacity is larger than the electron scattering opacity. If the star is close to the luminosity limit for electron scattering, any additional opacity in the envelope will bring the atmosphere close to the stability limit where \mbox{$g_{\rm rad}$}\simeq\mbox{$g_{\rm N}$} . This is called the “Modified Eddington Limit” (MEL; Appenzeller 1986 ; Lamers 1986 ; Davidson 1987 ; Davidson 2020 ). A small disturbance in the subphotospheric layers may then disrupt the delicate stability, and trigger the observed S Dor variations. In this respect, the iron opacity peak around a temperature of \sim 200000 K appears to play a key role. This suggestion is supported by the model of Grassitelli et al. 2021 that roughly explains both the timescale of the S Dor variations and the range of the observed luminosity changes. They calculated a time-dependent stellar evolution model for a non-rotating 100 M_{\odot} star near the Eddington limit, with sonic-point boundary conditions for wind models with mass-loss rates from Vink et al. 2001 and with a beta-velocity law with exponent unity ( Gräfener & Hamann 2008 ) and v_{\infty} = 2.6, or 1.3 times v_{\rm esc} at the hot and cool side of the bistability temperature of T_{\rm eff} = 21000 K ( Lamers et al. 1995 ) . The feedback of the mass loss on the envelope structure was taken into account. When the mass-loss rate increases above a critical limit due to the bistability jump, the opacity decreases and the extended envelope adjusts itself (shrinks) on the thermal timescale of the inflated envelope (years). This, in turn, leads to mass-loss variations that reverse the initial variations, resulting in a cycle that lacks a stationary equilibrium. Studies of the MEL by Ulmer & Fitzpatrick 1998 (hereafter UF98) have shown that the location in the HRD of LBVs during visual minimum (often called “quiesence”) coincides approximately with the location where the radiative accelation in their atmospheres reaches about 90% of their gravity if rotation is neglected. This strongly suggests that the S Dor variations are triggered when the effective gravity (i.e. corrected for radiation pressure in the atmosphere) is very low. A low effective gravity implies a high mass-loss rate which is an ingredient in the instability model of Grassitelli et al. 2021 . Observations of high rotation rates in LBVs (ranging from tens to hundreds of km s -1 , e.g. Davies et al. 2005 ; Groh et al. 2006 ) demonstrate that rotation effects must also play

Read the complete text